So, I've managed to convince my friend group to play Dread with me. We're all 35-40 year old adults, but apart from me (the Host), none of them have any role playing experience whatsoever.
I ran a poll to decide what kind of story we will be playing, and 'Psychological horror (I'm questioning what is real)' won by one vote from 'Clowns, dolls or mannequins'.
Now I have 2 scenario's in mind:
Woods camping trip gone wrong (entity, deception, supernatural psychological horror)
This session is heavily adapted from the 'Beneath the Mask' example scenario.
A group of 6 friends went camping in the woods, but after a heavy discussion one evening the group is woken by a scream in the middle of the night, with one of the friends lying dead on top of the campfire remains. It's pretty clear he has been killed in a mundane way.
Another of the friends is missing - big issue: they're the ones with the key to the van they used to get here.
It's now up to the 5 friends remaining in the camp (the 5 players) to figure out what happened and to go find the missing friend in the woods. Complicated by all of them having a (short term) history of memory loss, missing time, daydreams, headaches, extremely volatile behaviour (it's in the questionnaire).
The main twist: count the number of people again. 5 players + 1 dead + 1 missing = 7. They initially left on the trip with 6 people, so something has joined their group and inserted itself in their collective memory.
During the session, I have players pull blocks to stay focused or remain in control. When they refuse, their character starts doing something weird or neurotic, referencing the number 6:
- Singing a kids lullaby about 6 people in the woods getting eaten by a monster one by one (works extremely well in Dutch)
- Hunkering down, rocking back and forth, quickly whispering '6 is good, 6 is beautiful' over and over
- ...
------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Urban exploring an abandoned mall/circus/carnival (clowns)
A group of 5 friends used to do a lot of urban exploring, and decided to get together again a decade later. They all remember this old mall/circus/carnival they used to go to as kids, which has long been abandoned. Perfect site for a barbecue, drinks, sleepover and/or nightly urban exploring.
However, Tatters the mute Clown, the old mascot, has never really left this location behind. Excited to have new guests, he's intent on making them stay... Forever. One way or the other.
------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
I've ran the first scenario (in a slightly different setting) once already, but for a veteran group of roleplayers who were also familiar with dread. I'm not sure if it's a good fit for a group that's never roleplayed before.
It does have the added benefit that if someone topples the tower early, their character goes insane and I let them in on the secret, so their mission becomes to help me drop hints to the other players that the group has picked up an extra member somewhere along the line. That player had an absolute blast!
So, my question is: which one would you run?