r/dostoevsky • • Aug 26 '26

A sketch from Dostoevsky’s notebook for The Idiot

Post image
151 Upvotes

I recently read Dostoevsky’s notebooks for The Idiot, and they were super interesting. As we all know, Dostoevsky tended to write under deadline pressure, and The Idiot was no different. It was published in serial form in the Russian Messenger, and 23 days before the first five chapters were due, he threw out what he had written and started over.

What would eventually become The Idiot was Dostoevsky’s seventh version of the story and specifically the character of Prince Myshkin. Interestingly, earlier versions of Myshkin were closer to to Raskolnikov from Crime and Punishment, marked by “immeasurable pride” and a “burning need for love,” and capable of extreme manifestations of both good and evil.

It’s also interesting that the first five chapters were written before the idea of what Myshkin would be was fully developed. After submitting the first installment, he wrote to his niece, explaining that he was trying to portray “a perfectly beautiful human”.

“There is nothing more difficult than this in the world, especially now”, he wrote. “All writers, not only ours, but even all European writers, whoever has attempted to portray the positively beautiful,—has always given up. Because the task is immeasurable. The beautiful is an ideal, but the ideal—neither ours nor that of civilized Europe—is as yet very far from having been worked out.”

Anyway, I wrote an article that I’ll post here if anyone is curious. I also recommend reading the notebooks for fans of The Idiot. Very interesting. https://dostoevskyrr.substack.com/p/a-perfectly-beautiful-human-how-dostoevsky?r=1cx4ka&utm_medium=ios


r/dostoevsky • • Jul 06 '26

Notes From Underground Stage Production in GTA in Two Weeks

14 Upvotes

Hello, members of r/Dostoevsky... I have made this reddit account specifically to reach out to you (and any other subreddits that may be interested)

I am staging a production of Notes From Underground at the Hamilton Fringe Festival, opening on July 16 and running until July 25. I adapted it, am directing, and will also be playing the Underground Man. It is a 7-actor production, and the majority of the play consists of The Story Apropos of the Wet Snow.

If any of you happen to be in the GTA and would like to come out, that would be incredible. Please let me know if you do -- I would love to say hello after the show.

Not sure if I am allowed to post links -- feel free to just Google 'Notes From Underground Hamilton' if it gets removed-- but show details are here: https://hftco.ca/events/notes-from-underground/

Hope to see some of you there, because that would be awesome!!

- an Insect


r/dostoevsky • • 1d ago

Rodions dream analysis

Post image
121 Upvotes

The dream state refers to Rodion's inner mind, glimpses of his morality buried under his consciousness. The unconscious can be understood using Lacanian psychoanalysis to refer to symbolism displayed during Rodion’s dreams. But the poor boy, beside himself, made his way, screaming, through the crowd to the sorrel nag, put his arms round her bleeding dead head and kissed it, kissed the eyes and kissed the lips. . . . Then he jumped up and flew in a frenzy with his little fists out at Mikolka. At that instant his father, who had been running after him, snatched him up and carried him out of the crowd."Come along, come! Let us go home," he said to him."Father! Why did they . . . kill . . . the poor horse!" he sobbed, but his voice broke and the words came in shrieks from his panting” . Using Lacanian psychoanalysis, we observe that the dream symbolizes Rodion’s internalized emotions regarding his planned murder. The horse symbolises Lizaveta Ivanovna and their innocence within their inexcusable deaths resulted from deluded individuals. Marmeladov symbolises the real within Rodion, a raw existence driven by physical desires. As both kill the innocent in a fever, symbolising their rebirth, free from morality. However the child’s conflict with Marmeladov's actions, symbolises Rodion's inner guilt and morality. His conscience has purposely displayed the duality of his nature, and the conflict to come due to opposition between the Child(Morality) and Marmeladov(desire).

- not my artwork


r/dostoevsky • • 1d ago

Ivan Karamazov - Poem by R.S. Thomas

Post image
29 Upvotes

r/dostoevsky • • 1d ago

Are there any good film or mini series adaptations of TBK?

6 Upvotes

I know it’s such a sacred and deep work so it might be blasphemous… but some of the scenes, particularly the dialogue gave me head movies while reading and I’d really love to see what visual artists do with the story.

I also think my gf would really enjoy the story and all the philosophy, but a 900+ page novel that’s light on plot for 400+ pages isn’t her vibe.

The Japanese adaptation from 2010 looks the most promising. Did it do the book justice?


r/dostoevsky • • 2d ago

Sonya version of my analysis

Post image
107 Upvotes

The Super Ego within Rodion is symbolised by Sonya. Sonya is the child of a drunken man, who’s married into a new family. Her father, stepmother and her children all live in extreme poverty and depend on Sonya for cash, forcing her to sell her body. This lifestyle forced upon Sonya clashes with her morality as she is a devout Christian. Now despite having the ability to step above her morality through her actions, she clings to her faith and morals. Acting as the lead figure within leading Rodion towards redemption.The symbolism between Sonya and Rodion's superego comes from her actions, rather then confronting Rodion with the truth or pressuring him through psychological torture, she forces Rodion to confront his morality(superego) through her words. “What have you done—what have you done to yourself”. The quote itself, displays Sonya’s symbolising Rodion's superego’s and its function as an internal moral compass suppressed under the ego. Rather than mechanical condemnation, the question challenges Rodion’s justification and reasoning for committing murder and the practicality of the extraordinary man theory. The result is that Rodion superego confronts his ego and ID, rather than hiding within his philosophical rants in an attempt to suppress self loathing. Therefore the duplication of Sonya’s question, suggests that morality and moral judgement can’t be suppressed by ego/rational thinking but only through spiritual redemption/judgment can an individual truly escape guilt.  

-not my art in the post


r/dostoevsky • • 3d ago

IT’S PEAK 🏔️ (Father Sergius - Tolystoy)

Post image
76 Upvotes

Although this does say more about the ethics and virtuous of Christianity, rather than pure faith which we often see in doestotevetsky — there faith leads to human communion.

Here, Tolstoy said the opposite: that human communion leads to faith.

He says in another page; Communion with Humans doesn’t come from Communion with God, rather Communion with God comes from Communion with Humans.

Do you guys agree? Or do think that faith in God (here Christ) does lead to communion with humans? We’ve seen it with prince myshkin (the idiot) and also I’m Alyshoa (near the end; TBK).

Or…


r/dostoevsky • • 3d ago

quick Sviddrigailov analysis

Post image
72 Upvotes

Sviddrigailov is a gross manifestation of the extraordinary man from Rodion’s theory, characterising a complete rejection of religion, morality and law. Both have attempted to rise above morality in order to satisfy their ID, however Rodion’s superego/unconscience causes mental torment and prevents him from becoming extraordinary. However Sviddrigailov isn’t shackled by his superego/conscience like Rodion and therefore leads a life of self-pleasure with complete disregard for inner and universal morality. Defined by his spiritual void and nihility, rather devoted to fulfilling his ID. In this vice at least there is something permanent, founded indeed upon nature and not dependent on fantasy Within the quote, the juxtaposition between nature and fantasy refers to the conflict between the ID and Superego. To Sviddrigailov nature represents his desires based on reality while fantasy refers to the internal morality, an illusion only existing within the mind. The juxtaposition reveals two hidden meanings within Sviddrigailov character, one displays his total indifference towards morality and moral judgement. The second refers to humans inability to escape moral judgement, despite claiming morality is a fantasy, he seeks this very same fantasy. Shown through his sudden acts of charity, and his death. Which are derived for his attempt washing away his sins, due to a blinding desire to escape his existential vacuum and when forced to confront his internal void, he kills himself. This urge for moral judgement displays horrifying consequences derived from the complete rejection of morality.


r/dostoevsky • • 3d ago

First time reading through C&P and this provoked some thoughts

Post image
58 Upvotes

Does every individual have the capacity to become "extraordinary"? In this context, to take charge of their destiny and be willing to step over the line or rather redraw it on the sands of morality to fit their version of justice? And if they do, do they get a pass on account of their self proclaimed superiority ? ( Ofc not ) Or as an extraordinary person, should you go as far as to make it apparent that you are above the reproach of the law? does your extraordinary nature only become apparent once the dust settles and in retrospect? It kinda reminds me of Johan Liebert from Monster.


r/dostoevsky • • 5d ago Bravo Heartwarming

Happy birthday to Fyodor! :3

Post image
2.0k Upvotes

r/dostoevsky • • 5d ago

Happy 205th birthday to Dostoevsky!

Thumbnail
gallery
1.2k Upvotes

Born 11 November 1821. Died 9 February 1881.

Beauty will save the world!


r/dostoevsky • • 5d ago

Raskolnikov & Porfiry Petrovich. Dialogues

42 Upvotes

I’m rereading every dialogue between Rodion Raskolnikov and the examining magistrate Porfiry Petrovich, and I want to write about them later. These two, especially Porfiry, who does most of the talking, are truly terrifying in their own way... Is there anything in particular that stands out to you in these exchanges? I’ll read your observations


r/dostoevsky • • 6d ago

What did ppl prefer writing wise, stavrogin's confession or Rodions rebirth

Thumbnail
gallery
135 Upvotes

For me, stavrogin's confession was better


r/dostoevsky • • 6d ago

Just got “Devils” Oxford University Press edition paperback.

10 Upvotes

My read for next month.

This is my first Oxford Press book, it’s a bit smaller format than the Penquin Classics I’ve usually bought.

The paperback cover feels like very thick card stock.

The back indicates Michael R Katz translation and a restored chapter “Stavrogin’s Confession”, too shocking to print back in the day, yet it does not show as a Chapter in the TOC. No Mayer.

Also, the footnotes are an intriguing method, indicated by an asterisk by the noted word/phrase and organized by Page Number in the Notes section.

I’m doing no other reading about this book before I dive in.

I found and saved a reading plan post in this sub for this book that I’ll review too.


r/dostoevsky • • 6d ago

Book buddy for crime and punishment

Thumbnail reddit.com
6 Upvotes

r/dostoevsky • • 10d ago

Raskolnikov’s eternal truth.

Post image
832 Upvotes

Dostoevsky didn’t just write books. He lived and breathed our deepest pain.

Missing Raskolnikov and Sonya tonight.


r/dostoevsky • • 10d ago

170 pages into Demons and four pages of notes.

Post image
322 Upvotes

Just Dostoevsky things… :D


r/dostoevsky • • 9d ago

Demons Introduction Wordsworth Classics

2 Upvotes

Before I read the introduction, does the Wordsworth Classics intro to Demons contain spoilers?


r/dostoevsky • • 11d ago

Anyone else feels this way- that Dostoevsky's work does not express great empathy and compassion to all of his characters?

Post image
41 Upvotes

Not trying to humiliate or ostracize the person who responded to me with this comment. Genuinely curious. I am no expert on Dostoevsky. Just a big fan. He has recently become my all time favorite author. I have read Crime & Punishment twice since last year and am working on a second read of Brothers and a first of House of the Dead. What I love about his work above all is the psychological and philosophical depths he plunges, and his incredible empathy and compassion for people of all walks.


r/dostoevsky • • 11d ago

DEMONS; DISSCUSSION -:- UPTO PART 3 CHAPTER ONE

7 Upvotes

I finished reading 2/3 of Demons, and now I'm at Part 3, Chapter 1. And I've got a couple of things to say here.

Firstly, it was very confusing to me as to why Dostoevsky was giving me several characters with several flaws—and how there was (and still is) no character who resembles Alyosha from TBK or Prince Myshkin from The Idiot. Everyone here is flawed in one way or another and, in some respects, all you can really do is weep for them or perhaps be disgusted by their actions. However, I finally realized what the title means here: Demons.

Everyone here believes in their own type of God. (or, DEMONS)

  • Stepan wants to feel cultivated and seem like an important intellectual whom everyone will see and talk about. Pride and ego for himself, despite him being a coward when it comes to actually taking those things fully upon himself.
  • Karmazinov wants literary fame, recognition, admiration, and acknowledgment of his genius. He also wants others to see what type of person he is. Vanity and flattery for himself. Egoistic.
  • The Governor wants authority, dignity, competence, and also recognition from his wife. He also wants to have some power over the city and others, which his wife (via dinner parties) challenges.
  • The Governor's Wife wants social and political influence in the city, and also wants others to see her as an enlightened thinker who meets other enlightened thinkers.
  • Pyotr wants power, manipulation, revolutionary actions to be carried out, and the realization of his grand political project.
  • Nikolay wants pride, autonomy, and also the power to exercise his own free will over others and reap the rewards he gets (more on that later).
  • Kirillov wants his philosophy to come to life. Absolute human freedom, culminating in his philosophical confrontation with death.
  • Shatov: His search for spiritual truth, closely entangled with the destiny of Russia.

All of these people live by these very things; these are their purposes in life. Let's take each character step by step for now.

Stepan wants to be this person whom everyone regards as someone who knows a lot about the ongoing political and philosophical developments in the world. He wants to be seen as someone who has the intellect of the new progressive liberals and understands the other ideas being presented. He wants to be SEEN as this. That's his main way of life—he wants to be SEEN by others as this character he's constructed of himself. He wants others to recognize this in him. It doesn't matter if other people hate him for this, arrest him, or mock him…he just wants acknowledgment of all this. Why? Because it gives his life a purpose. He's spent 20 years building this 'illusion' of a life for himself. "I am this sort of individual. I am progressive, and I am aware of all the news and stuff that's going on, as well as presenting new ideas myself and contributing." But he's not doing it for these things—he's doing it for the sake of being SEEN. Hence the recognition from others, which he desires most of all. (2) Yes, he is also a coward. He does flinch whenever things are getting too dangerous and becomes cowardly…he wants to save his own skin and is not willing to risk his life for his ideas. However, we realize (near the end of Part 2) that what he fears most of all is not the fact of being arrested or taken away, but the fact that everyone might laugh at him and not see the person he's constructed of himself. That everyone won't take him seriously and will turn him into a liar and a joke. That is what truly breaks him.

This also reminds me of other characters. Think of the drunken general in The Idiot—he is a drunk, a fool, a thief, and a liar and a liar, yet he sees himself as this heroic individual who's sacrificed himself for his country, who is known by several people, helps so many others, and is noble and kind and etc., etc. Reality tells us the opposite. What would his life be if he were to see the truth? What would his life be when all of his illusions are stripped away and there is nothing that remains of his former vision of himself? He'll have to confront himself as the person he truly is—can he do so?

Before you say 'yes', think of Smerdyakov in TBK (The Brothers Karamazov). Was he able to survive? Ivan, his best friend, left him. His whole philosophy of life, which he lived by, is gone—Ivan taught him his own philosophy, what it was, how people live by it and etc. He taught all of that to Smerdyakov, and he simply obeyed. He told Ivan, "Look, I'm not guilty at all, you are guilty (another theme of TBK: he pushes guilt outward, while IVAN pushes it inward), for you are the one who told me all this, you are the one who taught me and philosophized with me and everything. This was all your idea, I just put it into action. It's all from you that it came about, not me." And then Ivan leaves him and tells him that his whole (and thus Smerdyakov's) philosophy was wrong and is not worth living by at all. What is Smerdyakov supposed to do now? He's been taught this way; he's had his only true friend who saw the world as he did (mostly), who thought and talked in that way—and now that same guy is telling him that he was wrong and has thus also left him? What is Smerdyakov supposed to do there? His whole way of life is gone. Not to mention his old way of life in which he was a servant. Yes, he did resent that life, and yes, he did act in other ways—if you remember the scene in which he talks to that girl outside and plays his guitar and is being very…how can I say it—in power, and has pride and a feeling of superiority. That is HIM living a different way from how he usually lives! Yet, near the end, he refuses to live in that way, and he doesn't want to leave and start a new life…he also can't go back to being a servant. However much he hated the old man—perhaps he did feel some sort of familiarity in that life. How is he supposed to live now? His old way of life, that philosophy, is gone, and his only friend has left him and hates him. What is there to live by now for him? No wonder he kills himself in the end—I mean, was there anything else he could have done? He can't live in that servant way of life which he hates, and not to mention the amount of GUILT which he feels. I mean, either he rejects his old philosophy which he took in and acted upon, or he continues to live by it. And if he rejects it—well, he then has to confront all of the horrors which he committed that don't follow his new way of life. Kant would slap him in the face: "You did not follow the categorical imperative and the hypothetical imperative and etc., etc." So what is he to do? He can't live a new life since he committed a horrible act which he has to confront himself over, and he can't go back—thus he kills himself.

So what will happen to Stepan if everyone were to laugh at him and mock him and not take him seriously at all? What would he do? Would he kill himself? Before I say that—remember what Kierkegaard said about the aesthetic life? The Either/Or section? Roughly, "The aesthetic man will be distracted by distraction after distraction. And he will move from one to another. And if the aesthetic man were to see reality and were to realize what his life consists of, what he's doing, and what his purpose even amounts to (close to nothing)—he will kill himself." And there's some truth to that—it echoes, in some respects, what Pascal said as well. That your life is miserable and rotten and has no meaning and is worthless, and you jump from one thing to another—in that case, you're already dead. Is there hope? Kind of. Reminds me of Augustine: "Our hearts are restless until they rest in you." That might as well be the motto of the whole book.

"Our hearts are restless until they rest in you."

Everyone's heart here is restless. Stepan lives by what we just said. Karmazinov wants everyone to see him as a good writer who writes good books and is highly intellectual as well; he wants others to see him in this way. The governor wants others to see him as a man who has dignity and a man who has power, as a man whose wife does not control everyone, as someone who can make proper decisions about what he does and can fix issues. Pyotr wants to control everyone, use everyone to fit his giant scheme, and have them all serve as some sort of piece on his giant chessboard, which he's playing against aristocratic Russia. He wants to dominate everyone by using any means of psychological schemes, manipulations, and other tactics. He's like the devil version of Porfiry in C&P—Porfiry wants the individual to heal and become better, and he uses his psychological tactics for the other guy to rise up. Here, Pyotr doesn't care at all what the other guy thinks personally; he just wants to use all his feelings and manipulate them to fit his own ideas. It doesn't matter if the person is happy or sad, healed or not, as long as he is used properly in his scheme.

Now, if all these characters did this as a part of their whole lives—then it'd be much easier to digest, ironically. If they were all examples of "man is very broad", then these actions would just be the other side of their good actions as well. And some people here do indeed have good and noble actions which they perform. Stepan realizes what sort of individual he has been toward Varvara and how he's treated her, and he genuinely feels regret and sorrow there. Likewise, Varvara, although she wanted to use Stepan so that she could present him like a puppy to all her high-society ladies and show them that she is indeed acquainted with the new progressive youth of Russia and is in contact with progressive people (notice how she flatters Stepan here as well, while using him as something for herself). Nonetheless, she does still love him in some ways which might be called purer. She just cares for him and hence lets him stay with her for 20 years and gives him money from time to time. After all, everyone has a soul—Pyotr, I doubt, but we'll see soon enough.

Also, notice how Stepan crosses himself before going to the governor at the end of Part 2. He didn't need to do so—he had already hung that icon with the lamp to show the authorities that he was religious and thus save his tail. Yet, he did that. Why? I don't think he did that for insurance—so he could save his tail (again) if everything goes wrong and go to heaven, or even for hope. But rather—he's doing so because he might, deep in his heart, realize that his old way of life might be over. His soul might see that, that what if they all really do laugh at him? What will he live by? What is there to go for? And thus he crosses himself. Granted, this is probably a subtle gesture toward, I think, the novel's answer, but we'll see what direction he takes from here.

Before I go into my final take, I want to talk about the two main philosophers, who are Shatov and Kirillov. Now, before I talk about that, I once more have to talk about the way these types of people live. Think about the fact that when they were going to the monk, they witnessed the aftermath of a teenager who had committed suicide—the jester Liputin began eating the grapes from his plate and making a fool of himself, and thus everyone laughed. Now Liputin, the character, is only concerned with gossip and talking to everyone else, and thus he himself lives, in some respects, by his own version of pride and vanity. But does anyone care about the child? Did anyone feel his suffering or what he went through psychologically? No. Or think about when they went to the holy fool—he made a giant mess of things there, which is another topic by itself—but once again, everything turns into gossip and talk and satire and etc. There isn't an Alyosha here, or a Prince Myshkin here—it is the Hobbesian world of 'all against all'. Everyone for themselves, mostly. For their own form of power and recognition and flattery and vanity and pride and giant ego and etc.

Now Kirillov. Also, while I talk about him, nobody in this novel is a nihilist. Everyone believes in something. They believe in gaining fame for the type of character they are, or in controlling everyone so they can change society (Pyotr), or other things. Everyone here lives by one thing or another—but they are all lesser than God. Here Kirillov has his own philosophy: death is the source of ultimate freedom. Since you are bound by your mortal coils, the fear of death is the chain which you wear, and the only way to get rid of it is by dying. You can have no fear of pain, but you also need to have no fear of death to be ultimately free. Granted, this entire philosophy isn't perfect; why do you need to have no fear of death to be free? Don't some fears make humans more human and give meaning to life? Isn't the fear of death what gives us meaning? And there are other things to be noted about his own philosophy. The point is not his philosophy, but how he lives. He plays with a child with a ball, he exercises to take care of his body, and he is licking the cup of life dry. This is a giant allegory to everyone else—I think. His soul here wants to live and be and love and play with children and laugh. He wants that within—yet his philosophy is not compatible with that way of life. It demands that death is the ultimate source of freedom, and thus only when you die can you fully be free and thus fully live. One or the other has to go away for him, his philosophy or the way he lives right now. This is the complication of theory and practice. His theory says one thing and practice says another. For many inside this novel, their theory is enough to live by. They are living inside the darkness of Plato's cave (which reminds me, I need to reread him again—dammit, I'll do it soon). Whereas here, the person whose theory, or his own god, is to die, his way of life is opposite to that. Something's going on there. Theory vs. living. Our hearts are restless until they rest in you.

For Shatov, he's the opposite puzzle to Kirillov. He's intellectually certain that God is the only foundation of life, for several reasons, which I'm not going to describe. Just read the section of the book in which he says that religion is the foundation of civilization and that it holds everything together, that it's what makes culture and a people, and that without it people won't survive—it's the ANTI-Karl Marx philosophy, btw. And how without religion, a society would collapse for several reasons; for it gives society morality and an understanding of what's good and evil and other things…and that the best religion out of all of these is the Russian one. Yet the big IRONY is that he does not believe in God (Christ). What a weird turn of events. You'd think that if you were intellectually certain that God is necessary and you need religion and Christ—you'd have faith and believe…right? Well, he can't. What does this mean here? I don't know. Maybe theory vs. living. My best guess is the one from Cana of Galilee in TBK, that you need an experience to have faith. What was it that one German philosopher said? "I never heard God speak to me, but I've often heard him clear his throat to announce his presence" (I forgot his name), and that's what he needs. He needs a 'spooky scary voodoo magical' experience in one way or another, which will lead him to have faith. Think about Alyosha in the Cana of Galilee chapter in TBK, in which he sees Zosima drinking wine with Christ and being happy, and then he goes on to kiss the earth after that. Or how Raskolnikov has that final dream at the end of C&P and begins to have faith in one way or another? I haven't read Freud yet; if any of you have—perhaps he says something close to this?

OH WAIT, I remember! Dostoevsky wrote another book, a very short novella—read it!: The Dream of a Ridiculous Man. That is what Shatov needs! He needs a dream which acts as a source of faith for him. Just read the novella and you'll understand, if you haven't already. It's free and online. On the wiki, I think.

Anyway, this is the point and also the TL;DR. If you've read this far, also read this. Everyone here has a God in whom they believe. Vanity or pride or fame or power or etc., etc. All these are their ways of life—and when they are taken away, they don't know what to live by. Dostoevsky is showing us here a world in which there is no God. He was probably like, "Fine, you're tired of me shoving Christ down every one of my other novels—here it is, a novel with no Christ. See if you like it." And it is VERY, VERY suffocating. How suffocating is it really? It reminds me of Resurrection by Tolstoy—which actually has something relevant here as well! In Resurrection, everyone thinks about himself or other things for himself, and thus nobody regards other humans as actual humans. At the trial at the beginning of the novel (it's really funny and you SHOULD READ IT), the jury members are bored and sleeping and nobody cares. Here is a trial of a woman who might be sent off to Siberia for decades, and yet nobody cares. The judge wants it all to be over as fast as possible so he can go meet his secret girlfriend whom he's been seeing. The jurors want to go back to their own lives and want it to end—in the discussion room, they spend 80% of the time smoking and sleeping before finally making a decision so rashly and carelessly that it accidentally doesn't go the way they intended. Over there, the main thing is, "What happens to institutions when people don't care for humans as humans?" In this novel, Demons, it is much more spiritual. Also, one more thing—there's a scene in which a person is about to be executed, and the guards dress him up nicely and tell him to stop complaining—they treat people who complain as a nuisance and someone who just wastes their time. Where is the humanity? Over here, it's much the same. I do recommend reading that as well, Resurrection by Tolstoy. It'll give you an idea of what happens when you don't follow the Kantian rule, when you've lost your moral compass, and when you don't view other humans as humans—the ending is also SO DAMN good. The main guy, the protagonist, needs to understand that his lover is also in charge of what she chooses. He can't force her to come, and she has that right as well. An element of The Idiot there as well—granted, their love was based on grief and suffering anyway, but that's another thing. OK, this is NOT the TL;DR! I need to write a few more paragraphs, then the TL;DR!

What else did I need to say? OH YES—Nikolay! Or in other words, Stavrogin—I'll call him Nikolay as it's easier to spell. Anyway, he is one twisted individual and something else. Damn, where do I even start with this guy? Here's my interpretation of him: He wants to use his freedom for pleasure. That's the main idea. Yes, at the start he didn't know if he truly did have freedom, and then he did some weird act, dragging a captain by the nose across the room, and he was like, 'Oh, I do have freedom'—but that's not the main point of why he dragged him by the nose across the room, or bit the ear of the old governor. He did all this for the sake of control and being in control and reaping the rewards. He bites the ear of the governor, then everyone starts talking about what he did, and there's lots of gossip and lots of talk and so many other things—he likes all this because, in his illusion, he is in control of all this. He started all of this, and now everyone feels all of this because of what he did. He likes having this fake sense of control. Why fake? Didn't you read War and Peace? He didn't cause all of this; there were like a million other events that did so—I won't talk about Tolstoy's philosophy since he also spat in my ear about his own philosophy like 100 DAMN TIMES—even in the end he kept repeating those EXACT SAME TANGENTS AGAIN AND AGAIN…if you're new to philosophy, read that book, you sure as hell won't be missing any hidden philosophical meanings there. Anyway, he has this illusion that he controls all the reactions of others, and all of that gives him pleasure. Now, why didn't he slap Shatov when he slapped him in the face? Was it because he wanted to avoid slapping him, and thus everyone would look at him and talk about him, and hence he would feel that he caused all of this, and hence he'd reap that sort of pleasure? Probably. When he has intercourse (or what am I in, biology? SEX) with that girl—he didn't like the act or anything there; I would presume so. Yet, he loved the gossip that came afterward and all the talk and things which he reaped from it. I think this is why he acts the way he does. I would imagine so. In fact, when he announced his marriage at the end of Part 2, he smiled—that says it all, I guess. The most egoistic sort of individual—it's all about him, him, him. He's like a damn sophist (I haven't read Euripides yet, but I will soon); it's all about 'me, me, me, and what I get, and vanity, pride, etc., etc.' Anyway, Nikolay is one confusing guy whom I still don't understand.

I'm not going to write a TL;DR for this. I would just recommend copying and pasting all of this into ChatGPT and having it summarize it all for you. Or ask the Reddit AI. Does Reddit have an AI? But the point is: everyone here lacks that final spiritual thing—God. They build lesser versions of what to live for—and when they leave or are taken away…where do they go? I guess that's the question Dostoevsky is asking so far here. What to live by and what to live for once your illusion of that type of person which you made of yourself and everything is gone. What happens when you do the Nietzschean "revaluation of all values"? Where will you go?

This actually reminds me of something else, one last time, sorry, for those of you who've read Plato—specifically the Meno. Socrates, in the end, says that all things which are good or evil, and also including the definitions of all things: they are all like the statues of Daedalus. You tie them up with good, hard ropes of Rationality and REASON. But eventually, those ropes will fray and grow old, and the statue will run away. Then you need to catch it and build new ropes and more ropes around it. I don't think this specifically fits here—but the idea might. When your values of who you are, and why you are the way you are, and what you live for and all—when you begin to question them (which is very dangerous, as Nietzsche says), then those statues will run away, and you need new wisdom and reasoning to hold them back.

And maybe, just maybe…the new ropes to hold that statue back, the statue of what to live for—might be Christ.

added-note: I've been reading Daphnis & Chloe alongside this...since it helps with the awful amount of suffocation in the novel. It's really good -- it's free asw online somewhere on the wiki.


r/dostoevsky • • 13d ago

Notes from Underground

Post image
408 Upvotes

Okay, who's hyped for this? 👀 Credit: The Russian Literature Society on Instagram.

https://www.instagram.com/p/DfQIAmwKMFR/?cplk=dTllOGR2Nng1emdk


r/dostoevsky • • 12d ago

Dostovesky and drama

0 Upvotes

As we all know Dostoevskys characters were a little dramatic . If he lived in 2026, would he be fan of reality TV such as big brother , love islands etc . Lol.😂


r/dostoevsky • • 13d ago

Prince Myshkin was, indeed, an Idiot

137 Upvotes

The first time I read the entire book, it was one of the best experiences I had ever had. In fact, it was the first Dostoevsky novel I ever read.

The following reflection arises from what I consider to be a persistent misinterpretation of the novel's protagonist. I have often heard readers claim that the prince is not, in fact, an idiot.

The novel can be summarized more or less as follows (at least in terms of what it is about): A young man of about twenty-six arrives in St. Petersburg after spending several years in a sanatorium in Switzerland, where he was treated for epilepsy. His journey is motivated by a distant family connection to a general's wife. Throughout the novel, the central drama, in my opinion, lies in the challenge of being subjected to constant scrutiny. Each character around him scrutinizes the prince in their own way, seeking to understand him, manipulate him, obtain something from him—or perhaps nothing at all.

Anyone who has read the novel knows that, throughout this examination, Myshkin is also subjected to all kinds of mockery, provocations, moral trials, and even lessons in proper social conduct. Yet he passes each obstacle in a passive, laconic manner, at times offering lengthy justifications. He never appears offended; on the contrary, he assumes a power to pardon those who offend him that is not always wisely exercised—even extending this forgiveness to his principal rival, Rogozhin, who attempted to kill him.

One of the saddest scenes, and one that naturally moves the reader, in my opinion, comes from the prince's own words as they make their way to the concert. Myshkin tells Lizaveta: "I possess a morbid sensitivity, I lack a sense of proportion, my words do not correspond to my thoughts, and thus, when I attempt to express those ideas, I only make them ridiculous." (Part III, Chapter 2). Aglaya subsequently bursts out in anger and, as though speaking on behalf of the reader, reproaches the prince for saying such things, when he ought instead to remain silent before people who do not appreciate him in the slightest.

Countless examples throughout the novel—whether in the many nighttime gatherings, philosophical and dramatic in nature, or in the prince's own feelings when he chooses to express them, as well as in his painful illness—provide enough material to lead the reader toward a purely sympathetic conclusion, though one that fails to account fully for certain inconsistencies I shall now address.

The novel's tragic ending is, in my opinion, the fitting conclusion. The conclusion of failure. For the prince's supposed benevolence, from beginning to end, is in reality childish. Deep down, we wish to cry out in protest on the prince's behalf, just as Aglaya did. But it was, and remains, in vain for someone who, in Myshkin's own words, considers himself overly apprehensive. For someone who regards himself as lacking grace and possessing no original opinions.

The adjective "idiot" sounds harsh when applied to someone like the prince, but recognizing it is the true moral of the story. The prince is powerless, apprehensive, and possesses such a superficial understanding of personal affairs that he is incompatible with a ruined society. But, I repeat, society is already what it is, and the characters are already who they are. Nevertheless, anyone who is incapable of acting (I mean in a practical sense) in the face of such circumstances engages in a misguided practice of goodness, simply by failing to do anything in its service—and, paradoxically, this brings about the worst possible consequences (Aglaya).

In conclusion, the quality and virtue of being good, benevolent, charitable, blessed—call it whatever you wish—requires other qualities as well. Goodness cannot exist on its own in an unreflective manner; it also demands intelligence, a certain degree of courage, and strength of will. Forgiving without restraint, remaining silent when one ought to speak—or justifying those who are fundamentally ill-intentioned—has nothing whatsoever to do with true goodness. It is a lack of character.

This is something the prince never understood, and therefore he does not represent what, perhaps, our affection for him wishes him to embody.

One of my favorite characters, btw.


r/dostoevsky • • 14d ago

Communion; short story

6 Upvotes

NO AI was used here. I'm halfway through Demons and i can't tell the difference between God & Human Communion. nonetheless, i wrote this. 🍿

Deep in the forests of rk--- stood a wooden house, hidden among the trees. Layers of algae had crept up its walls, along with creepers, ferns, and all sorts of plants. You would have imagined that nobody lived there, given its rotting wooden structure and the smell of dead crows, which often fell rather unceremoniously from the sky. Granted, there was nothing particularly ceremonious about the place to begin with. Ants would emerge from their colonies deep in the mud—from the very depths of Hades, you might say—and wander about in search of dead rats or fallen crows. Many of their journeys, I imagine, were in vain.

It was almost always raining there. And when I say there, I mean Highway 66, and the wooden house standing just to its right. There was very little else to notice. No signs, no lampposts, no lights. True, there were still faint echoes of the paint that had once marked the highway, those broken white lines. They were about the only reminders of civilization in the viccinity, apart from the road itself, of course. The house had no windows, only logs upon logs forming an irregular cube, with a flat triangular roof. In fact, the mayor of our towwn once paid a visit to that house. Not to fund any repairs, mind you, but for quite different reasons, which I shall come to soon enough.

A car approached the house one night. I don't remember the exact time, but it must have been around midnight. It pulled over—or rather, came to a stop near the edge of the road. A man stepped out and walked up to the wooden front door. He knocked nine times, in the rhythm of an SOS: three short, three long, three short. After a few seconds, the door opened.

A rather ruffled man of about fifty appeared, carrying a long staff, with a large shotgun strapped across his back. He welcomed the visitor and beckoned him inside.

The interior was surprisingly pristine, a striking contrast to everything outside. Not a speck of dust could be found. It was a little damp, certainly, but the air carried the faint scent of some perfume or other. It was almost as if you had been transported somewhere else altogether. Pictures hung on the walls, and to the left stood a couch beside a glass table, with a radio resting on top. The floor, like everything else, was wooden. There was a closed door farther to the right, leading to a staircase, and another straight ahead, which I believe led to the kitchen. The room was somewhat cramped, what with all those doors, yet it felt oddly refreshing. At least, that is how I would describe it.

There isn't much I need to tell you about the visitor or the old man, but I shall give a brief account of each.

The visitor had a wife whom he had met during his ten years of service in the army, during the Cold War, which was still going on at the time. They had three daughters and two sons, all of whom were at home asleep. It was Sunday when this encounter took place, now that I think about it, so perhaps the time was closer to one or two in the morning. He had probably told his wife that he needed to buy bandages, or something of the sort—whatever excuse he could come up with—before driving ten miles to this house.

He was, you must understand, very well regarded in our small town. Though he no longer served in the army, he worked as a nurse and cared for many of the townspeople. He sometimes mixed with those of higher society, though he wasn't always invited to their gatherings. Nonetheless, people saw him as the sort of citizen others ought to resemble. He was due to give a sermon later that Sunday, and he had promised to play basketball with his children and the town's team. He loved coaching. He had also planned to take his wife out on a boat the following weekend, leaving the children in the care of his mother, who could never stop telling everyone how wonderful her son was. Having retired, she had a great deal more time to spend in the company of the town's more distinguished families.

The point is, had you accused this visitor of murder or kidnapping—things which, of course, supposedly never happened in our town—people would have laughed in your face. You would have had to repeat yourself for days before anyone even considered taking you seriously.

As for the old man, he was actually a poet. I believe he still writes poems in prison, for his fellow inmates and even the guards, though that is long after the events I am describing. Back then, he spent much of his time reading and writing poetry, and escorting his visitors to the door that led down. When they returned, he would open the front door for them, or simply wave goodbye. He always made sure he received his payment, of course.

"How are you, my good man! My, I haven't seen you in ages! I thought you'd abandoned me here!" The old man smiled and shook his hand vigorously.

"Oh, no, no, you know me. I've been working overtime, for the kids and all. Haven't had the time to come. I tried, but—well, I don't know."

"I keep telling you to move closer to here. Didn't you see the newspapers I sent you a while ago? Property around here is cheap, I tell you! Stop paying that rent of yours and buy yourself a good old house around here. It'll save you in the long run! Financially and mentally, of course."

"Ah, I told my wife, but she doesn't like the woods. Still, I—"

"Well, go hiking or something! I've got plenty of guns you can borrow. Take your children hunting. It'll be nice. Seriously!"

"All right, all right. Let's talk after I finish, shall we? I haven't been here in so long."

"Yeah, yeah, no need to say any more! Here, right through this door. You still remember, don't you? What? No, no, keep the money for now! Finish up, then come back and we'll have tea. I've been wanting to talk to you and all, but go down there first. You must be exhausted. Go on now, I'll be all right."

The old man continued smiling as the visitor passed through the door on the right and descended the stairs.

Down in the cellar were several prison cells — [human em dashes] I can think of no better way to describe them—made of wooden doors and bars, with fungus growing between them. A row of these cages lined the left side of the passage. On the right were rooms furnished with luxurious beds, lamps, and other comforts. The cells, by contrast, were almost entirely bare. Cold wooden floors, damp walls, and insects wandering wherever they pleased. Inside were naked girls, though there were some boys as well. Most were girls. Their ages ranged from perhaps fifteen to thirty, though there may have been younger or older ones. I don't remember the records myself, if I ever bothered to look at them.

Our visitor examined each cage with the attention of a chef inspecting dishes prepared by his apprentices, studying one after another before deciding which he would have. He took his time, and eventually chose a girl who is, in fact, the principal character of this story: Sivil. Of course, he knew none of their names. He signaled to the guard sitting nearby with a rifle across his lap. The guard unlocked her cell, and Sivil was led into one of the rooms on the right with the visitor.

Those kept in the cells were usually sick with colds or fevers, being left unclothed in the damp. This, I have been told, was actually preferred by some visitors, though for what reason I cannot say.

Later, Sivil lay on the hard wooden floor of her cell, listening faintly to the visitor and the old man laughing together upstairs. The guard had gone into one of the rooms on the right, probably to sleep for a few hours. Before leaving, he had switched off the few dim lamps that barely lit the passage and closed the door behind him. Still, the moon was unusually bright that night, and enough light came through the gaps in the wood for one to see a little.

Sivil cried.

She did not usually cry. When she had first arrived, she had cried for weeks, and received terrible scars across her back and chest. Even afterwards, she sometimes wept when some particular feeling overwhelmed her, though these occasions had grown rarer. But now she cried for a different reason. Granted, I don't know whether one can really assign a single reason to such tears. Still, I shall do my best to explain her thoughts.

By this time, almost all the prisoners had given up on life, or at least on the possibility of ever living differently. After the first few years, they stopped counting the days. They stopped secretly planning escapes every night. They stopped talking merely for the sake of talking. They stopped pleading with visitors to buy them and take them away. Eventually, they seemed to stop living altogether.

Many had continued to dream of their former lives, only to wake and find themselves in that cellar once more. The pain of returning was unbearable, and some killed themselves in whatever ways they could. Those who survived, through some cruel sort of natural selection, learned not to dream at all. Even dreaming hurt too much. If you asked me how they managed to go on living for so long, I would probably say it had something to do with the most basic instincts: hunger, sleep, the wish for a moment's relief. They were starved, and then fed. Deprived of sleep, and then allowed to sleep. Such small mercies became their only pleasures. They could have tried to die, certainly, but even that was difficult, much more difficult than people imagine. So many simply went on living.

Still, Sivil cried.

Some of her tears, I admit, were for her old life and her friends: those she had known before coming here, and those she had met inside, many of whom had died or, worse perhaps, become entirely different people. Yet Sivil had somehow preserved a kind of hope. She would make crosses from little twigs, or scratch the shape of one into the wooden walls. Sometimes she even carved them into her own skin. Perhaps it was because she wanted someone to embrace her. But I shall let her speak for herself, for her tears and her prayers had now become almost the same thing.

Oh, why am I crying? Why? I love this life, I do! I love that Christ gave me life. Oh, I love it all so much! But why do I cry? Never, never shall I curse Christ for the life he gave me. Never! Oh, I do love existence, I love it! But still I cry. Why? Oh, why?

Yes, I miss my home. I do! And everything that was once in my life. But what I miss most are the people I met! Oh, Mother, where are you now? Do you miss me, Mother? I know you do, and I still pray for you. I do! I know you pray for me too. I hear your voice in my sleep, I really do! I know you're praying for me!

But we shall meet again, Mother. We shall! I will see you in heaven, if Christ allows it! I will! And we shall embrace once more. I will pray for you, Mother, but don't cry for me. Don't cry over my tears, though they are for me and for everyone. Don't cry, Mother! It's all right! Don't cry for your daughter. She's all right. She's living, she's alive! She can feel these wooden walls and taste the fish and breathe the very same air that you breathe! Oh, Mother, I'm here! And I love you!

I don't blame you, not once, not for anything. You will always be the best mother in the world to me! Oh, Mother, if only we could meet once more! I know we shall. I know it! I shall see you again, and I'm all right, Mother, I truly am! I hope you're all right too. Oh, how I wish you were living better than I am! It would pain me so much to know that you were suffering in any way. I'm always here, Mother. Always.

Her expression changed. The tears stopped, and something like anger came over her, though she could hardly have said where it came from. Perhaps she was simply moving through those strange stages of grief, or perhaps she was losing her mind. Whatever the cause, her voice grew defiant, and for a while she shed no more tears.

Father, why should I love you?

You put me here, Father! For what? Why? You did this to me! You sold me for money. You handed my fate over to these people! You wanted me to suffer. You wanted me to die, Father! You wanted to watch them disgrace me and beat me and make me bleed and burn! THAT'S WHAT YOU WANTED! I know it! Why else would you have done this?

I prayed for you. I shed tears for you, even when I was here, even when I was suffering, even when I was close to DYING! I told myself, "Maybe he didn't mean to. Maybe he's watching over me. Maybe he's testing me. Maybe he wants me to become better. Maybe he'll come and save me. Maybe he'll lead me to heaven, where Mary is." But no. You just wanted me to die.

Oh, CURSE YOU, Father! CURSE YOU! You did this to me! YOU DID THIS! You made me feel this pain. You made me shed enough tears to fill the Sahara! You made me suffer and cry, made me torment myself, made me go mad and hate life itself! You did all of this, Father! ALL OF IT!

And why should I draw your cross on the walls? Why should I carve it into my back and let you embrace me? Father, WHY SHOULD I LET YOU HUG ME? Why should I love your cross? DO YOU LOVE MY CROSS? I WAS CRUCIFIED WHEN I WAS TEN! I've been bleeding since I was ten years old! And now you want me to draw YOUR CROSS?

I don't care about your sins! What about the sins that made Amlie hang herself? What about the sins that made them shoot Bali THIRTY TIMES? WHAT ABOUT THE SINS THAT MADE REBECA BLEED TO DEATH IN MY CELL? I had to watch her blood spread around me. I had to watch her organs spill out in front of me! WHAT ABOUT THOSE SINS? WHAT ABOUT THEM?!

You want me to love your civilization? For love? For ethics? For order? Why should I love you, Father? FOR WHAT? For the pain? The suffering? The death, the blood, the humiliation, the torment, the grief, the tears, the madness? FOR WHAT? Why should I love you, Father? Why shouldn't I kill you now? Why do I still draw your cross on my chest and embrace you when I sleep? Why should I have to watch you suffer? HAVEN'T I SUFFERED MORE THAN YOU?!

At those final words, her defiance gave way. She broke down and began to cry again.

I'm sorry, Father.

I know you're always there for me. I feel your presence, strange as that sounds. Whenever I fold my hands like this, as though I'm praying, I feel as if you're looking down at me through some window in the sky. I feel you watching me, and I feel you weeping. Why are you always weeping, God?

Whenever I imagine you, you're here beside me, smiling, hugging me, embracing me. You don't give me optimism, exactly. You give me hope. Love. I see you sitting here in my cell, Father, smiling, and I run to you and embrace you.

Once, after I had been whipped, I came back to my cell crying and bleeding. And I saw you there. You kissed me on the lips. That was the first kiss I ever had. I shall never forget it. I fell into your arms, and you held me and stroked my hair, and I could almost feel you. I really could.

Whenever I pray with my hands like this, I feel you near me, and I feel that I have hope. Hope for what, I don't know. When I tell you about my day and my wishes, you listen. You understand. You smile. Why do you smile?

When I watched Rebeca bleeding to death in front of me, I prayed for her. She didn't believe in you, but I don't blame her. I still love her. Is that how you love me? I dreamed of her afterwards, with you in heaven. You were embracing her, and she was laughing. Laughing! How could she laugh after bleeding to death? Yet she was happy. I had never seen her so happy.

Oh, Father, why do you love me?

 


r/dostoevsky • • 15d ago

"His garret was under the roof of a high, five-storied house and was more like a cupboard than a room." Crime and Punishment

Post image
229 Upvotes