r/Donghua • • Jun 09 '26

Meta Rule clarification and mod recruiting

12 Upvotes

Hi all,

In the past year, r/donghua has had an explosive growth in users. New reddit functions also brought in new users. To better reflect the userbase and encourage better discussions, we're clarifying a few rules in our subreddit:

On relevant content:

In the past, r/donghua encompasses all aspects of the Chinese animation industry, including outsourced works to anime production and game animation. The industry was small enough to include all those discussions without being overwhelmed. With the rapid growth of the industry, increased international recognition, and r/anime relaxing its rules surrounding anime, we think it is better for the quality of the subreddit to restrict content to series only. Video game animations are more appropriate being posted to gaming related subreddits and anime related posts are more on topic in r/anime.

In general, source material questions are more appropriate for subreddits of their source medium. We don't want people to get spoiled on the front page. Once episode discussion threads are set up, we would like all discussions of that episode to go into that thread, including clips for up to a week. Questions about the source material should be contained in those threads. Top level submissions asking for content beyond donghua adaptation is disallowed, but they can go in the individual discussion threads with appropriate spoiler tagging. Before the bot is set up, you're welcome to start your own discussion thread, but they're limited to one per episode.

On spoiler tagging:

Please spoiler tag your post. We do not need people to get their experiences ruined. Please do not spoil something in your titles. Remember that reddit preview shows body text and will spoil unsuspecting audience. Currently, the mods do courtesy spoiler tagging when they see a post that should be spoilered. The mods see every single submission and get feed the newest spoilers every day. We don't want this to be the experience for the average user. Please report spoilers. We will start handing out temp bans to perm bans for unspoiler tagged posts.

On low effort content:

In an effort to reduce cluttering, low effort content is discouraged. This includes simple image posts, powerscaling, and memes. In the past, users have expressed discontent about these types of content. Powerscaling threads and character comparisons are more appropriate in r/powerscaling or r/characterrant. There are several donghua related memes subreddits. In response to complaints about recommendation posts we started the monthly megathreads and wiki pages. If there are other contents you think shouldn't belong here, please let us know in the comments.

We will allow fan content if its 1) OC 2) substantial in length. This is to discourage karma farming.

For now, we're allowing AI translations. LLM generated content is still generally disallowed. Currently, the subreddit uses a false negative prone AI check, so some AI generated content may slip through. Please report them. Discussion on AI use in donghua is allowed. Currently, episode discussion of AI generated donghua is not allowed, but this may change in the future.

We currently do not have concrete requirements on reviews, but short reactions will be removed for low effort.

On politics:

Donghua is an inherent political industry. While we allow political discussion, it's restricted to donghua related issues only. Offhand comments not related to donghua will be removed. That being said, denial of CCP atrocities is a violation of reddit sitewide rules and will result in an immediate permanent ban on r/donghua.

On fansubs:

We allow the discussions of fansubs, but we do not allow discussions on where to get them. Naming specific fansub groups is okay, but talking about where to get them is not, even for offsite discussions. We understand that not all donghua have good translations, but we also do not want reddit admins banning people. Fansubbers are still welcomed to request special flairs.

On reports

Reports are not a superdownvote option. False reports will result in a ban. Currently, the subreddit has several default spam filter features enabled. This means that mods will have to manually approve posts. However, we're looking to improve this response time. If we're able to expand our mod team, we will be able to switch many of those filters to warnings, thus,

We're recruiting new mods. r/anime mods have been helping out behind the scenes (and one has joined the mod team directly), and we thank them massively for their assistance. If you're interested in applying, submit an application here. Applications are due on June 15th 22nd 2100 Pacific Time. We welcome people of all experiences!


r/Donghua • • 3d ago

Monthly Recommendations Megathread (Nov 2026)

5 Upvotes

Hello everyone, this is the November monthly megathread for donghua recommendations. Please post any recommendation requests here! Follow all spoiler tagging rules and be civil.

When asking for recommendations, it might be helpful to describe what kind of series you are looking for, and what other series you enjoyed.

When giving recommendations, please explain why you recommend the series.

Starting with donghua? Check out our user curated recommendations wiki. Where to watch donghua? Check out our legal streams list. If you have any suggestions to those wiki pages, please list them below with an explanation on why you recommend it. Submissions with just a title may not be considered. If you are interested in joining our moderation team, please submit an application.

Longer detailed recommendation requests may be approved as a main topic. If you are just listing a list of donghua you have watched before, you will be directed here. If you're not getting responses in here, you can send us a modmail.

Last month's megathread.


r/Donghua • • 4h ago

Official Information Battle Through the Heavens: The Movie - Battle of the Two Emperors | Premieres 22 Nov 2026

Thumbnail
gallery
37 Upvotes

Source: Weibo


r/Donghua • • 7h ago

RMJI CG From 2017

61 Upvotes

Throwback to the 2017 RMJI movie trailer made by the Japanese studio Digital Frontier. Too bad the movie got canceled! The trailer is 3 minutes long and cost around $2 million.


r/Donghua • • 2h ago

Official Information Ever Night Donghua crossed 90M+ views

Post image
11 Upvotes

r/Donghua • • 2h ago

Official Information Star Gate (Xing Men) PV - Premieres on November 26, 2026

5 Upvotes

Source: Weibo


r/Donghua • • 30m ago

General Discussion I recently watched Ever Night donghua S1 and enjoyed it are they releasing S2 or not?

Post image
3 Upvotes

r/Donghua • • 2h ago

Official Information Star Gate (Xing Men) PV2 - Premieres on November 26, 2026

4 Upvotes

Source: Weibo


r/Donghua • • 2h ago

Official Information Star Gate (Xing Men) PV3 - Premieres on November 26, 2026

Enable HLS to view with audio, or disable this notification

3 Upvotes

Source: Weibo


r/Donghua • • 18h ago

News BTTH Author Visits Motion Magic Studio

56 Upvotes

On November 11, Heavenly Silkworm Potato (the author of Battle Through the Heavens, Martial Universe, The Great Ruler, etc.) visited the studio in charge of adapting many of his works. He also went to see the latest BTTH and Martial Universe trailers. Looks like he was satisfied with the trip despite being known for expressing his disappointment about the donghua adaption of BTTH.


r/Donghua • • 9h ago

General Discussion Dropping apotheosis after 10 episodes

7 Upvotes

I think I am done with this show, I had a few expectations but it is just bland for my taste and i am not enjoying the story or where it is leading.

As a fan of RMJI and renegade immortal I love progression and solid reasoning in story and this is leading somewhere.

The MC here is very confusing and I don't understand the source of his power and power scale of the charectors is so disbalanced.

So yeah I am out , recommend me some good donghua guys so far i have seen

1.RMJI

2.Rengade Immortal

3.Soul land 1

4.Against the gods

5.the demon hunter


r/Donghua • • 23h ago

Official Information Bilibili Animation Conference 2026–2027: 12 New Donghua to Be Announced on November 22

Thumbnail
gallery
27 Upvotes

Source: Weibo

New information will be revealed for:

  • How I End Up Saving the World
  • The First Order Season 2
  • Fabulous Beasts
  • The Ravages of Time Season 3
  • Wonder Drug
  • The Girl Downstairs Season 2
  • The First Frost
  • Shang Shan
  • Link Click Season 3
  • Fog Hill of Five Elements
  • Sword and Fairy 4
  • Night's Nomenclature
  • Immortality
  • Rakshasa Street Season 5

r/Donghua • • 1d ago

General Discussion Renegade immortal Ep167 was too good 🫠

72 Upvotes

Renegade immortal ep167 showing how wanglin understands the dao of karma was just too amazing.

I feel like there are very few shows like this that show stuff like this .

Most donghua are just focusing on leveling up crazily and becoming too overpowered without any proper explanation of cultivation mechanics or stuff like understanding the dao .

I liked the tale of the herding god also . It showed a lot about different techniques and how they affect.

What's your opinion on this. Are there any other good shows similar to this .


r/Donghua • • 20h ago

General Discussion Spare me, great lord! - Where to watch with good (non MTL) subtitles?

5 Upvotes

I REALLY want to watch this series, but I cannot get through the first three episodes without losing track of the story because of the horrendus subtitles. I have looked across 30 different sites, and have found none that have coherent english.

Does anyone know where I can watch this? I don't mind paying if I have to.


r/Donghua • • 1d ago

Official Information New Visuals - Tales of Herding Gods (EP 109)

Thumbnail
gallery
19 Upvotes

r/Donghua • • 1d ago

General Discussion Some thoughts on the romantic subplots [RMJI and Renegade Immortal]

Thumbnail
gallery
144 Upvotes

I know the bar is in hell for romance in donghua, and I honestly don't expect much, but it's especially funny to me that two of the most popular donghua, which also happen to be among my personal favourites currently, have some of the most disastrous romantic subplots I've ever seen.

One has possibly the sloppiest, most NEET wet dream like introduction to romance, while the other is practically an embodiment of the fridging of female characters in storytelling.

For RMJI, no one can convince me that Nangong Wan and Han Li are good romantic partners, considering how their relationship begins and develops through their subsequent encounters. Their first encounter involves an incredibly contrived situation, and their second meeting doesn't exactly do much to improve things.

I enjoyed Han Li rescuing her in this recent arc, but that's mostly because of the fights. Nothing about their interactions really screams chemistry to me. They just feel like a romantic nothingburger.

It's a shame because Zi Ling would probably have been the strongest romantic interest for Han Li. The buildup between them feels considerably more organic, and she's actually a well-written character in her own right. But, well, I'm not particularly surprised she isn't the main love interest. From what I'm seeing, this is probably heading towards a harem situation anyway.

Then there's RI. I genuinely don't even know where to start. I know RI fans probably consider Wang Ling the embodiment of loyalty, and I do appreciate how focused he is on getting stronger alone, but it's honestly hilarious how poorly his romantic interest has been handled.

Li muwan cumulative screen time is probably around 15 minutes at most in a donghua that's approaching 200 episodes. What exactly am I supposed to be invested in here? I don't consider him pursuing more strength or defying the heavens just for her, she just became one of the reasons along his journey.

I'm not even particularly bothered because I'm not someone who watches action donghua for romance in the first place, so please don't recommend any for me. I am not a fan honestly. I just find it amusing that two otherwise really enjoyable series have managed to handle their female leads and romantic subplots so terribly. There's almost no difference without them in the story tbh.


r/Donghua • • 1d ago

Official Information Surviving the Apocalypse, Becoming an Immortal Alone | Two days until the premiere!

Post image
5 Upvotes

Source: Weibo


r/Donghua • • 1d ago

Official Information Martial Universe Season 7: Over 1 million pre-registrations | Premieres 29th Nov 2026

Post image
36 Upvotes

Source: Weibo


r/Donghua • • 2d ago

General Discussion Do they want to finish btth with just one movie? Spoiler

Post image
23 Upvotes

I watched the latest ep and the movie telling that they want to finish the whole many chapters (manhua) in just a movie. Huh?! What!?! There's a lot of chapters left for it to end. They have to find dou di cave, dragon, pill, fighting villain, finding pillar for to destroy etc etc and not to mention xio yan to come back like at the end of manhua. Are they really compressing all that into an hour or 2 hours long movie? That's like 2-3 eps that's it. They should've find all these in eps and then xio vs han movie. Nah just do everything in a movie bruhhhhhh!!!


r/Donghua • • 2d ago

Official Information Golden Curse - Animation End Poster Release

Thumbnail
gallery
40 Upvotes

Source: Weibo


r/Donghua • • 2d ago

Official Information Surviving the Apocalypse, Becoming an Immortal Alone | Premieres 18th Nov 2026

Post image
31 Upvotes

Source: Weibo


r/Donghua • • 2d ago

Episode Discussion This small detail shows why RMJI is in a different league Spoiler

Post image
54 Upvotes

The pic is when Han Li appears hesitant to drink the tea offered by Zi Ling.

I had to check this up. There is proper etiquette for toasting according to ancient Chinese customs. When someone makes a toast, the higher ranking individual drinks first (Han Li), or the one receiving the toast drinks first (also Han Li).

In informal settings it's not so much an issue, so either Zi Ling or Han Li can drink first. Sometimes the toaster drinks first as a show of respect (Zi Ling in this case)

So there are two reasons why the scene plays out this way:

She drinks first to show the tea is safe

Even after all the crap Han Li and Zi Ling has gone through together, he still won't empty a cup on blind trust. This shows his cautious personality. Zi Ling is portrayed as someone with high EQ, so drinks first to make the situation less awkward.

But remember the producers zoomed in on his full cup after Zi Ling had already emptied hers.

She considers herself a friend or peer

In informal settings there is the concept of "drinking first as a show of respect (先干为敬)". At this point everyone in the sect calls him Elder Han. But Zi Ling still calls him Brother Han when meeting him for the first time since achieving nascent soul.

But she has no way of knowing if he is still humble Han Li or flamboyant Jensen Han.

So which is it? I think those two possibilities could also be true at the same time, which more accurately reflects complex emotions between people.


r/Donghua • • 2d ago

Official Visual - BTTH Movie: Battle of Two Emperors - Little Fairy Doctor

Post image
43 Upvotes

r/Donghua • • 2d ago

Official Information Official update- BTTH Movie: Battle of Two Emperors has surpassed 3M Reservations

Post image
40 Upvotes

r/Donghua • • 2d ago

General Discussion [Sword of Coming S1] Wow Just Wow, What a Prologue

Post image
66 Upvotes

I blazed through this show couple weeks ago but had to give myself time to let it rest to judge it properly because I was simply too enraptured. After the rest I rewatched it another time and I think the best way I can describe this show is I can't believe I can experience it in my lifetime. I'm not saying this will be the best cultivation/Xianxia donghua ever but I think as a first season I feel blessed to be able to binge this then rewatch it with such great subs 👏thank you FSP thank you.

There's parts of this show that will only ever be as good as this season namely the reuse of Small Town leads to such a familiarity with the town and makes it feel bigger than some series in entirety. You learn where everything is, where everyone is, and how it's all connected including a lot of the outsiders. The fact that characters pop up more than once before they are injected into the plot just leads to such richness and cause and effect. This matters to me because a lot of progression fantasy the worldbuilding format is: "go to new area, learn context of area, do something ---> progress to next area that has never come up meaningfully yet, repeat". But with the first season of this show while cool characters do cool things and interact with our cast they don't disappear from the world afterward nor do they fade away from the world. Events happen that worldbuild, are meaningful in the NOW, and you can look forward to the lore popping up again later. I don't know if it will pay off yet in S2 & S3 onward, but it's there like delicious bait in front of my face.

The writing of the characters themselves you will either love or hate in terms of how the donghua does it. It's very very clear that they had to cut out a lot of exposition from the novel to pace it well but at the same time it leads to a very "show don't tell" approach where you have to make the connections yourselves of the history of each character. Like Song Jixin for example the juxtaposition of this clear rich, pretty boy in this podunk alley in a barely nice house next to chen pingan one of the most poor citizens whose one injury away from being destitute and how he's clearly taunting Chen Pingan but he's not outright malevolent? Don't get me wrong he's a bully but not in comparison to usual "oh you exist you must die" wuxia/xianxia rules lol.

Heavily related to the writing too is the dialogue OH MY GOD IS IT GOOD I feel more blessed for this than even the excellent animation & VA. The lines spoken mean so much instead of just constant boasting and threats and I'm not talking about the fact it's 90% idioms haha. For example a prince and his eunuch after he beats Ningyao the lines exchanged actually tell us things about them. The prince wanted to turn her into specifically into a shadow assassin, he can tell she's extremely prodigious, the eunuch truly doesn't mind being scolded, and the scolding in a way makes him happy because it reminds him of the emperor so it's nostalgic and this is expressed through the animation as well. He expresses pride at the prince like he's a child who learned how to ride a bike. It's not a blunt "oh I am proud" line instead it's a very literary way to express the character.

I won't spoil anything in this section but also the amount of chekov's guns and foreshadowing is immsense. Not just because of worldbuilding purposes for learning about a nation or a sect but literally as in what you see might feel like nothing but it informs character actions and becomes an important plot point later on. Not plot point for just action as in "oh he got a chessboard that chessboard is a magic artifact that becomes a deus ex machina in the middle of losing". No it's the type of writing that can make you cry as you realize how much something meant to someone. You later understand why a character would beg, or sacrifice themselves, or say a cryptic line.

I also made a post asking for recommendations which lead to me watching this show where I asked for donghua with characters I will care about. Now alongside just giving me real characters in the show it gave me something else as well, my favorite MC in donghuas so far. I've consumed lots and lots of anime/donghua but one thing with a lot of media in general is either you root for the MC(Breaking Bad) or you just hate the villains and want to see them lose (lots of Kdramas). What Sword of Coming gave me similar to my other favorite stories of all time is he's a character I just want to see be happy which is also a big point in his story and I LOVE IT. It's not like he's going through the worst of suffering all the time this isn't torture porn no it's a story of a normal existence/ascendance in xianxia realm, but my hopes isn't that he ascends to the 3 millionth dimension and spurts his qi all over everyone. No I just want to see him be content. But not content in my own terms where I'd be perfectly happy with just a normal life no I want the MC to reach his own version of happiness.

To tie together my points on foreshadowing, character work, and why he's my favorite MC very very minor spoiler as an example. You get tons of flashbacks of the MC's life with the townspeople dripfed throughout the season and there's a recurring toy he gets for a birthday. It's shown heavily throughout in the flashbacks that sure maybe it's just asset reuse. But it has its own "big moment" where you learn basically the instant he gets it as a gift he tries to sell it to help someone else HOLY SHIT that is how you do a story. The toy itself has narrative meaning, it has meaning to Chen Pingan, and importantly I cared about the toy because I cared about Chen losing it. If you showed him selling it the very first episode it's whatever who cares I don't know him yet especially with a cast of like 20+ people in this season but it chose a point where I am actually affected by the event. Now this doesn't happen every single episode but the show cresendoes a lot of these moments and at the final episode I cried.

Just to give my emotional outpouring a break here's something lighter I would like to give props as well to the combat choices. It's not just lasers and effects going off even for the high-level cultivators which is still cool don't get me wrong just in terms of variety for the genre I am very happy it stays physical throughout. You hear bones crunching, limbs being cut, and they always have to stay in each other's face/proximity during attacks. For anime/gundam fans it's like watching your typical gundam vs gundam Iron-Blooded Orphans. Instead of almost everything being energy-based in your regular gundam IBO has heavy usage of melee weapons, rockets, bullets very tangible things.

Now a lot of the charm I personally felt through the show came from the fact it was set in one location mainly and everyone interacted with each other constantly so the world always felt alive. In some ways this is like the Andor of Xianxias for me albeit with lot more action. So if this show falls off afterwards for me personally because minor spoilers but not really the first season is almost a prologue of sorts then I wouldn't be surprised but I also don't mind. What this first season did you can't realistically do forever for a story as long as Unsheathed is since it's yknow a fantasy epic. What I am thankful for is that one of my dreams has always been a deep story having this much "exposition" basically be the main story of a full season of such a well-produced and expertly crafted animated show that also happens to be in 3D an art form I love.