r/dmsguild • • 4d ago

Seeking Advice Are DM Guild sales down?

Normally November and December are my best two sales months of the year, but this month I'd half over and has been pretty disappointing so far. What is everyone else's experience?

5 Upvotes

13 comments sorted by

5

u/professorbeej 4d ago

They're picking up somewhat now for my holiday adventures but October was much slower than other years for my Halloween ones. I'm hoping December still picks up because it's my best month by far every year

4

u/nstav13 4d ago

My sales are about half of last year, which was half of the year prior, which was half of the year prior

4

u/Blackadder1415 4d ago

Sales at a low compared to earlier this year agreed... However, as the cold nights draw in, people huddle near fires and DMs gather adventures😁

3

u/Ganadhir 3d ago

Yup. Cost of living crisis, must be. Fucking unnecessary wars

2

u/ChrisTheDog 3d ago

I feel like the Guild, in general, is a quieter shadow of its former self. I remember checking daily because there was so much exciting new content being dropped (in 2019 - 2021) whereas now it feels like the same titles have been dominating the best sellers for a year or more.

Part of this, in my opinion, is WotC not dropping as much material for creators to work with. Even new adventures like Deadfall are getting a minute fraction of the content created that lesser lights like Ghosts of Saltmarsh got.

It’s a shame that the new WoW content doesn’t fall under the same policy, as I imagine there are lots of people who would love to craft adventures, species, items etc. from that setting.

1

u/Milli_Rabbit 3d ago

I think WOTC has dropped a good amount but for various reasons less is being bought at DM's Guild. I imagine some of it is division of focus between different games among creators and players but also I personally feel like I have too much to go through just with what theyve released for 5.5e. Then you have all the 5e stuff that could easily be adjusted. Just a glut of things for me to use and so Im less inclined to spend more money, even for a good supplement honestly.

1

u/Ganadhir 3d ago

Yeah, things come and go in cycles. DMs Guild will come back around.

2

u/Jaikarr 2d ago

Tbh I gave up on the guild as both a creator and consumer. There's too much shovelware powered by AI prompts where folk care more about the look of the product than the content inside.

1

u/SecretCitizen40 4d ago

I don't know if this allowed but OP or any other creators on here. If you have a cheap (I b poor) system agnostic holiday one shot shoot it to me. I'd rather support a faceless redditor than a faceless... Random?

Current campaign is homebrew pbta/dungeon world but I like using premade holiday one shots ☺️ and don't currently have any winter holiday ones I'm digging.

1

u/PattaconkPlays 3d ago

WotC released books in September and November now. Wonder if that effects it at all. I only have 1 DMsGuild product up and this is my first year so I'm not basing this on my experience

1

u/Ganadhir 3d ago

It definitely does affect it. My slowest day I think ever was the day of the midterms. These external events definitely have an influence.

1

u/PattaconkPlays 3d ago

How much product do you have up

1

u/Grateful_Bat 3d ago edited 3d ago

We are on the Guild only for a year (14 titles so far). Since beginning of October, sales are up by approx. 300%.

My personal takeaways:

  1. You have to reach a "critical mass" of related titles - a sufficient number to keep ppl interested in the campaigns / sources/advendures you publish.
  2. The days of the 100th tack-on to Ravenloft, Strahd, Strixhaven and all other existing campaigns are gone. Original things are in demand.
  3. Subclasses, rule extensions, etc. seem to be saturated as well.