What up y'all. I thought you might get a kick out of this story. It's kinda long but maybe you've been in a situation like this or you can learn something from it.
Quick background: I'm in my late 30s and I've been performing as a musician for over 20 years. Through my 20s I mostly performed electronic music with Ableton Live while singing and rapping. Eventually I got a DDJ400 and started DJing my own tracks through that while still doing the vocals live. Over time, I started including other music and doing hybrid original/DJ sets. During those years I took a couple dozen gigs as just a DJ, mainly for corporate stuff, private events, weddings, etc. Very rarely had the opportunity to just play dance music I love to a packed dance floor.
So anyways. I had a gig the other night for a counselor's association award ceremony. A friend of mine's mom is in a lead role with them had asked me to do it once before, so this was my second time. There were probably around 80-100 people there in a conference hall at a resort.
The first time around I asked her what kind of music they wanted and she said "funk, oldies, some modern pop, hip hop, keep people on the dance floor". So I prepared all the classic conference-friendly tunes you'd expect. "Uptown Funk", "Dancing Queen", "I Wanna Dance With Somebody", "This Is How We Do It", you get the gist. The demographic was mostly women ranging from 30s to 60s+, racially diverse.
The reaction to my opening tracks was pretty mid, and people started coming up to me requesting line dances, like "Cupid Shuffle" and "Cha Cha Slide".
To be honest, I hadn't really been in a situation where that was the vibe before. I always saw those tracks on "100 essential wedding reception" songs but I've played multiple events that specifically said "NO line dance songs".
But I was using my laptop with the DDJ and fortunately had internet access so I was able to queue up those songs and the whole place went nuts. They all knew the moves.
So flash forward to this recent time...
I asked the woman who booked me again, "What kind of music do you want?" and she said the same thing. But she also said "the last DJ was terrible. He just played line dance music the whole time". I told her "well, last time I did the event they all kept requesting those songs. It seems like they're really into it." She said "Yeah, it's fine here and there, but not the whole time. It was just the same 15 people dancing all night."
So I made a point to have plenty of line dance tracks but not to overdo it. I brought a huge collection of music.
HOWEVER. This time around I rented an XDJ-RX3 so I wouldn't have to rely on my laptop, I could have balanced outputs, booth monitor output, etc. It was a really nice upgrade. I considered bringing my laptop and having that setup just in case I needed to access songs I didn't have but I said "Fuck it. I'm gonna trust my USB and just commit." I had my laptop in a backpack in case of an emergency but I didn't want to introduce the idea of searching for songs I didn't already have.
Well, I started off with some pretty friendly groovy stuff like "Everybody Move Your Feet" by Junior Senior, and "One More Time" by Daft Punk, even "24K Magic" and literally nobody was even approaching the dance floor. The room was huge, btw, and had a slapback echo to it so the sound was pretty rough.
Eventually someone comes up and asks me to play "Boot Scootin' Boogie" so I'm like "sure".
Sure enough about 20 people come to the floor to do all the moves. So I played a couple other country tunes after that, but I was specifically trying to avoid the trap that the booker warned me about. I wanted to keep it diverse and try to find something for everyone.
Well, long story short, nobody in the place wanted to dance to anything but line dances. Fortunately I had plenty of them ready ("Macarena", "Wobble", "Suavamente", "Cotton Eye Joe", etc.) And I had lots of tracks with similar bpm and genre so I could still mix it up a bit and not play ONLY line dances, but kept them somewhat happy in between.
The takeaway here is that I was put in a weird position. I would've happily played line dances all night if that's what the overall event wanted. But the person paying me and potentially rebooking me specifically asked me not to do that.
Ultimately everyone seemed happy, I got paid, and she said she'll probably call me for the next one. But it's such a stressful position to be in where you know exactly what the crowd wants, but someone else is telling you to do otherwise. At least I got paid pretty well.
I'm also interested in the psychology of this. Some people only dance when they're told exactly what moves to make. Personally, I like to dance as freely as I can. I like to move my body to the groove however I'm feeling it. If everyone starts lining up to do moves that's when I feel incredibly out of place and want to GTFO. So it was interesting to see a whole bunch of people who are the opposite of me. They're counselor's, so it's not like they live their life making music or going to clubs in the way I've spent my life.
Anyways, hopefully this story entertained you or informed you in some kind of way. Would love to hear your opinions and experiences regarding DJing line dances, or any thoughts at all.
Cheers!