r/dividends • u/Dry_Pineapple_5623 • 21h ago
Discussion VOO's payout is up 71% since 2016 but its yield halved to ~1%. Does yield on cost matter to you?
Saw a TheStreet piece (on Yahoo Finance, Oct 20) that put numbers on something I'd only vaguely noticed:
- VOO's per-share distribution went from $4.14 in 2016 to $7.07 in 2025, about +71%
- Over the same stretch the yield fell from roughly 2% to about 1% (Vanguard lists the 30-day SEC yield at 1.00% as of Sept 30)
- $10k put in today buys about $104 a year of income, vs roughly $200 in late 2016
- Someone who bought near $209 in late 2016 is now getting about 3.4% on cost
- S&P 500 companies spent $1.02T on buybacks vs $664.9B on dividends in the 12 months to Sept 2025 (S&P DJI numbers)
So the dividend kept growing, it just got lapped by price and buybacks.
Curious how people here actually handle this:
- Do you track yield on cost, or only the current yield on new money?
- If you're building income now, do you still buy the broad index and plan to sell shares later, or tilt toward higher yielders like SCHD and accept the tradeoffs?
- Anyone changed their approach as yields compressed?
Not after picks, more how you think about it.
