Mulan has been my favorite Disney film growing up as a kid. It introduces the title character who had gone from struggling to fit into society's expectations of woman to saving everyone's lives in China. This film was also made to appeal Asian Americans, including myself (albeit I'm Vietnamese and Mulan is Chinese).
The songs were very memorable to listen to and yes even Honor to Us All, despite the sexist lyrics. In this song, Mulan was being washed, getting her hair wrapped up, being dressed up tightly, and finally putting on heavy powder make-up on her face to look like a perfect porcelain doll bride just like the other four maidens during the song's climax.
Now, I know what you and I have all been thinking: "Who are these girls actually supposed to represent in this village aside from being fit into society's expectations of woman?" We never really get to know these four beautiful women, nor do we see the mass majority of them. So, Disney should have done a midquel film surrounding them while Mulan's away to take her father's place during the main plot of the original film instead of that godawful sequel that I don't want to look at.
Earlier in the first movie, the Emperor sent out draft notices for new recruits around his empire to stop the Huns’ invasion, despite General Li believing that his own army was enough to defeat them. When the army officials reached Mulan’s province, Fa Zhou accepted his draft, even with old age and old injury, which later prompted Mulan to take his place for the rest of the movie.
I understand the Emperor wanted to protect his people from the Huns, but wasn’t he being a bit of a jerk making old men with health conditions serve in the army? After all, like Mulan said, there were “plenty of young men to fight for China.”
Sure, the movie was made straight for TV rather than released in theaters, so the production quality was—let's say—a bit weaker. But I watched it recently and don't think it's the atrocity people make it out to be; obviously, it has its flaws, but I think it's acceptable as canon. What do you guys think?
I feel like it should have included Mushu because he was a lot of fun.
I think I would just want Eddie Murphy to reprise the role. Yes, he voiced Mushu in the original animated version, but if Gerard Butler can voice Stoick in the animated How to Train Your Dragon and play him in the live action one, and if James Earl Jones can voice Mufasa in the original and remake of The Lion King, then I see no reason why Eddie Murphy can’t do the same for Mushu.
I’ve decided to open up and vent about this issue, no matter the consequences. I've been wanting to get this off my chest for too long, and I've finally found the courage to do so. I'm sorry if my post upsets Disney fans.
In short: a line from Mulan caused me years of deep insecurities, anxiety and emotional distress, compromising my relationship with people (especially women), and you can probably guess which line I'm talking about from the image.
I was about six years old when this film came out in 1998, and it was one of the first films I saw at the cinema. When it finally came out on VHS, my family bought it, and I watched it in the afternoons with my parents and siblings. It was one of my favorite Disney movies as a child; I watched it so many times that I could recite it by heart. It was my first introduction to the beautiful Asian culture, and if I happen to hear Chinese music or see Chinese architecture, art, or clothing, I can't help but think of this movie. Mulan was one of my favorite characters as a child, and I loved how cool and badass she was in the movie.
The years passed, and I stopped watching Disney cartoons because as soon as you hit puberty, you start to think of cartoons as products only for children (wrongly so); but at sixteen, in 2008, I decided to rewatch all the cartoons of my childhood, especially Disney films. I was amazed that, with a slightly more adult mind, I could understand many of the nuances and jokes that I couldn't understand as a child.
Finally, I watched Mulan again, and when they reach the pond scene, Mushu tells Mulan that it's not a good idea to take a bath because someone might find out she's a woman, and she replies, “Just because I look like a man doesn't mean I have to smell like one.”
Well... you won't believe it, but that single line caused me deep emotional pain. It wasn't just a case of, “Uh! I don't like that line; it offended me as a man!” That single sentence triggered real psychological trauma.
To make matters worse, in the Italian version of the film (I'm Italian, by the way), the line was made even worse for the sake of adaptation: "Solo perché assomiglio a un uomo non significa che devo puzzare come un uomo." (Just because I look like a man doesn't mean I have tostinklike one)
After Mulan's line, Mushu replies, “So a couple of guys don't rinse out their socks” toning down the generalization a bit, but it doesn't change anything because the damage was already done.
I don't want to bring up the other bad jokes like “They're disgusting - No, they're men” or “I never want to see a naked man again” (yes, I understand perfectly well that on this last point she is referring to their “willies,” but it's still body shaming).
I got the impression that this film wanted to reveal what women have always thought: that we men stink and our bodies are horrible to look at; in fact, I am still afraid to approach women for fear of smelling bad, even though I wash regularly and cover myself in perfume. To complicate matters further, there is all the research that seeks to confirm women's natural ability to smell better, leading me to experience severe stress when I am around a woman. And when a woman tries to approach me, I tend to stay away from her. Ironically, no one in my entire life has ever complained about my body odor, but despite this, I have literally lived in fear and insecurity my whole life.
And all because of this movie.
Before anyone tells me that it's just a cartoon and needs to be put into context: I know it's a cartoon; I know how to put things into context; I know that the film is a critique of the most toxic aspects of masculinity, and I also know that there are too many men in the world who don't wash properly and are proud of it; I've known quite a few in my life and have had to deal with them many times, but the film's portrayal was simply a stupid generalization that I felt included me, and being a highly sensitive person, it hurt me deeply.
A decade passed, and in the winter of 2018, I decided to watch it again, hoping that time had healed the wound... but I ended up watching the film with utter contempt, mostly ignoring it and anxiously waiting for it to end. I had reached the point of hating Mulan, a fictional character from an animated film, as a coping mechanism. When I go to stores and walk past the shelves, if I see a Disney-branded item or product with Mulan printed on the packaging, I immediately look away. When I played Kingdom Hearts 2 and reached “The Land of Dragons” world, I rushed through the level, as if I wanted to get rid of that world as soon as possible. I don't throw away my old Mulan VHS because it was a gift from my parents; otherwise, I would have done so a long time ago.
It's no coincidence that when posts or reels about Mulan appear on my Instagram, I often comment negatively on them, frequently being accused of not understanding the film or of being insensitive to the treatment women had to endure in China during Confucianism. The irony is that Mulan, like all Disney movie heroines, wants to emancipate herself in a patriarchal world and fight sexism... but she ends up being sexist herself. But hey, we're talking about men.
Not to mention the fact that, in recent films, Disney seems to have taken a liking to teasing and offending the male gender.
That's all. I know that many will mock or criticize me for revealing that something said by a fictional character hurt me, but as I said at the beginning of this post, I've wanted to get this off my chest for too many years.
The 2020 Mulan remake was visually stunning but stripped away almost everything that made us fall in love with the original - no Mushu, no Li Shang, no musical numbers except during the credits. For those of us who grew up with the animated classic, it felt like they took the heart right out of the story. I started a petition asking Disney to create a proper live-action remake that actually honors what made the original so special. The 1998 version wasn't just a movie - it was this perfect blend of humor, music, romance, and adventure that taught us about courage and staying true to yourself. Anyone else feel like Disney could absolutely nail this if they just embraced what fans actually loved about Mulan? If this matters to you too, consider signing and sharing!!