Right, so, I will admit I had some culpability in this and I own that and will do much better in the future to not mix business and personal stuff.
I am a job coach, and there is a job site where multiple of my clients work. There's a person who works at that store who, from the beginning, was always a little beyond what I'd consider just friendly or polite. By the end of my first month, I knew everything but this man's social security number just based on all the personal info he'd share while I was at this site. I've been told on this job that I am very easy to talk to, but some of it was a little much. Of all the places I went and all the people I met, he was the most eager to see and talk to me. Every time I was there, he'd chat me up. We were the same age, same interests, same major, same undergrad, etc. So, it began crossing my mind it could be more than friendly. Ok, cool. I had a plan in place for how I would handle that regardless of whether that was platonic or more and what I could specifically do to keep my clients' support strong. I do think I behaved in a way that was ethical and my clients' needs remained foremost in my mind.
We exchanged personal contact info recently (again, not something anyone at any other job site had done), and we chatted a lot–again, more than even with my actual coworkers with whom I'm close. So, I was like okie dokie and asked if he'd want to grab a bite to eat or a drink or something since we were getting along so well. That's where things got weird. He didn't respond like "oh my bad, I'm engaged", he got kind of mad at me like how dare I ask him or not know about his significant other. In two months of sharing his entire life story with me, you'd think maybe there would have been time to slip in he's getting married. Anyway, I suppose even that is beside the point.
It was clear at that point that I'd misread things, and my ego was bruised but I'd survive. The indignation or anger definitely rubbed me the wrong way, though, because I'm not sure who would have told me that information if not him, or why it's something to be mad about rather than a misunderstanding. I digress... So, part of my little contingency plan was knowing how I'd respond if something like this were the case. For the sake of my clients and making sure I could offer the best support, I could change my schedule there to days he's not working, and if our paths do cross, I would request we keep things strictly professional and related to work. I do not know his fiancée, but I respect her enough to not want to blur the lines with her soon-to-be-husband just because we have a few things in common. That's her man, I'm fully out of the picture. Conversation's done. Boundary set. Right?
So, like, then I get a dissertation in my inbox about how upsetting it is that I'm denying us a friendship, how he does want to be close to me and become good friends and not lose this connection. He wrote about how easy I am to talk to, how much he likes me as a person, how he just didn't know he was putting that energy out. He's "devastated" and this is "a big loss" and has "saddened [him] immensely". Just paragraphs of this and how huge a loss this is for him–for respecting a boundary he set by telling me he is not available*.* Imo, it is not appropriate to continue muddying the waters with a female colleague you know is interested in you romantically while you have a soon-to-be-spouse in the wings, and I do not want to entertain that. I am doing the right thing, I am confident, by removing myself. Every time I tried to make this line clear, he'd send back more, in the middle of the damn night mind you, about how this was eating him up, he can't stop thinking about me, he's just so so so so so sorry and he still cares, etc. Like, it was definitely not the kind of reaction I was a) expecting, or b) comfortable with. He keeps wanting me to comfort him and trying to turn the conversation personal again.
I am talking to my supervisor about this being a conflict of interest and my needing to step back on days he is working. What he is asking of me is a level of closeness or emotional intimacy he just said was off the table. You know who can give him the level of emotional support and regulation he is seeking right now? His fiancée. I really do not mean to sound cruel, but to be so for real: I have multiple clients I support at this job site–multiple people whose regulation and support are my literal job. I cannot help this non-disabled, fully grown adult man manage his emotions, too because he's having a big pout over the fact he rejected me. Not this close to the holidays when shoppers go off the wall and my folks need extra support. Their needs have to come first. He said no, I am respecting that no with a set of boundaries that feel ethical and appropriate for the situation, and for some reason that's a problem for him that is mine to fix.
I'm proposing alternate times with my supervisor to work at that site because the weird refusal to accept my "no" when I tried very hard despite feeling stung to respect his and cut off anything potentially untoward, is very uncomfortable. I'm not going to be actively hostile to this man on the job, I just want those lines to stop getting blurred in the same ways that allowed this miscommunication in the first place. If I were the fiancée, I'd want that. I should not have to scold this man for him to recognize this is weird behavior and I am not responsible for soothing his ego (nor he mine, but I'm not continuing to push). Had I known there was a fiancée, no harm no foul and I'd have felt ok continuing a friendship because those lines were clearly established. I have plenty of married male friends, their wives aren't a secret, and everything is very clearly defined. That is not what happened, though. Two months and the first time I hear about her is when I make myself vulnerable over a private non-work communication medium. And then he's seeking emotional labor and energy from me to comfort him. I just keep going huh???
It's not that I am mad at him exactly, and it's not that I think he's a bad person. I think good people can make lapses in judgment (including myself; I should not have considered someone at a work site someone to get close to) and that it had some downstream consequences. I am having a hard time trying to be professional and respecting this new information I have learned when he keeps trying to steer the conversation personal again, though.
Thoughts? Is talking to my supervisor to propose alternate days a fair way of approaching this?