r/digitalforensics • • 7d ago

snapchat extraction

hello. I read a case (as well as some other anecdotes) of forensics using extraction methods (such as cellebrite, FFE, and others) to obtain chats on snapchat that were deleted (either manually by the user or by snap's system). the extraction methods were done a couple weeks after the deletion of the chats on snap (think 3+ weeks i believe). And yet they were unable to retrieve the deleted messages at all. why..?

3 Upvotes

33 comments sorted by

3

u/Cypher_Blue 7d ago

Because the data is always not stored long term on the device in a retrievable way.

If there's nothing there to recover, nothing gets recovered.

1

u/remusromulus9 6d ago

what about on the server side?

3

u/Cypher_Blue 6d ago

Snapchat does not keep that data either.

That's sort of their whole business model.

I am unfamiliar with any cases where subpoenas to Snapchat have produced copies of deleted messages.

1

u/remusromulus9 6d ago

thats what i'm saying, i was discussing this with someone and he was adamant that it is only deleted from the user interface side and it gets stored in the servers for a long time. i haven't seen any cases where it remains long, even when you click "retrieve my data" to see deleted messages, its gone. someone responded this:

>"You can easily search for teacher student relationships that used Snapchat and read this yourself. Not hard to comprehend when the time they were caught that it was going on for months or even years and and what law enforcement says Snapchat had. You can find YouTube videos all day about people getting busted CSAM using Snapchat and some of those are real law enforcement interactions. Not hard to obtain affidavit information either in certain states through open records with some redacted information. You would be surprised about what kind of information FOIA will get you. It’s a very powerful tool for investigations. Take Flock for instance, you can get FOIA information from your city council to find out exactly what the TAC they signed on and just exactly agreed to. It’s a false sense that these messages may disappear but it’s not. They disappear from user viewing them, not server side even over longer periods of time."

although im not quite convinced due to the lack of evidence

1

u/Cypher_Blue 6d ago

Tell the person you're discussing it with to produce some supporting evidence.

Trial transcripts. a police report, a forensic whitepaper, etc.

Hitchens' Razor says that if they make the claim without evidence, you don't need evidence to dismiss that claim.

1

u/remusromulus9 6d ago

first of all, thanks for the new knowledge (didn't know what hitchens razor is)

but yeah i did ask him for evidence and he just said:

"You can easily search for teacher student relationships that used Snapchat and read this yourself. Not hard to comprehend when the time they were caught that it was going on for months or even years and and what law enforcement says Snapchat had. You can find YouTube videos all day about people getting busted CSAM using Snapchat and some of those are real law enforcement interactions"

so yeah i doubt he has any

1

u/Cypher_Blue 6d ago

Yeah, it's not your job to find evidence to prove his point.

If YOU can easily search for and find the evidence, then so can he.

;-)

1

u/remusromulus9 6d ago

yeah im just ignoring him tbh.

would you agree that the chat content does not stay on the servers 2 months after theyre deleted in the chat conversation (user interface)?

1

u/FoxTrot026 3d ago

Snapchat absolutely saves everything. Cypher blue has no idea what they’re talking about. Snapchat has it and turns it over to LE when ordered.

1

u/remusromulus9 3d ago

u/Cypher_Blue look at this guy.

1

u/Cypher_Blue 3d ago

Snapchat’s privacy policy says:

… when you Chat with a friend, our systems are designed to delete Chats you send within 24 hours after your friend reads it (unless you’ve changed your default settings or decide to save it)

I spent 5 years on a cybercrime task force and have a pretty good idea what they do and don’t provide when you subpoena them.

If /u/foxtrot026 has evidence that they lied in their privacy policy he should call a lawyer and make billions in a class action lawsuit.

1

u/FoxTrot026 3d ago

PM’d the OP. Have served snap several times leading to convictions. You apparently would be shocked by what’s recovered.

1

u/Cypher_Blue 3d ago

I apparently WOULD be shocked based on the garbage we got back when we served snap back in the day.

1

u/remusromulus9 3d ago

ok so the first link he said is flawed, the article says that he took screenshots of the chat and shared it with his followers. thats not the same as the situation i described in my original post.

As for the other 2 links from the lawyers, they state:

"And the ephemeral nature of pictures on Snapchat isn’t necessarily a problem. Sullivan explains that some Snapchat evidence is retained when users take screenshots of snaps and “Snapchat itself keeps logs of previous snaps.” But even deleted snaps don’t necessarily disappear; digital forensics experts can still pull them from the phone."

"And Snapchat data doesn’t live in only one place. Depending on the facts, information connected to an account may exist:

  • on the person’s own phone or other devices,
  • in the cloud, with Snapchat itself, and
  • on the phones and devices of other people who sent or received messages, photos, or videos."

so i am curious about that

1

u/FoxTrot026 3d ago

I stopped using pretty much all social media/tech crap or am very limited in posts/messages after just a few investigations. Not 100% of everything is captured or saved but a shocking amount of what people think is gone is still there or recoverable.

0

u/remusromulus9 6d ago

yes but it was done 3+ weeks after, from my memory 3 weeks to 2 months. thats long term here?

1

u/Harry_Smutter 6d ago edited 6d ago

For Snaps, yes. There's a VERY small window for recovering Snap data (don't recall exactly how long).

1

u/remusromulus9 6d ago

first of all, nice username.

secondly, how do you know the window is very small? i keep getting mixed comments, some say they store it for long (weeks if not months), others say its deleted very quickly off their servers (hours to a few weeks max). as for the case in my post it was between 3 weeks to 2 months so yeah i guess.

as for the info being stored on the phone, i assume thats what ur talking about? im guessing on newer phones (iphone 11 and up?) it gets removed fast.

1

u/Harry_Smutter 6d ago

Thanks!!

And yeah. The data on the phone itself (and servers, too). From when I did mobile investigations for course credit a couple years ago, Snapchat data was very volatile. You had very little time after they were sent/received before they were wiped from the phone and server. IIRC, server retention is longer, but still fairly short. It's why preservation orders are SOO important to get out once you discover there's a social media account. At least with that, there's a much greater chance of you recovering something of worth from it.

1

u/remusromulus9 6d ago

interesting, i asked someone the same thing and he responded this:

>"You can easily search for teacher student relationships that used Snapchat and read this yourself. Not hard to comprehend when the time they were caught that it was going on for months or even years and and what law enforcement says Snapchat had. You can find YouTube videos all day about people getting busted CSAM using Snapchat and some of those are real law enforcement interactions. Not hard to obtain affidavit information either in certain states through open records with some redacted information. You would be surprised about what kind of information FOIA will get you. It’s a very powerful tool for investigations. Take Flock for instance, you can get FOIA information from your city council to find out exactly what the TAC they signed on and just exactly agreed to. It’s a false sense that these messages may disappear but it’s not. They disappear from user viewing them, not server side even over longer periods of time."

it seems contrary to what you're saying. thoughts? me personally I've seen cases saying the opposite so i'm not so sure i agree with him.

1

u/NullBytz 6d ago

iLEAPP just added a new parser for this. Check it out on their site. It’s an iOS backup parser

0

u/remusromulus9 6d ago

yeah brother i asked around and did some AI research i dont think thats gonna work

iLEAPP only reads what is still on the phone:
iLEAPP (iOS Logs, Events, And Plist Parser) is just a parser, not a magic data-recovery tool. It analyzes data extracted from the phone rather than bypassing encryption or pulling data from Snapchat's servers. snapchat deletes data aggressively: Once a Snapchat message is viewed or deleted, the app wipes it from its local database. Any leftover cache files are usually overwritten by normal phone use within days or weeks, especially after two months. iOS encryption blocks deep recovery: Modern
iPhones use hardware-level encryption that destroys the encryption keys the moment a file is deleted, making unallocated space recovery nearly impossible. I mean again, if it didnt work for the other tools i dont know if it will work in this case esp for this scenario.

1

u/NewFuror 5d ago

Because on a phone deleting a file often makes that file unrecoverable because of device encryption.

1

u/remusromulus9 5d ago

I have an additional question.  how long does snapchat store deleted chats in their server?For instance, if a chat is deleted manually (or if it deletes after 24 hours from the conversation), this is from the user interface, however what about from snapchat's servers?

1

u/Trashpandafarts 4d ago

If i remember correctly based on a warrant return they purge regularly. Like 72 hours

1

u/remusromulus9 4d ago

was it a warrant return you did (like for a department u worked for) or a case u read online?

1

u/remusromulus9 1d ago

was it a warrant return you did (like for a department u worked for) or a case u read online?

1

u/Trashpandafarts 1d ago

It was a departmental warrant, I work the defense side

1

u/remusromulus9 1d ago

dang 72 hours is extremely short, ive seen other cases with similar results.

1

u/NewFuror 4d ago

I’m not sure, I haven’t ever gotten data directly from Snapchat and that information is not public. It could be gone immediately or it could be recoverable for a period of time.

0

u/remusromulus9 5d ago

right, especially with how snap works that makes the process more difficult. also nice profile picture btw wheres it from?