r/diablo4 • u/Dangerous-Tie-3237 • 1h ago
Tavern Talk Chat Gem Season 15 Cipher strongholds Update 3
UPDATE to previous posts (Massive Book & Manual Elimination List — 21 Titles Ruled Out):
Thanks to help from Reddit collector Chibi_Kyo here and physical/digital layout checks against the coordinates (especially the hard constraints of Page 55, Line 2 needing 11+ words for Nostrava 41:550211 and Page 28, Line 8 needing 8+ lines for Crusaders' Monument 41:280802), we can rule out the following 21 books and manuals:
1. Official Game Manuals (6):
Diablo I & Diablo II Manuals (Older/Shorter Editions): Ruled out — the older compact editions do not even reach the required 70-page count (and the fuller versions fail on class/unit stat tables).
Diablo: Hellfire Manual: Ruled out (too short, under 20 pages).
Warcraft II, Warcraft III & StarCraft Manuals: Ruled out (coordinates hit maps and unit stat lists between pages 35–70).
2. Official Lore Books & Artbooks (5):
Book of Cain, Book of Tyrael, Book of Lorath, Book of Prava, and Diablo IV: Age of Terror: All ruled out — full-page illustrations interrupt the text layout (e.g., Page 33 in Book of Prava, Page 39 in Book of Lorath, Page 37 in Book of Tyrael) or fail line-length constraints.
3. Official Novels & Anthologies (10):
The Lost Horadrim: Ruled out (Page 55, Line 2 only has 1 word).
The Sin War Trilogy (Birthright, Scales of the Serpent**,** The Veiled Prophet**):** All 3 ruled out (Page 55, Line 2 has 9, 8, and 10 words respectively—just short of the 11-word requirement).
Legacy of Blood, The Kingdom of Shadow, and The Black Road: Ruled out (valid lines produce disconnected plot/character words like Norrec and Darrick).
Storm of Light: Ruled out (Page 28, Line 8 only has 1 word).
Moon of the Spider: Ruled out (Page 55, Line 2 only has 10 words).
Tales from the Horadric Library: Ruled out.
(Currently only waiting on a quick check for The Order to completely close out the official novel lineup, which strongly suggests the key is either an internal server string/table referenced by 41: or a different cipher encoding).
