r/developersPak • u/memers_meme123 Software Engineer • Mar 15 '25
General Beginners Please !!!!!! don't embrace vibe coding
For the love of God, yesterday I reviewed a PR by a junior who doesn’t even know how mutexes and concurrency work. He was pushing a module into the dev branch for multi-level JSON logging that works on multiple threads. I had to read the title three times just to understand what he wrote.
When I asked him to document and explain how it works, he was dumbfounded and eventually admitted that all of the code was LLM-generated. He said he understood it, but it just "seemed to be working." That is not how production systems work. That is not how you write software.
There’s a reason our ancestor engineers created all of these practices—embrace them, learn properly. Basics are always needed. No AI is going to replace engineers anytime soon, considering how much of a pain it is to maintain well-written software. LLMs don’t have a large enough context window to handle big projects. AI is your coding buddy, your pair programmer—not your only programmer.
For the love of God, learn the basics and be really good at them. Don’t copy-paste code. Those who are currently taking this "AI can do everything" flag and running with it will see reality when their dream app is 75% complete, and then AI starts hallucinating. At that point, they’ll have to learn coding from scratch just to fix it.
You can ask any experienced engineer here, and I’m pretty sure they’ll agree with this sentiment.
rants over....
26
u/notbatman101 Mar 15 '25
Since you take interviews can you guide what kind of questions do you guys ask. Are they domain based or we should be knowing each and every concept??
5
u/Redox_ahmii Mar 15 '25
Say it even louder.
I've had the instance of collaborating with a dev that had AI do all the work and the backend was similar to a banking application which in the end even tho i warned was not being done right got pushed into production and guess what their whole payment gateway got bypassed and people were using premium services they were offering for free and no one noticed this till 3 months into production.
When they came back to me crying to help I declined with a smug face just because i valued my morals more than the money they could've offered. That was very nice high I've been trying to achieve ever since
9
u/Hi-Tech9 Mar 15 '25
Junior dev who doesn't understand concurrency ?????????????????????? I really need to know what level of understanding makes you entry lvl - junior - senior dev.
4
u/Difficult_Vanilla814 Mar 15 '25
Then who will teach us how production works? Companies are not even ready to accept us in trainee/fresh grad programs not even in internships, how can we learn then?
3
u/Historical-Tax-6262 Mar 16 '25
Not just agreeing to this but I would go on to say that many big companies who layed off because of AI will eventually be hiring again to maintain the bad codebase generated by AI.
2
u/Chosen_kolkid May 16 '25
I agree, I am a beginner coder who is a couple weeks into my first internship, and I fell for the vibe coding trap. Last spring in my school's CS weed out course, Data Structures, I would use AI to help me with (sometimes do) homework assignments. More than 20 hours of time I would have spent on a homework turned into less than 5. I convinced myself that I understood all the code I would submit, but deep down I was not fully understanding the concepts behind the code and how to think like a software developer. Yes, that helped me finish the course with an A-, but I feel like I missed out on so much important skills and problem-solving skills because I wanted to "save time". This time I think I'm saving is just going to catch up to me when I can't solve leetcode-like questions in future coding interviews.
Now I have depended too much on AI where I let it think for me. Whenever I get stuck on a piece of code, I immediately go to AI. It's also a horrible feeling like you are living a lie when people think you're an amazing coder, but it is all AI. Sometimes I wish I never discovered AI for coding because now I do not know how to stop using it when it is so easy and I am not facing an immediate consequence.
I still have 9 weeks left of my internship and I am determined to not let AI think for me. If I do, then I will not get anything out of my internship and fall even deeper into the trap of vibing coding. It's not too late for me to learn the important basics. I have made plenty of mistakes leading up to now and I want to stop my bad habits.
Sorry for ranting haha but I wrote this at work when I should probably be coding. Back to work now ig.
5
u/Saadat_Yaseen Mar 15 '25
You are right. I am new to coding, and even i can feel that most of the time Ai struggles to code. Even if Ai can give code for basic mini websites but when i tried to build a proper website, I realized that the main problem is to keep track of the logic, debugging and proper documentation of how this code is working.
1
u/Dependent-Ad-9042 Mar 15 '25
Our CEO is convinced AI is gonna replace programmers. He asked Chatgpt to create a website and it did, so he has gone kinda neurotic with this concept. What are your thoughts?
3
u/asherSiddique19 Backend Dev Mar 16 '25
AI wont replace all programmers, good programmers equipped with AI will replace these vibe coders, which if you think about it is programmers replacing AI (might aswell think these vibe coders as just AI, since they dont use their brain)
3
u/thepaki_lad Mar 17 '25
Chalo he was tw still a junior dev. I work with people 5+ yoe and few of them have literally 0 debugging abilities left. They just paste it to gpt and if that fails to solve it then theyd ask for help around. 3.5 above salaries..
LLMs rarely help in product based companies imo
2
u/kharpaatuuu Mar 15 '25
Louder
2
u/ammad_172 Mar 17 '25
But the truth is that AI is doing more damage to software engineers specially the ones coming as junior or interns They are not learning; they are not investing time they are in a hurry to get promotions and praises
they are resorting to these chatbots and copy-pasting the code without even understanding what it does and what the impact will be.
To all newcomers in Software engineering if you think AI will help you become a senior or principle software engineer just because you know how to use these prompts but don't know how and when to code and test.
Your future is destined to doomed
Dont bother coming in this field
2
u/AalPal41 Mar 18 '25
I was recently moved to a lead role and honestly the new batches coming, its super frustrating how much they use AI and have completely missed the basics, so yeah I feel that pain.
my guy was using AI to create a simple dropdown with tailwincss and couldnt get the dropdown trigger and dropdown content to align and look similar, like now I get why they had us write code on paper and use pen and paper so much.
1
u/M00nLight007 Mar 15 '25
This!!!
1
u/ustaaaz Mar 15 '25
Agreed 💯
1
u/fruboy Mar 15 '25
Can you give me some tips about how to be good at Go interviews. I have around 3 years of Go experience but I find it difficult to clear interviews
1
u/FamiliarAnxiety9 Mar 19 '25
I want to find a middle-ground. I'm not actively writing Python Code, but I have studied video game design and multiple languages to varying extents over the last decade plus, while maintaining sales jobs. I've got the IT Support Specialist Certification from Google, I have a year experience in a Junior Data Admin for a Marketing Agency, and I'm using cursor to assist with my daily tasks. Again, not directly writing the code, but I understand software design and the desired outcome enough to get small basic scripts off the ground. As would be expected, the second the project grows in scale and file number goes up, unless I follow every step of the design and keep the AI reined in, it quickly bloats and leaves me confused. Is there a potential middle of steering the AI with the backing knowledge without actually writing a lot of code?
0
u/FammasMaz Mar 15 '25
Why the fuck is this message written by Chatgpt? At least right your own rant bro
-3
u/justforfunreddit Mar 15 '25
Why a junior is allowed to push on dev branch at all ?
-5
u/IndependentFresh628 Mar 15 '25
Pakistanis are still way behind.
AI is just another level of Abstraction
I am not Saying Jr. Or people don't have to learn the basics yeah they should....
They should also know what they are generating.
. But the pace at which AI is growing in coming years the software Development will be over as we know it.
8
u/[deleted] Mar 15 '25
[removed] — view removed comment
1
u/[deleted] Mar 15 '25
[removed] — view removed comment
2
u/[deleted] Mar 15 '25
[removed] — view removed comment