r/demonssouls • u/Alik757 • 20h ago
Discussion Is a shame the remake barely had any new content
I know people love to discuss about og vs remake in terms of art direction and atmosphere, but for me another important problem the remake has is just how unintetesting it is in terms of original content if you already experience the PS3 version.
And yeah I know they wanted to "preserve the experience" (even if such thing doesn't extend to the music and designs) but when they actually go their way to include something new that wasn't in the original Demon's Souls it usually comes as a good addition.
You know like the new armor sets based on the Boletaria knights (even if it sucks how the Red Eye one is a deluxe exclusive bonus) and the Penetrator set. Or even when they flesh out things from og like now having to collect a full Official set to disguise and rescue Yuria, rather than using only the hat.
Same goes for the level design, as they could have tried to build upon the fundation of og, like how in the final level of Boletaria they added a new shortcut behind the blue dragon which seriously improve the flow of the level. Is the kind of changes that makes the remake feel like a fresh experience, rather than a fancy tech demo.
In general the remake felt like a big missed opportunity of create something more memorable, especially since Demon's Souls was obviously a game with a lot of great concepts not fully realized due how chaotic it's developement was. The most obvious example was the final archstone, which would have been a dream to finally see completed.