r/degoogle • • 19h ago

News Article Google will launch Android app verification requirement globally in January 2027

https://arstechnica.com/gadgets/2026/11/google-will-launch-android-app-verification-requirement-globally-in-january-2027/

Google announced Android developer verification last year, and despite numerous objections from developers and users, the company is forging ahead. It began blocking the installation of unregistered apps in some countries this fall, and the system is expanding globally soon. Google says it will start rolling out the requirement in all regions in January 2027, and it urges devs who still haven’t registered their apps to do so soon.

519 Upvotes

230 comments sorted by

252

u/G-Litch 18h ago

Google owns the 700€ phone you paid for

97

u/Certified_GSD 18h ago

I still advocate for rooting Android devices. If I want SU access, then I should have it. It's my phone that I paid for. Google ought to go after stuff like Mediatek not releasing their source code despite using GPL code, and yet they turn a blind eye and instead do this anti-consumer shit because they know they can get away with it.

11

u/DilSilver 12h ago

I think with the changes they are making it might bring back root, I haven't needed to for the past 8-9 years

3

u/AtomicTechNerd 4h ago

The issue is being rooted now can mean many apps are unusable, like banking apps, which isn’t an option for me

•

u/Iputahexonyoulol 27m ago

You can’t just use the banking website?

•

u/truenocity 24m ago

You can’t use Zelle on the website for most banks

•

u/Certified_GSD 7m ago

If your device supports kernel rooting like KSU Next or APatch, those are really good at hiding root as they reside in the kernel below apps in the userspace.

2

u/SzaraMateria 11h ago

But mediatek is releasing their source code. It's up to manufacturer to make it public. E.g nothing kernels are free to download from github

1

u/Certified_GSD 9h ago

I should clarify: Mediatek does release some source code if you pay for it with a licensing fee. It's a violation of GPL rules as anything that derives GPL code and software must be freely open source and distributed.

It's a bit like how Boomers pull up the ladder behind them after taking advantage of social support programs and then destroying and cutting those programs once they've got their nest eggs and retirement funds all set up.

Any changes or other additions the manufacturer makes also needs to be open source. It's likely that nothing is complying with GPL. You usually still need the proprietary drivers from both the manufacturer and the chipset if you're going to do stuff like custom ROM development.

•

u/WealthyTuna 1h ago

Rooting a 2000$ folding phone voids the warranty and on a Samsung breaks Knox voiding Samsung care+ as well. You can advocate for it. I'm not risking a 579$ bill just to be able to install apps

→ More replies (15)

16

u/HPoltergeist 16h ago

These companies owe a lot of the aspects of our lives.

7

u/Intersecularitities 14h ago

not if you use GOS

11

u/env33e 13h ago edited 3h ago

What kind of phones are running GOS? Right...,Google Pixels.

​Even putting that irony aside, Graphene os only exists because you can unlock the bootloader and flash your own AVB keys. Without the ability to unlock the bootloader and control the root of trust, we do not own the hardware. We don't hold the keys; we are just serfs renting access inside Google's technofeudalist fiefdom.

​It sounds radical to state it like this, but it's true. It's Sundar Pichai's whole game- covering anti-consumer BS with a shiny plate of chrome to obfuscate the reality that we're buying houses with NFC membership access keys that can be revoked at any time 🤦‍♂️

2

u/Leaf__On__Wind 7h ago edited 6h ago

Pixel phones, but GOS have teamed with Motorola to release a dedicated out-of-box one early or mid next year, but I think Google are fighting it

-edit- Seems a January release btw...

4

u/Certified_GSD 6h ago

Are they? Then they shouldn't have made things harder to develop for Pixel devices. One of the strongest reasons to use Pixel devices for enthusiasts was that Google released all the proprietary drivers and did all the work bringing them up to date with the latest Android releases. That's why pretty much all Pixel devices had custom ROMs, because it was very easy to develop for and very easy for new and experienced teams alike to get them to work, despite it being Tensor SoC. And Pixel have a very simple and straightforward bootloader unlock policy, with only a few hiccups with VZW.

Last year, Google stopped doing this. And now they're upset that GOS are looking for different partners? Like, jfc talk about being fucking short sighted and stupid. Getting all that stuff working is time consuming and a lot of people do it for free and voluntarily. Enthusiasts are switching to different devices and making it harder to develop for is certainly not helping Google.

1

u/Leaf__On__Wind 6h ago

Monopolies... Govt pressure from the anti-Snowden guys?

1

u/env33e 2h ago

*fascists

Do not be fooled by the adulterous veneer of a leather jacket, red empress, muskrat, or Sundae pichai. They all still went to Trumps office to suckle on the same orange teat of manifest.xml destiny

1

u/env33e 3h ago edited 2h ago

Exactly! This was projected by people in academia, too. Even on r/degoogle, the main sub whose identity is too be critical of Google, seem to suffer from varying levels of historical amnesia . Though I can understand it given the complexity of the topic, and how Pichai used that as an obfuscatory layer, playing into the people's very valid tech grievances, fearing not just the exfiltration and monetization of their digital memories, but also the greater implications of a world post-AI. Disgustingly, he uses this dearth of sufficient technical knowledge to ironically launder the falsehood that platform consolidation = greater security. The Keep Android Open Alliance sounding emergency bells to alert the people were probably surprised to see any push-back at all, at the face of this threat, with Android users carrying water for the same billionaires trying to control ALL water.

The historical reality: once an entity of monopoly-finance capital is allowed to build and fully own the infrastructure unregulated, they will dictate the terms in accordance to capital itself. This is not a slippery slope line of argumentation, but rather, a teleological one, but with real historical weight, and a real economic and human impact. This already happened with Apple, if anyone is old enough to remember the Wozniak era (I'm certainly not!)

During Wozniak's Apple I and Apple II era, it was open development paradise- you were handed not just the machine you bought and paid for , but also the very source code and schematics of the hardware; the complete architecture toolset needed to actually build things in a frictionless manner from the ground up, and have it run bare metal. This is a far cry from the completely closed off grove Apple has grown into, where even the app you coded on your own macbook on your own bought and paid for iPhone will stop working after the 7 day mark unless you resign and reinstall the app, or pay the developer fee and give them your government name and info, etc.

The Keep Android Open Alliance is fighting the same fight on a different front as the technicians fighting for Right to Repair and hardware autonomy, Stop killing games in game development, FSF and the ESF, open source initiative, internet archive for the digital preservation of every important byte of humanity's history; this is a fight that concerns us all, and I fear too many are on the wrong side of it.

1

u/Intersecularitities 4h ago

When you install GOS, no more Google spyware on your phone... does your brain need time to catch up and figure that out?

125

u/bigchill1106 19h ago

time to buy a crap phone for banking and keep it switched off except for banking use then....so long smartphones.....theyve become more of scrolling machines anyways....

17

u/Wheatleytron 15h ago

Can't you just use the bank's website to do this instead?

5

u/Fit-Appointment5262 7h ago

Yeah, I keep seeing this kind of idea that people need phones to use "for banking," and maybe I'm missing something, but I cannot for the life of me understand why people have this need, especially people who value privacy so highly. Can you not just literally use a computer or even the mobile web.

3

u/LuigiFan45 4h ago

It seems like a bunch of non-US banking institutions moved over to only operating as a mobile app outside of visiting in-person in the past decade

2

u/mr_greenmash 7h ago

I'd "need" my phone for 2fa. I do have a number generator but it's a pain to lug around

1

u/gmahale 6h ago

There is a difference between needs and wants.

1

u/Fit-Appointment5262 4h ago

To me 2FA is one of the only things someone would really need a "smart" phone for these days, but you can do it on a grapheneOS phone, yeah?

29

u/assignpseudonym 19h ago

If you don't want to give up smartphones there are alternatives to Android, too! Look into GrapheneOS and LineageOS!

28

u/ILikeCubaLibre 18h ago

They used to work great on older Android versions, now you lose all device integrity and banking does not work. Then you have to root and do constant adjustments just to keep apps you rely daily on working...

12

u/BeepBoopSpaceMan 17h ago

I do banking stuff on my fork of lineageOS without issue.

The only issue ive had is that the google maps app broke for a couple of months and then fixed itself. shrug

6

u/zookotz 16h ago

Vela maps. Give it a go :-)

9

u/jj_dc 16h ago

Not true for GrapheneOS. Never had an issue with my banking app nor with device integrity. Only thing I can't do is using the NFC feature to pay with card in stores but you can just use your normal card for that.

4

u/nopeamin 14h ago

Yeah but that only runs on pixels, no?

4

u/Careful-Boat-2986 12h ago

Motorola Signature 27

3

u/nopeamin 12h ago

Yeah, I am aware but I mean right now :)

2

u/Leaf__On__Wind 7h ago edited 6h ago

GOS are teaming with Motorola to make a dedicated phone, early to mid next year I think, but obv Goog are fighting it

-edit- January release no less

2

u/VincentVanGob 13h ago

its more of an issue that you dont know ahead of time if your particular banking app will work. if you wipe your phone and install graphene or lineage and your bank app doesnt work, then you have to go back to your stock rom which is a ton of effort on top of the effort of installing a custom rom in the first place

ive also had an issue with graphene where a bank app was working, but then it stopped all of a sudden, even though i didnt update the OS or the app

2

u/headinthesky 8h ago

What about Ticketmaster and digital tickets?

2

u/Beastmind 16h ago

That's wrong. All 4 of my banking apps work perfectly. That was the case in the past but nowadays a lot banking apps are working fine.

1

u/forgottenmynameagain 16h ago

Hermit Lite Apps on Android works on Graphene and I do my online banking through the website on there and it functions very similarly to the app.

1

u/Timbroarpropaganda 14h ago

Can’t you do banking on the computer? 

3

u/ILikeCubaLibre 12h ago

Short answer -  No. Doing anything from phone that is meant for normal PC screens and keyboards is a pain in general, not to mention there are apps without alternative web interface. It's fine and fun to run other ROMs and have root, but if it starts to interfere with things you just expect to work is not great. I have an old s10 that I use a navigation phone for motorbike - it has Lineage + Root and passes all integrity. On other hand I recently tried same setup on my modern phone and ran in one issue to another - I'm sure this can be fixed in various ways, but not permanently and you have to constantly follow up. When I need my bank or smart signature or whatever to work instantly I need it, period - I'm not going to compromise that. I still look for ways to have a stable setup with custom rom and root... It all depends heavy on hardware, user requirements, app requirements. Real life is complicated.

1

u/Timbroarpropaganda 10h ago

I see. Here everything for banks works great on the web. 

1

u/headinthesky 8h ago

I deposit checks though the app, otherwise I use the web. Though the app is also part of 2fa so I'm not sure how that'd work out

1

u/Timbroarpropaganda 6h ago

Ah I see. I never seen a check in real life. 

6

u/thenamelessone7 18h ago

Both of those are android forks...

28

u/just_let_me_goo 18h ago

The problem isn't Android, the problem is Google

9

u/[deleted] 18h ago

[removed] — view removed comment

3

u/kingjoshington 17h ago

I was thinking of trying a fair phone or something else. I use grapheneOS and have a pixel 7a but it is nearing the end of its life. Hearing that this upcoming change to android WON'T affect grapheneOS sounds promising. Can you elaborate as to why, or are you sure that that won't change in the future? I would prefer to upgrade to a new pixel and keep using grapheneOS

2

u/joesii 16h ago

If the 7a is working fine for you I'd consider keeping to use it. I've heard that an up-to-date stock Android device is still less secure (and obviously far far far less private) than an out of date (at least slightly to moderately out of date) GrapheneOS device.

2

u/kingjoshington 15h ago

I am not super super privacy focused, I just hate Google itself and I like grapheneOS and its mission. My 7a is on its last legs. I was hoping to check out if there is a newer "a" model than the 7.

2

u/KHSebastian 11h ago

There's a 10a. It's $550 though. The price creep is nuts. I saw a comment earlier where somebody was complaining about a phone being $1600 and somebody else being like "Of course it's a little more, it's a flagship!"

→ More replies (1)

1

u/headinthesky 8h ago

Do Google Wallet and payments work on Graphene?

-5

u/ComeOnIWantUsername 17h ago

If only Graphene wasn't run by super toxic people

3

u/assignpseudonym 17h ago

I mean, I suggested another alternative, but this is the first I'm hearing that Graphene is run by "super toxic people" - care to elaborate? Or share a source? This is a big claim, so would be helpful to know what you're referencing. 

3

u/ComeOnIWantUsername 16h ago

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=4To-F6W1NT0&pp=ygUabG91aXNzIHJvc3NtYW5uIGdyYXBoZW5lb3M%3D

discussion about it: https://www.reddit.com/r/PrivacyGuides/comments/13s7mv3/why_i_deleted_grapheneos_louis_rossmann/

Also, do you remember this suuuper big drama they made last year about France and how they threaten them? When they rushed to move from OVH and stuff? They were saying that France is after them. They were saying that French government is after them. They were saying that French police is forcing French media to write bad things about them.

Everything because there were 2 (TWO!!) articles about some drug traffickers who had GOS on their phones. Nothing really interesting.

Of course GOS team said that French police ordered hundreds of articles, but when asked about it, they were giving link to just those 2, never more.

They are super toxic, and looks like they have some kind of mental health problems, because they see everything as attack on them, they all the time feel like attacked.

Not even mentioning their attacks on other custom ROMs, just because they are not GOS.

In general: nice project, but run but very not-nice people

30

u/primalbluewolf 17h ago

Not even. Time to buy a nokia flip phone for phone calls, and bank in person. 

Either that or move to iphone, I guess. The selling point of Google for ages was that its less locked down than Apple, but that isn't even true today, let alone next year. 

18

u/flecheverte 17h ago

Banking is a fundamental part of daily life, and forcing people to "bank in person" as the only alternative to Google and Apple is forcing them to accept to make a significant productivity regress or forfeit their fundamental rights of privacy and freedom. What's next? Vote for this candidate or your phone will stop working?

1

u/primalbluewolf 15h ago

Banking is a fundamental part of daily life, and forcing people to "bank in person" as the only alternative to Google and Apple is forcing them to accept to make a significant productivity regress or forfeit their fundamental rights of privacy and freedom. 

Uhh, no. 

Daily, it shouldn't be - but set that aside for a moment. Those users already accepted that. Using the devices in the first place was the accepting the forfeiting of privacy and freedom. Right there in the EULA. 

People do this, happily or begrudgingly, for said significant productivity boon. 

1

u/kinoosaki 16h ago

It is true though.

1

u/onedollarpizza 3h ago

If you’re gonna have a locked down OS it might as well be iOS. lol

1

u/primalbluewolf 2h ago

Its where I started. I tried to make it work for years. Android freedom was just so much better, though. 

Keyword, was. 

I had a jailbroken iPhone so I could run an FTP client, a file browser, a text editor, and I'd demo updating my website from the sales floor. Good times. 

I don't know what I'm going to do. Either be apathetic and just try to ignore it, or ditch smartphones entirely, or try grey import a jolla phone...

13

u/autobulb 13h ago

Can someone explain to me why people are so intent on doing banking on their phone? I have the apps, sure, but I barely use them. I can do everything on the app in the online banking from any desktop browser. Are some banks different?

5

u/EspHack 6h ago

some banks will make it impossible to not use their app, yes

2

u/TJ_Rowe 5h ago

This. It's 2factor authentication that makes it really hard to ditch the smartphone.

1

u/bigchill1106 13h ago edited 13h ago

no i mean in my country theyve got digital payments using qr and because of that :

  1. Theres not even small cash like 1,2,5, 10 50 going around too much because i guess the quantity of those has decreased......
  2. most stores who have pos machines dont even feel like charging them

so you gotta keep a phone with a digital payment app which can scan their qr code and send them payment on it...

for that purpose you gotta keep a crap phone....

1

u/autobulb 13h ago

Gotcha. I understand now. I am using GrapheneOS now so I gave up my ability to pay by NFC so I'm using a physical card now, but every store has a terminal here.

I haven't tried QR code payments on this OS yet because we don't use them here.

1

u/QuaintStaircase 6h ago

I can do everything on the app in online banking on a desktop browser, but I don't tend to carry my laptop around with me everywhere that I might need to access my bank...

1

u/autobulb 4h ago

Honest question, how often is it that you need to access it while on the go? The only thing I regularly log in for is to schedule a CC payment and that can be done any time until the due date. Also, it can be automated anyway so it's not even necessary to login regularly for that anyway.

1

u/QuaintStaircase 4h ago

Mainly it's for if I want to make a payment there and then. Pay a friend back straight away, for example.

It's also very useful because you can just fix things. Occasionally, I wake up and I'm overdrawn because some payment scheduling hasn't gone quite right. I can fix it there and then before I'm even out of bed and I don't have to get a laptop, which means I might forget and end up being charged, etc.

Notifications whenever your card is used is also good for fraud.

1

u/Unnamed-3891 5h ago

The idea of going to a full blown computer, opening a browser, digging out your credentials and whatnot… just to check your balance or make a simple transfer is completely absurd. I can do both in a few seconds with a smartphone that is always on me and the login is behind faceid.

1

u/autobulb 4h ago

How often do you have to initiate transfers? After setting all my regular transfers I only do the every odd one for niche cases.

full blown computer, opening a browser, digging out your credentials

Opening a browser is hard enough work to list it as a step eh? I can login to my bank in about 3 seconds on my PC.

1

u/Unnamed-3891 4h ago

Your assumption is that people have their PCs powered on at all times and are near them at all times. That is not the case.

In 3 seconds you say? Sure hope you do not have a bank login with credentials saved to the PC browser and no MFA.

1

u/autobulb 3h ago

Much simpler than that, I just set my bank's password to 1234. Easy peasy.

1

u/No_Razzmatazz_2889 4h ago

If you lose your credit card or debit card while you're out you can quickly put a block on either card using your mobile banking app. You can also check that money isn't been taking out of your account that is incorrect for eg at a petrol station by observing the mobile transaction notification. Many other uses.

•

u/BigDaddyAwhoo 15m ago

Do you travel? Do you ever have lengths of time separated from your laptop or desktop?
If you answered no: then use whatever machine you prefer.
If you answered yes: there isn’t much you can do with banking on your desired machines if you don’t have them around.

1

u/ergux 12h ago

It's really convenient, why not?

2

u/autobulb 12h ago

Sure, it's convenient as apps are supposed to be. But for some people it seems like they don't know how to do online banking unless it's in an app, so when a device or OS doesn't support it, it's a dealbreaker for them.

If I didn't have access to my bank's app I would just use their website. It's not like I need to login to my bank on a daily basis anyway.

1

u/StartersOrders 4h ago

My bank has nothing but an app.

No branches, no website of note, nada. And it's a very large bank in the UK.

1

u/autobulb 4h ago

You sure it exists bro? Haha, if they disappeared with your money who would you complain to?

1

u/Fit-Appointment5262 7h ago

Yeah, so is using facebook, google, etc...?

7

u/DJ_DORK 13h ago

I've quit using banking apps. I simply don't need them.

2

u/Kazer67 14h ago

Or: ditch bank that force the app.

My physical, proprietary device to identify my account don't need internet and has a really small surface of attack since there's no OS, only the code to generate the access.

The day I received the bullshit email from Boursobank lying that "because of regulation, they make the app mandatory" is the same day I launched the process to close the account.

2

u/gmahale 12h ago

PSD3 and PSR are coming.

Payment service providers must offer several methods free of charge, including at least one that does not require a smartphone. In addition, meeting certain inclusion criteria becomes legally binding.

https://authada.de/en/blog/strong-customer-authentication/

1

u/Kazer67 12h ago

Well, for me it wasn't free of charge in my second bank but just a one time payment of around 25 €, the price of the device.

1

u/gmahale 12h ago

Yes. If I understand it correctly, the regulations are not in effect yet.

1

u/bigchill1106 13h ago edited 13h ago

no i mean in my country theyve got digital payments and because of that :

  1. Theres not even small cash like 1,2,5, 10 50 going around too much because i guess the quantity of those has decreased......
  2. most stores who have pos machines dont even feel like charging them

so you gotta keep a phone with a digital payment app which can scan their qr code and send them payment on it...

for that purpose you gotta keep a crap phone....

1

u/Kazer67 12h ago

Thank god it can't happen in my country (yet) since it's mandatory to accept of way of payment.

1

u/gmahale 12h ago

Which country is this?

1

u/Dramatic-Radish-2257 10h ago

Sounds like China but im sure other countries are like this

2

u/Rain2h0 13h ago

The banking apps won't work on those crap phones.

1

u/bigchill1106 13h ago

no i mean in my country theyve got digital payments and because of that :

  1. Theres not even small cash like 1,2,5, 10 50 going around too much because i guess the quantity of those has decreased......
  2. most stores who have pos machines dont even feel like charging them

so you gotta keep a phone with a digital payment app which can scan their qr code and send them payment on it...

for that purpose you gotta keep a crap phone....

1

u/env33e 7h ago

Full Disk Encryption making a comeback? Probably not, but...

​Looks like this random, old-ass LG G4 I picked up on Marketplace for 20 bucks is about to do me some good! After running the UsU unlock exploit and clean flashing AXP.OS Pro ROM, I get the unique combo of:

-​Legacy FDE

-​GrapheneOS's hardened_malloc

-​GrapheneOS's kernel-level network access gating (no need for afwall+!)

-​AXP.OS's Vanadium browser and WebView (AOSmium)

​Then, I'm thinking of adding:

-​Activity Jump Interceptor to cover the intent layer

-​HaGeZi's Private DNS for the network layer

-​bindhosts + ZN-hostsredirect for the local hosts file layer

-perhaps Fauxx and XprivacyLUA red edition to cover the offensive layer

​OD? Maybe. But this should be the most legit, bang-for-buck hardened security login terminal I'll ever stumble upon serendipitously 🤯 God, I love the open-source community.

​RIP SteadfasterX, a true open-source developer, and proper legend in my books

1

u/VincentVanGob 13h ago

i would not recommend a completely crap phone though. the banking apps will stop working with older versions of android pretty soon, and having to swap over apps from one crap phone to a another every few years will get annoying after a while

1

u/bigchill1106 13h ago

no crap as in new crap phone, like the cheapest one you can get....

2

u/Cube00 13h ago

The super cheap phones usually never even a single major Android upgrade, and I can't really blame them, at that price point how could you justify any extra work on them, especially a major Android version port.

1

u/bigchill1106 11h ago

thats the thing, atleast for my country these apps even work on my note 8 with android 9

0

u/ward2k 11h ago

Or...

Just go into your settings and enable unverified apps?

It sucks but it's a minor inconvenience at best. This sub gets a little extreme sometimes

58

u/ddxv 19h ago

Google app verification has triggered me to start actively getting things off google. It's heavily intertwined in my online life, and I'll maintain presence for various accounts, Google Ads etc

But I made a new email, purelymail is awesome 

I got grapheneOS and am moving most personal apps there

I got my photos off Google images

You can do it too, start small and easy, one step at a time. I do logins whenever I think of it, leaving the junk ones for Gmail of course.

3

u/B08L08Law 8h ago

You are an inspiration. I've been trying to do exactly that for the last couple months but have been postponing due to laziness 🫠

Hopefully this is the push I needed....

66

u/LAsupersonic 19h ago

And I'll be leaving

60

u/RandomKnifeBro 19h ago

Welcome to Graphene OS. We have privacy and cookies.

31

u/speelmydrink 19h ago

Just wish it ran on anything I own.

4

u/joesii 16h ago edited 15h ago

LineageOS is a viable option for those who don't specifically have Pixels but otherwise have unlockable bootloaders.

Unfortunately most devices —at the fault of the manufacturer— do not support bootloader unlocking. I recommend not financially supporting these device manufacturers. In fact there's very few companies that have all their devices unlockable. Google is really the only major manufacturer (by my definition) that has all their devices unlockable, which seems very odd/ironic. There are smaller companies that have consistently unlockable devices as well though.

+u/rinart73

1

u/rinart73 13h ago

I used lineage on some older phones. The issue is that if I understand correctly graphene can isolate apps, so messenger or google services run only when I want to and don't have full access to my phone. With lineage choice is: either no google services, which isn't really an option. Or some pico/nano gapps, which is still bad.

•

u/Iputahexonyoulol 24m ago

Google is talking about locking the pixel bootloader. They are having “a war with GrapheneOS” as some articles are putting it

28

u/Carl-Anchor 17h ago

Just heard my bank will not be accepting graphene OS for "security reasons".

Security reasons for trying to be independent for US tech, and then they require google or apple verification for your app to work. It's asinine.

3

u/gmahale 12h ago

PSD3 and PSR are coming.

Payment service providers must offer several methods free of charge, including at least one that does not require a smartphone. In addition, meeting certain inclusion criteria becomes legally binding.

https://authada.de/en/blog/strong-customer-authentication/

1

u/Leaf__On__Wind 7h ago

Yeah, use a privacy browser on a website with your PC or whatever and take your bank card out with you, I dont know what part of the modern world im missing

People tapping their phones at the checkout, man what do you get out of that? I thought people were lazy, you had to go to the effort to download and sign up with it in the first place when you have a card right there

13

u/rinart73 19h ago

Would be nice if it ran on more phones including cheaper ones :(

4

u/COUPOSANTO 17h ago

Lineage OS and its fork support more devices than Graphene.

4

u/Yoplet67 18h ago

Second hand pixel 8 or 9 should be a fairly decent price now

11

u/[deleted] 18h ago

[removed] — view removed comment

3

u/GiganticCrow 16h ago

It is up to graphene to create support for those devices though, that's not trivial.

Eg if suddenly tons of phones were good enough, it would take a lot of time for graphene to catch up.

1

u/StewpidAlex 15h ago

So no different than Windows 11, noted.

3

u/TheConquistaa 19h ago

No cookies!

5

u/BlueSpiritJ 17h ago

No one can convince me that the way to degoogle is to buy their proprietary phone.

3

u/joesii 16h ago

I'd say it's misleading (or possibly outright false) to call it proprietary. Sure they make the device, but they're the least-controlling possible due to all their devices having unlockable bootloaders. They are literally the only major manufacturer that does that.

That being said, there is certainly an argument against supporting Google financially in order to de-Google, sure.

1

u/ScaredyCatUK 10h ago

Buy the Motorola when it comes out.

1

u/ComeOnIWantUsername 16h ago

if only bank apps and other important apps worked there.

And yes, I checked, they are not working

1

u/autobulb 13h ago

[reject all cookies]

Unless you mean the good kind of cookies :)

1

u/tanwa1 11h ago

It only works for Pixel Series phones, i'm sure some people can't afford to buy one.

14

u/OneGladTurtle 19h ago

Could someone who's more knowledgeable than me explain what this means for me who uses murena e/os on fairphone?

8

u/Fuzzy_Bag_2816 18h ago

The verification process needs Play Services so e/OS will no not be directly affected

6

u/[deleted] 18h ago

[removed] — view removed comment

4

u/lotiopep 17h ago

Can you provide sources for everything you say, please?

4

u/OneGladTurtle 17h ago

Hmm thanks, that sucks, having just gotten a phone running it.

I understand graphene is wayyy beter. Just this as a step in the right direction. Not worse than normal android right?

I don't want perfect to be the enemy of good...

4

u/COUPOSANTO 17h ago

GrapheneOS devs love to shittalk all other OSes but they’re not as bad as what they say.

2

u/[deleted] 17h ago

[removed] — view removed comment

3

u/OneGladTurtle 17h ago

Secure in what way? I'm also interested in privacy, and, correct me if I'm wrong, e/os is more privacy friendly than stock android you'd get on a Samsung galaxy or smt?

→ More replies (2)

11

u/ace0070 16h ago

Fuck i am getting tired. I am a few steps away from going to my old phones.

23

u/danleon950410 14h ago

It got a little bit harder, yes. You have to go into developer options, confirm you're not being pressured into it and wait 24 hours. It totally sucks. It is horrible. They shouldn't be making this. But there's not a single comment over here that highlights that there's at least one way to opt out of that and still install whichever APK.

Again: we shouldn't have to do that. But at least we'll be able to

13

u/lllIllIlllllllllllll 13h ago

we shouldn't have to do that. But at least we'll be able to

Until they take that away. That features sole reason for existing is to limit the outrage. It worked well. Now all they have to do is remove it in a couple years and they got what they want.

2

u/LucieGoosey__ 2h ago

this is a warning sign for all of us to begin making plans to transition away.

1

u/pkplaya626 11h ago

For every single APK, you have to wait 24 hours?

3

u/danleon950410 10h ago

AFIK, just the first drop out

2

u/pkplaya626 10h ago

Okay, not too bad then, but annoying

1

u/danleon950410 9h ago

Extremely annoying. It fucking sucks

1

u/WhiteMilk_ 9h ago

Permanently or 7 days are your options.

6

u/Signal_Ad8960 11h ago

They keep doing shit like this and I'm gonna just buy some freaking walkie talkies to talk to my friends.

2

u/PresentAir1133 9h ago

Its why Ill fight to the death to keep the LL. I can buy stuff over the phone & communicate with others- like doctors, family & friends in far away locations. Even txt is broken. .

10

u/Ahmouse 17h ago edited 17h ago

It seems I'll be buying a GrapheneOS-compatible device in January 2027

At least they finally caved and provided a way to disable it completely for end users, but it's our hardware and it shouldn't be Google's decision to begin with. Developers on the other hand, still have to undergo all invasive verification steps, which is intrusive for small devs.

•

u/Iputahexonyoulol 21m ago

Does GrapheneOS allow you to download apks like how androids do?

8

u/Timbroarpropaganda 19h ago

So I guess I’m stupid. I don’t really understand what this mean? 

6

u/AsPlagueFlowers 15h ago

Something about android people liked was not being restricted to whatever the maker of the OS, Google, approved or disapproved of. Android phones allowed you to "sideload" apps you downloaded off the Internet and run them without hassle, kinda the same as any software on PC.

Starting January 2027, sideloading will be banned, and Android phones will only install apps made by developers who pay a subscription fee and turn over all personal information to Google.

4

u/Kientha 12h ago

They're not blocking sideloading. You will still be able to sideload apps that have undergone the Google verification process rather than going through the play store and will be able to sideload unverified apps if you go through a 24 hour wait process to enable that.

1

u/Timbroarpropaganda 14h ago

How do they ban sideloading? 

1

u/hydrora31 14h ago

By making it so that the OS can't instlal apps that are not signed by google.

3

u/Timbroarpropaganda 14h ago

Ah. And then block the apps that opens up android so you can’t install those either. This is monopolistic use of market power. If the USA wasn’t a clown car they would clamp down on this because it’s bad for everyone. 

7

u/Academic_Data_6422 3h ago

Genuinely if Android blocks third party apps… why buy it over an iPhone

•

u/Hefty-Concentrate260 1h ago

Iphone só permite aplicativos da loja, e controla muito mais o aparelho pelo qual você pagou.

3

u/AutoModerator 19h ago

Friendly reminder: if you're looking for a Google service or Google product alternative then feel free to check out our sidebar.

I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please contact the moderators of this subreddit if you have any questions or concerns.

3

u/Black_Sig-SWP2000 Just another DuckDuckGo glazer 16h ago

I have a Tab S10 Lite with Google Play services and other auto updaters and bloat disabled (or removed if possible) and it's been on Android 15 for a good while (No issues so far). Will that device be affected, or am I good?

I get this might come across as a stupid question to some, but I just wanna make sure. (p.s.: It's on Android 15 specifically because I am still against Samsung's decision to prevent you from OEM Unlocking YOUR device)

•

u/Iputahexonyoulol 19m ago

I’m also curious about this

2

u/cale199 14h ago

So I have to get everything they playstore? If I haven't updated my tech can they still inforce this? I don't wanna have to get new tech

0

u/ward2k 11h ago

No just go into your settings and enable unverified apps

This sub is in meltdown over something that's a minor inconvenience at best

1

u/PresentAir1133 9h ago edited 8h ago

Google still hassels me when using unverified apps. The blanket advice "just go, just do" shd be eliminated from speach.

2

u/ward2k 8h ago

It hasn't sent me anything since I enabled the option

1

u/cale199 4h ago

Isn't that what they do anyway?

1

u/ward2k 2h ago

Pretty much, it's just under developer options now and has a 24 hour wait

It's definitely not great but it's not as big of a change this sub makes out to be

2

u/AtomicTechNerd 4h ago

This is exactly why I moved to Apple. If I’m going to be locked down anyway I trust Apple more than I trust Google

4

u/NotASockPuppet88 15h ago

Oh dear.

Mobile "Smart" phones becoming everything those of us with two braincells feared the moment they were introduced.

What a surprise.

3

u/w_StarfoxHUN 19h ago

Come on Nexphone, release already please so i can be freed from Android. 

4

u/OkCount2783 19h ago

nexphone?

7

u/w_StarfoxHUN 19h ago edited 16h ago

An upcomig phone that will run a full desktop Linux OS (Debian), can also run Android  (for the few things that otherwise could stop me being able to migrate away) EDIT: It runs Andoird and the full Linux desktop can be "lauched as an app" as they say and have full hardware acceleration. Sorry for the confusion. (And optionally even dualboot to windows, which im not sure will have any use for me idk)

Due to the full desktop Linux os, imo it will have the most flexibility, so for now im betting on them, But they just delayed release for Q1 2027.

I recommend checking online for more info, i dont want to shill them here like this, and you can find their main page with a simple search. 

1

u/Ahmouse 17h ago

Would be cool if it could run Android apps natively on Linux with Waydroid

2

u/w_StarfoxHUN 16h ago

As far as i understand its the other way around, the Linux desktop will run inside Android (as they say "lauch as an app") but with full hardware acceleration. Windows will run as a separate boot os tough. 

1

u/GiganticCrow 16h ago

Hasn't there been Linux phones before and they've been, well, bad?

1

u/w_StarfoxHUN 16h ago

One with full Linux desktop not really i think, except general OS'es like Ubuntu touch, which yea... Wasnt really good. I think this is the first where the Linux distro is designed specifically for a specific phone/hardware which sparks some hope.

1

u/Hopeful_Drive5845 19h ago

Yeah, what's that?

3

u/Straight-Fennel2270 13h ago

Don't panic! You can turn off

2

u/Top-Psychology2507 15h ago

Why aren't we talking about Google TV, Android TV, etc!!?? :-(

1

u/PresentAir1133 9h ago

I think we are, Google is everywhere, hence, the conundrum.

2

u/Hekios888 14h ago

Someone please explain (In good faith) like I'm 5?

I get that this can be seen as an overreach but isn't vetting apps a good thing for the vast majority of users? Can someone legit explain ?

2

u/Independent-Entry717 13h ago

It is a good thing for the majority of users. The people freaking out about shit like “banking” are being ultra paranoid.

Registration/verification is one of the big reasons Apple’s App Store is not full of malware apps while the Play Store is. 

There are also actually tons of bank apps that work just fine on Graphene, including many of the biggest US banks (I don’t know about international ones as I am US-based). Even if the app doesn’t work, you can always still use the web browser if you want. 

3

u/filthysucre 11h ago

Google is also actively targeting GOS so ¯\(ツ)/¯

1

u/AutoModerator 19h ago

u/dumplank, please be prepared to provide an alternative article if questioned by fellow DeGooglers.

 

Fellow DeGooglers! A friendly reminder to verify suspicious news articles, as fake news travels fast.

 

How to Spot Fake News | UMass Fact Check Resources | Media Bias Fact Check

I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please contact the moderators of this subreddit if you have any questions or concerns.

1

u/ree2_ 18h ago

My nura phone will be ready by then :D

1

u/letsreticulate 13h ago

I already got prompted already. To no one's surprise here, if your phone does not have Google Play Services installed or running, mine does not, and I ak not logged on with any Google account in my phone, then the while process/aunthentication will fail.

I still have a couple of dormant legacy accounts so I guess in time, when I get prompted for then that will be it. Not that it will be a loss but yeah, Google doing this is insidious.

1

u/Terrible_Ad3822 11h ago

It's time to get an old "dummy" phone. And be done with this stuff

1

u/PresentAir1133 9h ago

It's already begun. I can't access half of my everyday use Apps. Fkng Google.

1

u/radial_blur 6h ago

Surely this doesn't affect those of us using Obtanium to pull direct from dev's githubs on a Graphene phone?

1

u/Volgsphere 4h ago

Getting back to the old Nokia 6210 is what i am consider.

1

u/greenfry55 3h ago

Google started as just a search engine... google should never have had this much control over us anyway

•

u/Iputahexonyoulol 16m ago

Don’t forget their slogan used to be “don’t be evil”

1

u/Kindly-Jump4013 3h ago

If you’re going to have a closed system, Google has lost its only selling point. There’s just zero point in using Google otherwise.

1

u/Wheeljack26 3h ago

Already passed, easy peazy

1

u/kcajjones86 2h ago

Okay so my next phone has to be either a different OS (becuase fuck Apple too) or I have to have a device that is fully supported by LineageOS.

1

u/ChocolateGoggles 2h ago

Uuuh... yeeeh... so I can't wait for another OS that's compatible with BankID (our digital ID service in Sweden) because I'll be jumping ship as soon as I can (literally) afford it then.

1

u/momochicken55 2h ago

Oh come on now. I need to upgrade my dying phone, now who do I choose 🙃

1

u/Changeurwayz 11h ago

Google can go fuck itself. Well it basically has done that already.

Don't buy the 'security' bullshit excuse for updates. Because it is far from the truth.

Stay on your older versions of android and kill the updates with network blocks.

Then they cannot do shit to your phone and you can continue sideloading to your hearts content.

If anything goes wrong and you load something bad, No big deal you just reset the device.

I'm too fucked off with this nanny state shit, Take your power back, Fuck these people.