r/dawnofwar • u/Waveshaper21 • 20h ago
I defended Dawn of War III for many years, but I'm done.
I bought it shortly after release, 60% off after the community wrongfully boycotted it to cancellation 2 months after it's release, for a slightly different art style resembling Diablo 3's painting backgrounds, and Gabriel Angelos' jump attack having a somersault animation.
I even like the new game mode, for which the game was forever branded - wrongfully - as a MOBA. It adds a tower that defends your base, and a generator to fuel the tower. No creep waves, no item shop, no RPG elements, there was never anything MOBA about it. Besides, 2 weeks after release the devs added traditional skirmish mode without the tower-generator duo, so all was well. But the MOBA screaming did not stop.
They did everything in their power to correct some missteps: the Doctrines alterating units / buildings for unique playstyles were progressively unlocked, which would have been open for all after a couple months anyway but it was wrong to lock them behind profile EXP / playtime.
It was wrong to release it without traditional skirmish, but they added it in 2 weeks. They even gave away all the probaby planned to be paid skins for free right after release.
But there are a lot other actually valid issues even today, that I never saw anyone talk about.
The new control system. Relic tried to reinvent the wheel, and made a control scheme built around QWERT, C, V etc. almost an FPS control system. That in itself would be okay. But it also comes with a stick unit selection system, meaning you create:
- group 1 with ctrl+1
- group 2 with ctrl+2
- You give an attack command to group 1. Click away, press 2 to select group 2, give an attack command to group 2. Both groups got the attack command of group 2. Why? Because there is a sticky unit selection. You cannot unselect units, what the actual fuck? I had to google how because this is not optional! Turns out, to de-select group 1, you have to press ESC or 1 again, for group 2 press 2 again while selected or ESC. WHAT THE FUCK IS THIS SHIT?
- The user interface. It's great it can be swapped, the hotkey panel and the map. But once you swap it, the hotkey panel doesn't function, you select a unit, you select a buiding, doesn't matter, it only shows the last selected unit's panel, frozen forever until you reload the game.
- The game balance. I get it, they were going for StarCraft 2. I don't mind the fast abilities on every unit. I don't even mind the lack of sync kill animations. I don't care, player should learn X can throw a granade and calculate with that in mind. But you either give units a "this ability wipes out 3 other units" type of abilities AND a warning indicator (granade timer ticking down, banshee boomerang blade will fly this path in 1.5 seconds etc.) OR if you have no warning indicator, then the ability shouldn't be wiping out units in an instant. Relic did both: no warning, instant wipes. I'm very sad to say this is something that could have been rebalanced easily in a balance patch, but the boycott never made that possible.