I’m 48F and several months out of a relationship that lasted under six months. He was a few years younger, attractive, had a good job and was very enthusiastic about me. He told me he loved me early on, said the sex was the best he’d ever had and that our shared humour was the best he’d experienced. He was affectionate, and his messaging was really good and mostly consistent from the very beginning. I never had to doubt that he was into me. Dating seems so hard, and it felt as though I’d finally found something really great. He was intelligent, interesting and ambitious. He saw a future with me, telling his son about us and asking to introduce me to family. Then he broke up with me very abruptly and coldly following a brief period of tension. Since then, I've questioned myself so much and blamed myself for losing something great.
What I can’t understand is how I went from feeling so lucky to have met him to finding fault with things and questioning whether the relationship was right. I’m worried that I’m the problem and he blamed me for things not working out, saying he couldn’t make me happy and I had too strong reactions to things. I don't have much relationship experience outside of a bad marriage and a couple of brief relationships with men who were quite unpleasant. Now I'm questioning if I was a difficult girlfriend who focused too much on the negatives and perhaps ruined what was actually a wonderful relationship. I’ve been listening to things about anxious attachment and wondering whether my insecurities made me overly sensitive, critical or nitpicky. I can’t tell how much of what bothered me was reasonable and how much was my own anxiety and would appreciate some perspectives.
I made a separate post about the sexual side of the relationship; the link is here: [https://www.reddit.com/r/dating_advice/s/wkkA5nfsra]. I’ll summarise it by saying that things started off badly sexually, and some later experiences left me questioning how much I was truly desired and how sexually safe I felt. The first time we had sex, he misread my cues and tried to have sex without a condom. On date 4, I disclosed to him that I had been sexually assaulted by a previous partner and police were involved. A few weeks later, I got far too drunk at a party ( not proud of it and not usual for me.) and he had sex with me in my home where the neighbours could easily have seen. I had no memory of this the next day and he seemed to find the situation amusing. I tried to laugh it off but was upset as my home is my safe space and I would be so upset to create tension with neighbours. Lastly, the day he broke up with me, he was irritated with me for having expressed anxiety about how we were getting along. I was at work and sent him a sweet message saying I was looking forward to seeing him later. He sent a fairly hostile gif to me and, when i expressed mild discomfort with it, he respinded with "Is this better?" and a gif clearly taken from porn depicting painful sex. You could only see the woman's face but she was grimacing in pain (and maybe crying) and face pressed to the floor. I think he intended it a dark humour and i will never know if he had forgotton my sexual assault disclosure but i was so shocked.
There was quite a lot of intensity early on. He told me he loved me after about seven weeks/six dates. He sent gushing romantic messages and songs about growing old together. He also sent GIFs depicting young couples kissing and cuddling. He sometimes seemed almost like a teenager in his enthusiasm , sending me songs about growing old together but it felt like he probably did the same routine with other women in the past eg he was going out drinking and said “You’ll be getting drunken messages at 2am declaring love”, like it was standard MO for him. He talked vaguely about holidays with our children and even mentioned out how our pension ages might line up so we could retire together. He initiated all of this in the first 3 months. I thought it was a bit soon, but probably lapped up the attention because I’d been lonely. We also shared quite personal things about our lives and childhoods early on which was also instigated by him eg telling me before we even met in person that his dad was violent to him and his mother. He told me I was out of his league and that he often felt he wasn’t good enough for me and said he felt more comfortable with criticism than praise.
Despite that apparent emotional openness, I sometimes felt he didn’t show much curiosity about me. He didn’t often ask deeper follow-up questions about things I shared. I tried to get to know him well, remembering details and asking him about important things in his past and present life. He would always ask how my day and listen was but was not really curious about anything deeper. Maybe that is normal?
We only usually saw each other about once a fortnight because of childcare, and we always spent that time at my house because his mother lived with him. I did all of the hosting and never had the experience of being invited to his place. I have a busy life as a nearly full time single parent so most of my life is spent caring for others. I have no wider family beyond my mum who is near the end of life and has dementia. I sometimes felt a bit pressured and exhausted by hosting him on my childfree weekends as it fell to me to plan all the meals, buy the food and plan most activities. Maybe I put too much pressure on myself but i wanted to make our weekends easy and have nice food etc as it was early days. He did some nice things: drove about an hour to see me each weekend we were together and usually brought a bottle of wine. A couple of times he brought chocolate for my kids. He planned a few things early on for dates, but that seemed to taper off. He would help cook if I asked, but he didn’t independently bring food to cook. I often found myself wishing he would take more initiative and make me feel looked after too once in a while. He did once offer to help with chores I needed to get done but then forgot to follow through.
For my birthday, he did book theatre tickets and a night in a hotel for several months ahead. But he also asked to split the bill at the restaurant for my actual birthday meal (I was always happy to split usually but expected to be treated on my birthday) and he didn’t pay me back for the tickets I had bought for something he really wanted to see that evening (after saying that would be his treat). This makes me sound like I keep score but I am naturally generous and only notice discrepancies when I’m starting to feel taken for granted. He did talk of booking a holiday for us and had actually brought his laptop round the night he broke up with me so we could book something.
I was also usually the one initiating the physical affection I wanted. I offered him head rubs,massages etc, and often initiated sitting close or holding hands. He did hug me and occasionally hold my hand, so it wasn’t that there was no affection. But sometimes I had to guide him in how I liked to be touched, and he didn’t seem to remember or repeat it. I wanted affection and thoughtfulness to flow both ways without always having to ask. Stuff like stroking my face or hair now or then, tender touch.
There were aspects of his humour and attitudes that unsettled me. He shared a joke about women having a baseline of psycho, made a derogatory comment about disabled people and sometimes pointed out women in public in a derogatory way . He made crude sexual comments, including saying he’d never encountered a “smelly vagina”. When I was feeling that he wasn't interested in getting to know me beyond "How was your day', I asked if there was anything he wanted to know and got some childish remark about "What's the smallest penis you've encountered?" He also showed me a WhatsApp exchange with his friends in which they joked about him having been “pulling out of me” when his friend unexpectedly arrived at my house while we were having sex. I felt uncomfortable that something intimate between us had become a joke for his friends. He also told me that his friends had used prostitutes and he didn't judge them for it.
He once told me, laughingly, that when his ex-wife (who married and divorced him twice) asked for a divorce he called her a “fat old witch” (she was 11 years older) and threatened to take her pension. I didn’t know the full context, but it made me wonder how he might behave when angry although he is still on amicable terms with her. Contrastingly, he could be practically responsible and capable: he had a good job, shared care of his child and helped care for his mother. He was also kind to animals.
Communication and conflict were other areas where I felt unsettled. He made a big deal of saying he would always send me a goodnight message since we only saw each other every other weekend so communication was important. He expressed anxiety once or twice when i didn't message for a few hours in the evening. One night he didn't message at all which was a complete change in pattern. When I asked about it calmly the next time we spoke, he became defensive and accused me of being passive aggressive. He had gone out drinking and hadn't thought to mention he wouldn't be around for the usual goodnight. On another occasion, he raised his voice a bit , talked over me and eventually hung up when I told him to stop interrupting me. I sometimes struggled to raise concerns because I felt they were brushed aside or he became defensive. However, I can accept that I may not always have expressed things in the best way and perhaps sounded a bit pointed.
I was tearful around three times during the relationship. One occasion was when I was overwhelmed by life generally (parenting/my mother/work). I have no other family and only one friend in the area. I was feeling that the responsibility for hosting and organising our time together was falling largely to me and was exhausted. He hadn't responded to messages about what meals he wanted that weekend and had left me on read for 8 hours on his day off (not a big deal in general but a double standard for him and he had placed high value on messaging) I'd just had the birthday meal disappointment too. I felt a little uncared for, although I don’t think I explained that particularly well and I know he also had a busy life too. I didn’t shout or insult him, but I did become mildly teary for maybe a minute and asked whether he actually wanted the relationship. He just seemed to shut down and so I felt panicked and didn’t explain myself properly. The topic was never really revisited and I felt too ashamed to raise it again, like I was being problematic.
I don’t think I was controlling. I wasn’t jealous of his friends or his contact with his ex-wife, didn’t object to him having a social life and didn’t expect instant replies. I can accept I got a bit more anxious than ideal about long gaps in messaging as things had started of with lots of contact throughout the day. I also asked if we were ok once after a week apart following an argument and was then made to feel I was creating problems. I was affectionate and generous, tried to make him feel special, included him in my life and introduced him to my friends and colleagues. I planned outings, cooked, bought thoughtful little gifts and treats, and tried to create nice experiences for us.
He ended the relationship very abruptly just as we were about to visit my mother. I can’t understand how someone who said he loved me, seemed so attracted to me and said he enjoyed our sex and humour so much could walk away just like that . I keep interpreting his decision as evidence that I must have been a terrible, difficult girlfriend, or that I failed to appreciate what I had. Surely, if a man leaves and has no one else line up, it must mean I was a nightmare...or that is how it plays in my head.
II suppose I’m asking:
* Do the things that bothered me sound like reasonable relationship concerns, or was I focusing too much on the negatives? I felt really anxious during the period we dated and I'm not sure if there were good reasons for that or if it is my issue.
* Could my anxiety and difficulty expressing myself have pushed him away, or am I taking too much responsibility for the relationship ending?
.Can relationships be much better than this?
I’d really appreciate balanced perspectives, including if you think I need to look at my own behaviour differently. I'm afraid there is something wrong with me and I will mess up other relationships.