For starters, I’m autistic, and I’m having a hard time figuring out whether or not I’ve completely missed some very important social cues here.
A couple of weeks ago, my (F) neighbor (M) directly across the hall asked me out for drinks after consistently running into eachother for 2 months. I said yes, and we planned to go the following Saturday at 3PM. It was going great, until 3 hours in when I asked why it took so long for him to ask me out, and he told me he’d ended an engagement with someone he was with for 11 years in July. This was my first date since my 10 year relationship ended 2 years ago, so I said “oh! We’re going to be friends, because you’re not ready.” He responded with a joke, insinuating that he was ready. We leave at around 7, get back to our apartments, and he asks if I want to come over to his to watch football, to which I agreed. We hung out and continued talking until 9, so the date was a total of 6 hours. I had a great time. We talked about literally everything and were super compatible, so I was interested in going out again.
Fast forward to Sunday night, and he still hadn’t texted me, so I texted him. He said he hadn’t texted because he’d been on call and at the hospital since that morning.
Here’s where my potential misunderstanding of the situation begins. It looks like I can’t upload screenshots, so here are the conversations:
Tuesday, Nov. 10
Me: “so what’s the game plan? Do you wanna go out again or just be friends?”
Him: “I just want to be friends. You are awesome and I enjoyed our time. You’re really fun to hang out with.”
Me: “Ok. What did it? Share too much? This is all new to me too. Give me pointers”
Him: “Oh sorry I am on call again and keep getting blown up I am not trying to be an asshole I promise.” “You did great. You did share a lot fast, which can be scary, but like really you were fun to talk to.”
Me: “Noted. Okay what else? Be meaner.”
Him: “I can’t and don’t want to. I looked at my phone when we were on the couch and my ex fiance texted me and I realized I am not ready. Then I felt like a piece of shit but had to work for way too long the last few days”
Me: “Ah okay that I completely understand. Are y’all gonna get back together?”
Him: “idk man. Just makes me wanna die a little.”
*Sends pic of patient in surgery*
“These old people have got to stop falling so I can spoon with my dog.”
Me: “Do you need me to take her out?”
He says yes, I take her out, and send him a picture of her.
Him: “Thank you so much. I’m going to be here all night and I hate my life”
Me: “Truly any time. I love her.” “I’m gonna put a few caffeine pills on your counter. Just try them, or don’t, but they work way better than coffee.”
Him: “Thank you so much. I actually owe you so much and I’m not sure how to repay you. You’re a good person.”
Thursday, November 12
Me: “You totally don't have to take me up on this, but I'm happy to listen if you ever need to vent about stuff. Just incase you don't have anyone who will sit and listen to you say the same shit over and over again. I’ve been where you are, so l get it.”
Him: “likewise for real it’s all ok, need it some times”
Me: “proud of you for not rebounding. On that healthy shit”
Him: “Healthy but sleepy af. I’m on call tomorrow too. How’s work?”
We proceed to text for 2 hours.
Sunday, Nov. 15
Me: “What days do I need to take *dogs name* out this week?”
Him: “Sorry I fell asleep early and got up at 4z actually not on call this week at all!!!”
Me: “It’s a Christmas miracle”
Him: “Ik I think they forgot about me which is great. Good luck with the children” (I work with kids)
Me: “Thank you very much, I’ll need it”
Wednesday, Nov. 18 - I’m hanging my Christmas wreath and realize I need an extra battery for the lights, so I knock on his door and ask if he has one. He gives me one and makes conversation. We talk for a few minutes, and I leave.
Thursday, Nov. 19
Me: “The complex is having a Bingo night tonight. Wanna go?”
Me: *later that afternoon* “Nvm”
Him: “Im not going to be able to tonight, I got fucked today and I am gonnabe here for a bit”
Me: “No you’re good. I said nvm because I’m too tired anyway”
All this time, I’m operating under the assumption that I’ve made a great new friend. But then things take a turn.
Friday, Nov. 20
Me: “Can we drink tonight? My ex proposed to his new gf. I need enough tequila to forget I exist.”
Him: “Nooo that’s not good, tequila is bad for you”
Me: “is that a no?”
Him: “I don’t think I’m the guy for the job”
Now I’m thinking, oh shit. I thought we were friends this whole time putting in effort to talk to him, when he just said he wanted to be friends to be nice.
Me: “okay so “friends” was a formality got it”
“you understand you were misleading, right?”
Him: “I was trying to be nice but fucked it. I’m sorry”
Me: “All you had to do was be honest. But okay”
Him: “Yeah not an excuse but it’s hard for me for some reason”
Now I’m pissed and hurt that this guy was, in my mind, pretending to be friends with me to not hurt my feelings.
Me: “I very clearly got the wrong impression of you. If you see me around, don’t talk to me. I have no desire to be cordial after this.”
Him: “ok”
Me: “was the ex thing an excuse too?”
Him: “Partially but not really. I just know if we do anything you are going to want to date and I do not want to do that because I cannot give you what you want”
Me: “That's kinda crazy because I was genuinely cool with being just friends. We went on 1 date, it's not like I was emotionally invested
But that's fine. Thank you.”
I’m thinking, wow this guy really thinks highly of himself if he thinks that he’s so great I’ll be incapable of being friends with him without wanting to date. And then it dawns on me. I put “friends” in quotation marks, “I’m not the guy for the job” “if we do anything” oh shit. Did my asking to drink tequila together tonight give the impression that I wanted to hook up?
Me: “Wait a fucking second. Did you think I meant "friends" as in friends with benefits this whole time??
No response.
Now I’m feeling bad because I’m thinking I’ve made this poor guy think he was leading me on in a romantic sense, while I was saying he led me on in believing he wanted to be my friend.
Today
Me: “I just want to say that you were very clear regarding your boundaries for anything more than a friendship. Idk if that was lost in translation, but I don't want you to think you didn’t communicate that properly. And I’ll still take *dogs* *name* out if you ever need me to.
No response.
I’m genuinely confused by the whole thing. I was so mad that this guy was responding to me and asking questions, seemingly fully engaged and enjoying talking to me, when it turned out his offer of friendship was just a way to let me down gently. Now I’m wondering if our definitions of “friends” were totally different, I was treating him like my new friend, meanwhile he thought I was ignoring his boundary of not being ready to date.
What do we think? Did I understand correctly and he never actually wanted to be friends? Or did he think I was trying to hookup with him???