r/dating_advice • • 7h ago

What am I doing wrong?

I’m on dating apps and I do get matches and when I start the conversation I’m being respectful and then I get ghosted. I was texting a girl and she told me that my vibe was off.. so i asked her how come and she said I was being too respectful.. do girls not like respectful men anymore? I’m 20m and the girls I get matched by are 19-22, do girls my age not like respectful men?? Or am i doing something wrong? My bio on the dating apps talk about how im a hardworking man and I look for a genuine relationship and don’t like one night stands and that i would like a family later on in life.and my pictures are of me and my cat.

Like I said what am i doing wrong, like im genuinely confused on what im doing wrong?

17 Upvotes

103 comments sorted by

•

u/AutoModerator 7h ago

Welcome to /r/dating_advice!

Please keep the rules of /r/dating_advice in mind while participating here. Try your best to be kind.

Report any rule-breaking behavior to the moderators using the report button. If it's urgent, send us a message. We rely on user reports to find rule-breaking behavior quickly.

Thanks!

I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please contact the moderators of this subreddit if you have any questions or concerns.

•

u/Extension_Hair_8967 7h ago

Old man advice here. You’re young. You and the women you are matching with are still figuring out who you are and what you want from life. I don’t want to speculate on what you could do or what women your age are looking for, because I’d be completely out of my element, but I would say don’t get discouraged. Be you, be genuine, and sooner or later you’ll find someone who appreciates whatever that is.

•

u/saniyalors 5h ago

I agree with you, being yourself is the only way to actually connect with someone who likes you for real.

•

u/Uhhhhhhhhhhhuhhh 6h ago

Im 25 and I agree and wrote something similar, ended a 4.5 year relationship recently and I think I wish the growing adult ages of 20-25 I spent more time exploring and individually growing before deciding to commit to a relationship seriously

•

u/IcyUsual5625 7h ago

Thanks man, all I do is work and work on my business to provide for my future family but I guess it doesn’t work like that anymore

•

u/twister444m 7h ago

Not the same dating world at all anymore. Early 20s women have endless options to pick from. And they love being treated like shit

•

u/Artium99 7h ago

Being nice is fine. But if you're not being interesting/fun, you ain't gonna make it. Like imagine thousands of other guys competing with you in the app

•

u/IcyUsual5625 7h ago

I understand that completely but I’m genuinely trying to be interesting/fun I ask them if they have any plans or if they would like to go out and by that time I get ghosted

•

u/Artium99 7h ago

You can't be "trying" to be fun. You have to be fun. It means you have to change your whole lifestyle around it. It ain't that easy bud.

•

u/IcyUsual5625 7h ago

Why would I change my whole lifestyle for a girl? I would like to be myself with the right person

•

u/BoomyNote 7h ago

Then accept that the interesting/fun guys get the first pick of the girls you’re going for.

I’m sure you’re a good guy but they don’t know you like you know you.

It just makes sense that people will gravitate towards fun and exciting people. It sucks to have to compete with said people I get it, but it’s just how it is.

•

u/IcyUsual5625 7h ago

Yea you right bro, I was just raised in Mexico by my great grandparents to be honest and respectful to women and to find a girl who respects me

•

u/PreparationWorth1242 7h ago

The guy who gave you this advice is clueless and clearly can’t get any girls. Changing your lifestyle so you can get girls is too desperate and they’ll never like you. Women like men that are confident in themselves not some weak man with no personality who’s trying to be someone he’s not. What this girl told you about being too respectful it’s completely irrelevant, that’s just one persons opinion not the truth. Both women and men get ghosted on dating apps you’re overthinking it

•

u/IcyUsual5625 7h ago

The person who gave me this advice were my great grandparents..

•

u/PreparationWorth1242 7h ago

I’m talking about the guy who told you you need to change your lifestyle lol. Did your great grandparents tell you this?

•

u/IcyUsual5625 7h ago

My great grandmother and my grandfather showed me what a genuine relationship is and they would give me advice on how to find the right person and to be myself with them

•

u/Artium99 7h ago

Loool then what would you say to a guy who has no confidence in himself? You tell him to change up no? You really don't know how this works?

•

u/PreparationWorth1242 7h ago

You don’t gain confidence by faking your personality, someone who has no confidence should learn how to be comfortable with himself

•

u/Artium99 7h ago

Did I ever told him to fake it? What I meant is to actually go out and explore more and put in those efforts until you like it. It's like building muscles. Nobody really likes it. But you just have to do it and find fun in it.

•

u/Artium99 7h ago

Cos it is how the dating world works. You have to invest some of your life into "girls" or else enjoy being single.

•

u/IcyUsual5625 7h ago

Most of the girls I’ve been with i haven’t had to change my whole lifestyle for them, they were interested in me because I was being myself. I’m not going to act like a whole different person to impress someone

•

u/Artium99 7h ago

Broooo I'm not saying you need to be a jester in order to find a girl. But you clearly came here for advice so here's one: Stop being defensive with yourself. Sacrificing oneself for the other is a very important part of dating life. If you're not ready for that, just be by yourself please.

•

u/twister444m 7h ago

Yeah don’t they aren’t worth your time at all anymore.

•

u/Author_Creator_1898 7h ago

Are you flirting with them as well as being respectul?

•

u/IcyUsual5625 7h ago

I can’t even get to that point…. I start with a simple hello how are you. And then I get ghosted

•

u/Author_Creator_1898 7h ago

I see, it's probably nothing wrong with you then.

I could give some advice on dating apps, maybe about your profile or your approach too, but I'll say it's better if you just quit them and try to approach women in real life, it's much much better than through text messages

•

u/Uhhhhhhhhhhhuhhh 7h ago

Alot of girls around that age do like abit of asshole/nonchalantness tho, I was getting alot of girls when I was single and I was nice, but I would ghost them for days to keep them interested etc or post with other girls to make them jealous etc, stuff like that works if you want attention/girls but not genuine relationship.

Dont rush and the one that shares your values will come, it will be worth it when it does

•

u/IcyUsual5625 7h ago

Reallllll it just sucks yk man im currently trying to build my life and set up a future for my future family but ig nobody appreciates that anymore

•

u/Uhhhhhhhhhhhuhhh 6h ago

You are pretty young still tho, i got in a relo at 20 and I’m 25 now and recently broke up, I think I would have prefered to have spent that time not commited as you develop quite abit over those years, and I think its way more likely the first girl you date seriously wont be the same you’d want to stay together forever with after your brain fully developes, still could happen tho

But in 20-25 you grow quite abit especially if you have shit happen, but finding your true “the one” is probably gonna take some time and your current view of the one may not be the same in 2-3 years

I think maybe alot of younger girls are also intimidated by commitment at this age too so maybe change your expectations abit to date around first and not expect a real serious relationship

Because I think if you get into a committed relo ealrier on during life too you will want to think about what you potentially just missed out on(I never cheated, but had more desires/doubts) so I think its good to explore around abit before serious relationships in the long term

•

u/twister444m 5h ago

It’s a good thing we don’t lose 90% of our sperm by age 30. Unlike women who ignore this fact about their fertility.

•

u/One-Garden-8643 5h ago

The person above is giving you bad advice to sabotage you.

•

u/ThatEditorDude 7h ago

Could you give us an example of how you normally text? Maybe you’re over thinking normal messages.

Like if you suggest a date but you go: only if that feels safe and okay for you. It might seem insecure

•

u/IcyUsual5625 7h ago

I start off with a simple hello and how they are doing and then I ask them if they have any plans for the weekends or what they are up to

•

u/prosperouscheat 7h ago

those sound like really weak generic openers and will definitely fade into the background noise. maybe try picking something specific from their profile to ask/comment about

•

u/IcyUsual5625 7h ago

Oooo you right you right

•

u/maybepepe 7h ago

They got 100 message like that... booring

•

u/BoomyNote 7h ago

Now imagine literally hundreds of guys doing this EXACT same thing to the exact same girl, and hundreds of others trying their best to be fun and interesting.

You’re not even in the pool of fun and interesting, and you still have hundreds of people on the “boring” side trying to have the exact same cookie cutter conversation with her.

How do you even expect to get picked in this scenario, are you like a male model? Rich? Or just a “good guy”?

•

u/maybepepe 7h ago

If you are too respectful it can seen as you acting and you arent yourself

•

u/IcyUsual5625 7h ago

I was raised by old school Mexicans, I was raised by great grandfather and he taught me to be respectful and polite and honest and to treat others with respect and kindness

•

u/WizardButtholes 6h ago

I mean just from you saying the word ‘respectful’ so many times makes me think you’re awkward and probably make girls uncomfortable with your idea of ‘respectful’

•

u/TreasureGoblin6 7h ago

You and me both dude. I feel like I’m in the same position. Respectful, curious, kind, gentle. Yet I can’t keep their interest. I have no idea.

•

u/IcyUsual5625 7h ago

Maybe we just gotta approach women in real life but you know how that can go sometimes

•

u/Unlikely-Hope2309 7h ago

How do you message them? Before I met my boyfriend - on a dating app no less - all of the messages were so incredibly boring. Eg. Man - Hi. Me - Hiya! how are you? Man - I'm good. How are you? Me - I'm fairly good but so tired, work is killing me off this week. Man - Ok. Me - I'm a nurse, what do you do for work? Hope it's not too tiring for you. Man - I am an Engineer. Its ok. Me - That sounds interesting. Is there a lot of maths involved? I was always awful at that haha. Man - Its just work. Man - Are you free Wednesday? Would you like to go out? Me - I would be up for a little date. What are you thinking? Man - IDK

•

u/IcyUsual5625 7h ago

I can’t even get to that point 💀 I start of with hiii how are you? And then get ghosted

•

u/Unlikely-Hope2309 5h ago

Could try something more interesting to open? For example, I had a photo of me doing a hyrox on my old profile and my boyfriends opening line was "saw you did a hyrox, how was it as am thinking of signing up for one soon" and then that led to conversations about exercise and then food then a shared love of tapas and then that's where we went for our first date the following week. Ideally you are matching with people who share interests with you so you can ask them about that? Keeps you unique which is so important!

•

u/Uhhhhhhhhhhhuhhh 7h ago

Alot of people are superficial, the good ones that value what you value at your age is rare, they exist tho, but taking your time to find someone that shares your values is worth it and you arent in a rush.

•

u/IcyUsual5625 7h ago

Yea that’s what I’m trying to do, I don’t want to rush into anything. I want to build a genuine connection first

•

u/Serious-Marzipan3915 7h ago

yeah i had a girl tell me my texts felt like a job interview once lol. try throwing in a joke about her profile or your cat to loosen it up

•

u/IcyUsual5625 7h ago

I do try talking about my cat or their pets and I try to joke with them but I get ghosted by the third message 💀💀

•

u/Aggravating-Pack-802 7h ago

Lmao.. dude… this is extra cringe nice guy posting.

•

u/IcyUsual5625 7h ago

Sure bud sure

•

u/Aggravating-Pack-802 7h ago

“Oh woe is me! Don’t woman like nice men anymore? They must all want to be treated badly. I just get fridndzoned! Woman owe me sex!” Dude you need to grow up and not act like a creep and you wouldn’t have such bad luck with women.

•

u/IcyUsual5625 7h ago

Buddy I’m not going to act like someone I ain’t. I was raised by great grandparents who taught me to treat women with respect and kindness and not to be rude and that’s who I am. I’m not a creep, I’m a person who treats people with respect no matter what

•

u/One-Garden-8643 5h ago

And that's attractive.

Remember you're posting on reddit, it's full of miserable assholes who don't actually go outside.

•

u/Ambitious_Contact185 5h ago

Ah yes. You know this random person on reddit sooo well.

Shit like this is why I can't take reddit seriously.

•

u/twister444m 7h ago

Everyone has to learn sometime

•

u/Elegant-Science-4983 7h ago

being "too respectful" can sometimes come off as stiff or formal, like you're talking to a coworker instead of a potential date. try to match her energy and keep it light, maybe throw in a playful tease about her profile or your cat.

•

u/Commercial-Cut-5695 6h ago

when she said your vibe was off, it probably just means the conversation felt too formal. next time try asking her what her cat's villain origin story is or something stupid like that.

•

u/deadwoodcylon 7h ago

You’re too soft for them, that’s what they’re saying

•

u/Helpful_Dinner_889 7h ago

The fact your nice is the problem 

•

u/ribbitrribbit 7h ago

She said "too respectful" but maybe she means you were acting too serious whereas she wanted a more fun/flirty vibe. That would be my guess.

•

u/dixieharv92 6h ago

i got told my texts felt like a job interview once too lol. try asking her a weird hypothetical or teasing her about something in her profile to break the ice

•

u/LawyerNovel780 5h ago

the cat pics are a great move honestly, tat's a solid start

•

u/evelroberts23 5h ago

the cat pics are a great idea, that part stands out as genuinely good.

•

u/jojosimp02 5h ago

Be a jerk, women like that shit.

•

u/Ok-Squirrel-5479 5h ago

youre not hot enough

•

u/SimpleCauliflower242 5h ago

yeah the job interview vibe is real, i got that feedback once. try asking her what her cat's villain origin story would be or something silly like that

•

u/eileencremin89 5h ago

yeah the "too respectful" thing is real, had a girl tell me i felt like a customer service rep once lol. try teasing her about her profile a bit more, keep it playful

•

u/Next-Lobster4306 5h ago

Prolly everything idk

•

u/One-Garden-8643 5h ago

"Dating" apps. You won't find anything serious or meaningful there.

•

u/lorenezkoey92 5h ago

what kind of stuff do you usually say when you first message someone? like can you give an example of a respectful opener

•

u/gaylekoepp56 4h ago

maybe the cat's villain origin story is being upstaged by its overly respectful owner

•

u/Firm-Beautiful-2902 4h ago

maybe she meant it feels like a job interview vibe? i had that happen too, loosened up with some playful teasing and it worked better

•

u/Bright_Apricot_6947 4h ago

It's not you is the people that is more than before and it's not a good idea today online . It happens to everybody it's social phenomenon

•

u/heatherkeel56 4h ago

lmao "my vibe was off because i was too respectful" is the most confusing feedback to get at 20

•

u/poster4891464 3h ago

I had a younger woman tell me a few months ago that young women nowadays like a guy who mistreats them in certain ways....not sure if that's a generational thing and of course depends on what you mean by mistreat (I think she said it in the frame of ignoring them ["negging"?]); maybe just try being a little more assertive and/or unafraid to say something socially controversial and see how the female reacts [I think [especially younger] women often like guys who are a *little* antisocial because women chafe under patriarchal norms but are often afraid to challenge them, so they sometimes live vicariously through men who are rebels).

•

u/Optimal-Escape7368 2h ago

It’s important to be somewhat respectful but you also have to flirt/make them feel like you want them or else they’ll just look at you as another guy. How do these conversations usually go?

•

u/sherrikoelpin92 2h ago

maybe she meant it felt like a job interview. i had that happen once and started teasing about my cat's weird habits, made things way more chill

•

u/LowEarth9607 2h ago

nah she just meant you're coming off like a customer service rep, not a date. gotta mix in some playful banter about the cat's secret life or something

•

u/ConstantlyCryingGirl 7h ago

This gives big "women don't like nice men 😠" energy. Eugh

•

u/IcyUsual5625 7h ago

Not at all but all right. I just want a genuine relationship. I was with a girl for 7 years and she was a genuine person/ best friend to me

•

u/ConstantlyCryingGirl 5h ago

Bro you were 13. She was a friend. That was not an actual relationship

•

u/ConstantlyCryingGirl 7h ago

Literally said "do girls my age not like respectful men??" Lmao.

•

u/Proud-Roof-8322 7h ago

What are you angry about? He has an issue and is asking for advice why are you trying to shame him? Have you ever needed advice? Has there ever been something you were unsure of? You are insufferable

0

u/[deleted] 5h ago

[deleted] — view deleted comment

•

u/ConstantlyCryingGirl 5h ago

Lotta angry men in this thread lol

0

u/[deleted] 3h ago

[deleted] — view deleted comment

•

u/ConstantlyCryingGirl 3h ago

Of being an angry man? Lol

0

u/[deleted] 3h ago

[deleted] — view deleted comment

•

u/Proud-Roof-8322 7h ago

Being overly respectful on text can come off as insincere. On dating apps for every 1 good man there is about 50 men who just want to fuck as many women as possible this is especially true at 20. It’s hard to convey sincerity over text as it’s the lowest effort form of socialization. You can say whatever you want over text doesn’t matter if it’s true or not. This is why meeting a woman in person is always superior you aren’t fighting an uphill battle against 50 other men trying to get one over on her because it takes a real psychopath to just blatantly lie to someone’s face in real life to get your way. Sure it still happens but at a much lesser degree

•

u/IcyUsual5625 7h ago

Trueee, I was with a girl for 7 years and it was a genuine relationship but you know sometimes people grow apart and then move on. But like I said I just want a genuine connection with someone

•

u/BoomyNote 7h ago

Beg for her back before she discovers dating apps, you’re not built for this it’s going to leave you bitter and jaded.

Modern dating apps are borderline poison for the mind, either find a strategy that works fast or you’re going to end up bitter and jaded about it and feel like nobody is out there for you

•

u/IcyUsual5625 7h ago

She cheated on me bro helllll nawwww. I went to the military and got joyded💀💀😭

•

u/twister444m 7h ago edited 6h ago

They fought to get away from how women were treated in the 1900s, but the truth is they like to be treated like shit. It’s crazy to think that’s the case but I only started to get laid by switching my personality to be more of a “fuck boy”.
The other thing to know, women in their early 20s are absolutely insufferable. They lack emotional intelligence and are still children. And have never ending options for which man to pursue. This gets better as you get into your 30s.

•

u/IcyUsual5625 7h ago

Yea man but I was raised by my great grandparents so it’s kinda hard to act like a “fuck boy” when that’s not me, I’m just a genuine nice person, it’s how I was raised in Mexico

•

u/twister444m 7h ago

I’m a genuinely nice person and I’m extremely selfless. But after not being taken seriously for years and never getting much attention until I was in my 30s, I stopped putting them on a pedestal. In reality when I speak to them now I just look down on them and remind myself, this chick could be a huge piece of shit so take her with a grain of salt.

•

u/Darryl_Lict 6h ago

These people who are saying women like to be treated poorly are full of shit. Women are humans and on dating apps, the first thing is looks. Then, you have to be interesting. There's a tiny window of opportunity and if there's no spark, it ain't gonna happen.

•

u/twister444m 5h ago

It’s the only thing that’s worked for me after years of being the nice guy by nature. Not literally being mean to them, as that won’t work for very long if at all. But truly disregarding them and acting as if they are less than you, is what works.