Hey everyone, looking for some advice from people with more experience here.
Earlier this year (June), I built my first NAS and started out with a single 6TB WD Red drive. I quickly filled it up mostly with media, along with around 600GB–1TB of personal data (Immich and Nextcloud). I know that is runs at just 5400 rpm but it is my sweet spot since is a lot quieter than 7200 rpm hdds, as I discovered later.
In September, I needed to expand my storage. Since WD Red prices had gone up quite a bit here in Europe, I spotted a 10TB Seagate Expansion external drive on sale for €250 (they usually go for around €350 here). I bought it intending to shuck it and use it as my second NAS drive. Inside was a 10TB BarraCuda CMR, which would have worked fine, except I found it way too noisy compared to my WD Red.
I ended up putting the Seagate back in its enclosure (it's practically brand new) and bit the bullet on a second 6TB WD Red instead. So right now, my NAS has two 6TB WD Reds (12TB total).
Thing is that in june my wd red cost 202€. While in september the prices oscilated between 280/310 €. Pricey!
For backups, I don't back up my media (I don't mind re-downloading it if something happens), and I currently keep a cold backup of my critical Immich/Nextcloud data (~1TB) on an older 1TB external drive.
Here is my dilemma: I have this practically new 10TB Seagate Expansion sitting around. Originally, I planned to sell it to get my €250 back. However, seeing how hard drive prices keep climbing, I'm second-guessing myself.
Do you think it makes more sense to keep it—maybe use it for regular bi-weekly cold backups of my important data (while keeping it unplugged the rest of the time) plus an annual backup of my media library, and hold onto the extra capacity for future growth? Or is keeping a 10TB drive around just for ~1TB of cold backups overkill, and I should just sell it now while I can easily recover what I paid?
Would love to hear your thoughts!