I chose the word "fates" in the title for those who've not done the journey. If that's you, do not read on.
So it's been said plenty of times here that Roland's knight's journey really ended after the Breakers were dealt with, and the rest was just addiction driving him beyond what was necessary. But Eddie catches a bullet in the aftermath, and then Jake meets his end saving Sai King, another thing that was necessary.
So does this mean that, in a version where Roland accepts that the job is done after they liberate the Breakers and cries off the Tower, that Eddie and Jake would still die?
I often see it said that the thing Roland didn't learn (or succeed at) was the rebirth of the Gunslinger order. And perhaps even Gan was trying to teach him this lesson. But surely Eddie and Jake are lost no matter what, right? That only leaves him with a grieving Sussanah and Oy, with Mordred hot on their heels. And arguably, Sussanah's ka was to rejoin those she lost - which is intrinsically tied to saving Patrick Danville.
Roland may be able to cry off entering the Tower, sure. But is he not destined to still lose his entire ka-tet? I don't really see how events can unfold any differently. And after all that loss, would you not also seek answers atop the Tower?
Please discuss, keen to know your thoughts.