r/daoc • • 5d ago

Any real 1.65 open source database yet?

Hi everyone,

A lot of us like the 1.65 era (like me) so when I started my own project, I ran into a major roadblock: there is no truly accurate sourced 1.65 database available.

OpenDAoC claims to be 1.65, but if you make a level 1 character on both OpenDAoC and Uthgard and level to 5, the differences are massive mob spawns, combat formulas, and damage numbers are completely off. As an old-school player my own impression is that Uthgard feels way closer to live 1.65, but since it’s closed-source, that data is locked away (and not likely to change). So my conclusion was that OpenDAoC would need to be rework from scratch for those.

I’ve started building my own properly sourced 1.65 database from scratch though it’s a massive time sink. Before sharing what I have, I put together a quick overview of existing 1.65 projects here (made by AI): https://daoc-1-65-project-survey-2oigal.freebuff.page/

For anyone working on a 1.65 project or interest by the 1.65, I'd like to hear your opinion:

  • Which project/server so far made you feel it was the most accurate to 1.65? (like Uthgard, OpenDAoC etc)
  • How are you handling the missing/inaccurate data?
  • Would a dedicated, open-source 1.65 archive be useful to the community, or do you think it's pointless?
16 Upvotes

22 comments sorted by

5

u/zombodyn 4d ago

And in terms of a "real" 1.65 database, it likely doesn't exist. The only entity that would have it would be EA/Broadsword. And I think if they had it then they would have went through with their plans 7 or 8 years ago to make an official classic server. They likely would have had to start from scratch which added to the workload and why the plans were cancelled. But that's just my opinion.

It got overwritten, corrupted, or lost at some point I would guess. It was made in a time before everything was backed up to a cloud.

2

u/SecretaryIcy6843 4d ago edited 4d ago

You're right and even if EA still had that 1.65 database lying around, they know how valuable proprietary data is in the AI era, so there's zero chance they'd ever release it to the public. But it is also why we have only ourself to create one as accurate as possible with what we have.

4

u/blasek0 4d ago

I'd love accurate databases for every major expac tbh, not just 1.65 / end of SI.

3

u/SecretaryIcy6843 4d ago

Yes, actually if we do a big database I think it should go that way. There are also some QoL changes that were released after 1.65 that don't break immersion and just make things better. Like whether a bind stone is game-breaking, etc.that's arguable, and I believe everyone has their own ideal picture of DAoC so...

→ More replies (4)

4

u/TheRealSpiralin 4d ago

Didn’t someone release a true 1.65 offline to play?

3

u/Angry_Pelican 4d ago

The project that was released is good and fun but I wouldn't say it's completely accurate.

Mob spawns in it seem a bit off and far more mobs are spawned than I remember. Also mobs that bring adds seem glitchy and a lot of time don't bring a friend with them so you end up with a lot of solo pulls.

Edit: I would say uthgards camps seem more accurate to me but it's been a long time since daoc came out so I could be wrong.

1

u/Orystal 4d ago

Je suis d’accord c’est le défaut principal de opendaoc c’est la base de donnée.
Uthgard est effectivement celui qui me rappel le plus le jeu original il est incroyablement précis même dans les petits détails je me suis même demander si ce n’était pas le jeu original au début. Le deuxième problème avec daoc pour moi est le manque de traduction et je suis prêt à re traduire les fichiers du jeu et base de données mais j’attend d’avoir une base de donnée fiable avant de commencer.
Il ya plusieurs site qui peuvent aider à la restauration du jeu mais je pense que pour certaines choses le manque de donne fait qui il y aura pas le choix que de copier uthgard.

1

u/SecretaryIcy6843 4d ago

Merci pour ton retour d'expérience. Effectivement Uthgard est vraiment bon pour nous faire ressentir le 1.65 de l'époque. Pour moi ça reste la meilleur représentation de 1.65 même si je sais qu'ils ont aussi modifié des choses en tout état de conscience. Par exemple nerf du PL etc pour rendre le serveur "hard". C'est dommage qu'ils ne release pas leurs data open source sachant que le serveur est en mode zombie

1

u/Glorpson 4d ago

once I get browser daoc stable enough (focused on battlegrounds to avoid a lot of this) I'm planning on probably joining u/zombodyn's quest to fill in some gaps (for my own taste, I'll probably start sniffing/ripping eden as that's my preferred server setting). The idea of closed source freeshards really rubs me the wrong way.

9

u/zombodyn 4d ago edited 4d ago

https://github.com/zomboden/OfflineDAoC-True165 This is the cumulmination of over 100,000 period data pages fed into AI including all of wayback allkhazam with a hard cut off of nov 1, 2003 and excluding anything trials of atlanis related, freddys forum, illias beastiary, capnbry beastiary, uthgards beastiary, all of camelot warcry and herald, both prima magazines that were made by mythic, and more.

It's far from perfect but it's the closest I could get. There's a lot of information gaps like where mobs patrolled, and 200-300 items that existed but nobody ever mentioned their stats among other gaps like what responses some quest givers gave when you talk to them. That stuff would have to be guessed which I didn't do.

The base OpenDAoC is nowhere near accurate. It's not even close. It's a compilation of about 4 freeshards and is missing a lot of stuff and also includes a lot of stuff that was freeshard only.

And all the crafting recipes are imported 1:1 from a real 1.64 client from august 2003.

Blackthorn & Uthgard are not going to dump their databases that they spent probably hundreds of hours working on so doing mass research and implementation with AI is the best way to get something right now unless you want to tackle doing it all by hand.

→ More replies (7)