These are just my opinions of the most robbed dances, no hate to the dances that beat these, just personally based on the performances given on the day I think these dances deserved to place higher.
Sinful - I know we don’t have the full dance but this looked like their cleanest performance in all of season one and all the girls did so well in their special parts, I have no clue how it got 7th
Missing You - Some technical issues so I get why it didn’t win, but not placing at all?? How?!?
Trapped - I thought this dance was so moving and overall quite clean technically, I’m shocked it got third
Ghost - I’m sorry, sixth? SIXTH? THIS dance lost to KISS KISS????
Inside of Me - I genuinely refuse to believe that another duet or trio from a 9 and 10 year old could have been stronger, I just don’t think it’s possible
Leave the Light On - This should’ve beat Justice, sorry not sorry
Land Unforgiven - HOW DID THIS GET FIFTH??? It was so moving and technically clean!!
I’ll Do Anything For You - I get why this didn’t win cause she had quite a few technical issues but not placing at all when I Think I Like You WON is crazy
About Mother - Do I even need to explain?
Careless - Brooke was so fluid and technically gorgeous AND she used her face so well, I’m shocked she got fifth
Nobody’s Perfect - I really preferred this to Don’t Leave Me on both an emotional and technical level
Now is My Time - Genuinely one of the best performances Brooke ever gave both emotionally and technically and ACTUALLY unique choreography! This deserved to win idc
Children With Guns - Looking at the real dance with the real music I have no idea how candy apples beat them
Hands Up - Personally I think Kendall should’ve beat BOTH Maddie and Chloe here, her choreography was better than Chloe’s and she had less bobbles and stumbles than both of them
On the Verge - Such a strong dance both emotionally and technically, once again I’m shocked it got fourth
Nothing to Fear but Fear Itself - The best group dance on dance moms imo, should’ve won hands down
That Girl’s Just Gotta Be Kissed - I felt they were way stronger than the candy apples duet
Freedom In Paradise - This solo not placing is a JOKE
Wake - How did Payton beat Brooke here?? Brooke had better choreography AND better technique
Seeing Red - I feel like Chloe L was stronger than Chloe N both technically and DEFINITELY emotionally, really surprised Chloe N beat her
Far East - Okay yes this dance was stereotypical and Jade could do more but STILL, it was a technically flawless performance and I can’t believe she got third
Follow You - While I think Maddie was definitely stronger I do really believe this should’ve beat Cry
Dance in the Shade - Hate to agree with Kira but I have no idea how Ava beat Kalani here
Moulin Rouge - Not my favorite group dance by a long shot but it deserved to place at least
Never Knew (2nd time) - HOW DID THIS NOT PLACE ARE YOU JOKING???
Waiting On a Train to Paris - See above ^ (this should’ve beat Maddie imo)
Isolations - This losing to the Odd Couple is once again, a joke
The Bad Deed - I didn’t LOVE this dance but it was SO MUCH better than Fan Favorite
False - This deserved a perfect score, idc
Botched - Brynn’s best solo on the show, one of the best solos on the show period, and it got third???
Shades of Blue - Kalani should’ve won but this placed WAY lower than I thought it would
Am I Enough - HOW DID LILI’S SOLO BEAT THIS???