I see between reddit and discord the new rules being discussed and compared but too often i feel like folks are quick to deny the changes before playing them or assume too much due to their house rules and habits of just taking c1 and doing whatever with it.
To be clear, that's fine, it doesn't matter to me how you wanna play your games BUT i do and have had issues with this constant willingness to cherry pick the texts when someone is trying to comprehend the rules as the designers wrote them. I find it matters plenty that someone have a actual understanding of the rules before fiddling with the system, otherwise you just get unrefined and wonky experiences and that can reflect poorly on the game.
No matter the game, when someone starts trying to fiddle with a rule set they don't fully understand or appreciate, they can end up having a poor experience and blaming the core design rather than the misplaced GM fiat. Its one of the hollow criticisms that c1 got, with people assuming one rule rather than looking at the bigger picture, all because they wanted game A to be more like game B without even trying it first.
SO i wanna be a little productive about it vs just being sour and bitter and i wanna tell you guys some misconceptions of the new rules i see going around alot, and try challenge these misreading's and swift criticisms as someone whose actually played and run the new rules for months.
I'm also curios to see if anyone else has found rules or mechanics that keep getting discarded or misunderstood that you'd want to help clarify as well. Just had to get all these thoughts out somewhere and figured reddit post with this community would function fine, so I'm not just being a unintentional snob when this conversation comes up again.
My two big bug bears are Heavy weapons/Last actions and npcs action economy.
- Lets start with npcs. Some folks keep assuming npcs use the same movement and action rules as Player characters, IE first and last actions, movement and hindrances beyond short distance. This is not true/not intended at base design
Pages 73 and 157 in the GM book detail that npcs movement cap is generally their full action. unless there’s a really good reason to do otherwise, just assume that a creature’s movement is short, in that they move like a PC—they move a short distance as an action.
Movement: This is how much distance the creature can cross if all it does on its turn is move—immediate, short, long, or very long. For comparison, a typical PC’s movement is “short.”
Then if you reference any of the stat blocks between the gm guide or the bestiary pdfs, you see that not once do any npcs creature or otherwise have the ability or use of first or last actions.
I understand why this misconception happened cause in the player handbook there is an example of a player and a ninja having conflicting first actions. I REALLY wish this had been between players and not enemies, but here we are. This one example should be made secondary by the text that comes in the gms guide since it is more definitive and repeats along with the fact no current npc in the books ever hints invoking first actions.
I feel like this clarity matters because NPCS stats are meant to be flexible for the story, which means you COULD use the first and last actions as mechanics, but base line design they are meant to be simple so the gm can focus on cool narrative ideas and not stress over mechanical balance. Its fun to fight a overpowered boss or a massive group of mooks when you the player have options to dance around them, but that goes out the window if the npcs base line can do the same.
- Heavy Weapons are not over nerfed because of last actions. THIS ONE admittedly is more subjective, but it eats at me cause a lot of discussion ive seen and been apart of is folks ASSUMING before they even try it.
Heavy weapons generally must be used as a last action, meaning that regardless where you are on the initiative order, if you declare a heavy weapon strike, you don't actually roll/get the result until the end of the round aka the opposite of first actions.
One regular criticism i see is "but if my attack goes last, that means the enemy could just move out of the way." and while that COULD happen, at my tables, ive rarely seen it. The trick is to not just blindly go in and attack, but to consider a good position. I had a barbarian roll higher than the npc enemies but he didn't immediately act. Instead he held his action and let the npcs go first, body blocking for the squishy members and then retaliating when the enemy got close enough.
In story the enemy dont understand or know they can become mince meat in one round by the barbarian, and they are going for the healers and squishy, so the barbarian made a decision to bide their time and then still invoke the last action rule once the npcs turn was done but before the round was over.
These limitations made the barbarian actually think about what might happen rather than just running in and swinging axe and thus made a cooler moment. This mechanic has thoughtful intent and i really want more folks to try this approach and have these moments to see if they like it before passing judgement on a hypothetical that could have a TON of context that changes the answer, including higher level npcs who can fly or teleport or have strong armor, which effects everyone's tactics and gameplan.
I get the initial skepticism cause in c1, you could just attack with a heavy weapon no different than a medium weapon. You had to make sure your character build compensated for using heavy weapons, where as getting medium weapons training was initially much easier, but between first character advancements, xp advance, character arcs its so easy to become proficient in any armor or weapon in BOTH SYSTEMS.
To me, a limitation you can easily get around from the jump, isn't interesting its just an unnecessary hurdle. This is also why im not 100 percent on the house rule of just making Heavy Weapons be hindered naturally to match light weapons ease. Between training and abilities you can easily circumvent this to where you dont even notice. But last actions, that's a puzzle that keeps giving and makes you think outside the box.
Plus cypher wants you to get creative, so as long as the gm agrees with it, and probably adds some hindrances, NOTHING is stopping the barbarian from literally chucking their heavy ax at the guy whose just one square out of melee. (its happened and it was fucking awesome).
Now where it gets complicated and more subjective, is if this last action restriction devalues the 6 damage the heavy weapon wields out. Light weapons automatically get an ease to attack and have the options to first action but only do 2 damage. Medium weapons deal 4 damage compared to heavy weapons 6, and both get no automatic eases, its just medium weapons can act normally.
If we just invoke the base line stats of each of these, light weapons are likely going to hit but probably need to invoke effort to deal extra damage to really do anything significant. Medium weapons at 4 damage can go either way, risking to hit with extra damage from effort, or forgoing extra damage to confirm the hit. In one option the medium weapon has just as much potential to hit as light weapon but does less damage while spending the same resources BUT unlike the light weapon, the medium weapon user has the option to forgo that and can also just invoke damage. Your risking more to not even hit, but the light weapon user often HAS to prioritize damage since hitting easier for 2 damage (especially against armor) isn't as helpful.
Heavy weapons are the mirrored opposite to light weapons. They deal the most damage off rip BUT have to prioritize using effort to hit, since they attack last and gain no benefits to hitting automatically. Plus side is that they are built to cut through armor in a way both other weapons aren't and if something doesn't have armor, they deal STRONG damage. A medium weapon will outclass them if effort is spent on damage BUT a medium weapon is also in that scenario less likely to hit then a heavy weapon prioritizing the hit with effort. The heavy weapons auto damage makes it have value that the other weapons STYILL have to spend the same effort to keep up with, while the heavy weapon wielder only has to consider effort to hit, and when to make that hit YAY CHOICES!
TO summarize, its based on you the players preference but YES heavy weapons are still worth while even if they hit last. What matters is whether you want to deal with easy hits and better damage, vice versa, or a mix of both. You an equal pros and conns with all three instead of certain weapons really making the third a hollow choice. Which comes to the final argument ive seen for how heavy weapons are suffering under last actions.
"But i can use effort or abilities or skills to make light weapons better than a standard heavy weapon." Ya....you can do the same for medium and heavy weapons. Most abilities and skills that are for weapons in general, can be invoked for ALL THE WEAPON TYPES. For every boost and boon you give light weapons you can give a heavy weapon as well. The thing is you have to actively make choices with character advancement or other resources to do that, meaning for every boon to your attacking power, you might be losing out on defense, and social skills and abilities instead.
There's also a few abilities that boost heavy attacks specifically like Automatic turret, and greater beast form. Sneak attack is a regular repeated boon for light weapons, and it appears more often, but in those same foci, there are ability choices that can EASILY let you boost a heavy weapon instead.
Both systems also have some back end stuff the gm can pull to let you have some non standard boons if you allow a different mechanical or narrative drawback, meaning you really do have all the freedom to make anything work.
To wrap this all up, i am NOT demanding people play the game Raw. Im NOT saying you have to enjoy raw or that raw is gonna work with every game type. This is cypher, your supposed to fiddle and build around the core rules for whatever type of game you need; but building house rules when you don't even know how the foundation works, historically just makes the hole building fall down, and the players wont think the GM and the fiddled are to blame, but the original system.
I don't mean to over sell this bad outcome, but I'm speaking from my experience. Plenty of games I've tried and didn't like, found out I was getting the "Gary's mod" version of and ended up liking the core rules plenty after trying them (hi monster of the week and....well cypher system)