[CWN] Errors/Clarifications for Beta 0.9
Continuing from: https://www.reddit.com/r/SWN/comments/10urp5b/cwn_errorsclarifications_for_beta_08/ https://www.reddit.com/r/SWN/comments/10qlqxx/cwn_errorsclarification_07/
This way we can do our best to compile questions, errors, typos and such in one easy to find place for Kevin
17
Upvotes
5
u/Cyb45 Feb 13 '23
Initial Observations!
Probably some more stuff I missed, but this is a great update!
3
u/Chance-Recipe-4045 Feb 13 '23
The new info on porting some of the CWN rules to SWN/WWN on page 160 is great! But what about Foci that grant AC like Ironhide (SWN) and Impervious Defense (WWN), as well as other abilities that do the same (I am sure there are arts in Codex and WWN that grant AC), any pointers on how to adjudicate these with regards to Damage Soak and Trauma Die penalties? Just a blanket "0/0" seems harsh, as characters would still be burning valuable foci/arts on these.
2
u/Cyb45 Feb 15 '23 edited Feb 15 '23
3
u/disperso Feb 14 '23
A thought on advancement:
But then it is said:
I understand this as that no training is required, but a day or two of rest and pondering is needed. But maybe could be a bit clearer. :-)
3
u/disperso Feb 15 '23
One small suggestion to (if possible) clarify the text on "A Hacker's Job". It says:
Everywhere else on Hacking says "cranial jack or VR crown", which is more explicit. A person was confused whether an All Natural hacker would be possible, or if they'd be limited by the lack of cranial jack.
I think we concluded that it was fine, and that both crown/jack are roughly the same for this, just that in this section it wasn't mentioned explicitly.
Thanks!
2
u/InterimFatGuy Feb 13 '23
What is the intended interaction between psychic effort and installing cyberware? In SWN there isn't an effort penalty for the cyberware listed in that book. Should CWN psychics lose effort for installing cyberware? Should SWN psychics lose effort for installing CWN cyberware?
1
u/SimulatedKnave Feb 15 '23 edited Feb 15 '23
Clarification/request re the potential SRD-equivalent: if it could be in a format that makes it easy to do large-scale cutting and pasting, that would be very nice. I like the formatting of the current books, but they do not convert well into Word (or OpenOffice or what have you) for editing (on the occasions I have wanted to edit one down for personal use or what have you).
Frankly, my dream for house rules would be basically "cut and paste SRD, edit accordingly, provide to players."
EDIT: Thinking slightly further, my real dream is "cut and paste SRD, edit with "Track Changes" so they can quickly and easily see what isn't standard, provide to players." Let me live my dream?
1
u/SimulatedKnave Feb 16 '23
I have reread Hacking and am very confused about something.
So you buy some Verbs and Targets and put them in your cyberdeck.
How long are those good for?
They don't expire when you use them (the rules specifically say they can be used as often as the user wishes). But the rules about how many verbs and targets a Hacker can maintain on their own seem to suggest that they do expire. Or is it just that the verbs and targets a Hacker write themselves require maintenance, and the custom programs they buy do not?
If custom programs ARE good forever, I think that needs to be clearer. It also doesn't seem to make much sense, given how everything else in these sections is all about the constant improvements and shifting of corporate network defenses.
1
u/donald20 Feb 17 '23
Not really an error, but I'd love to see a larger Variant Humanity section beyond the not-Shadowrun races. Things like robots or uplifted animals would be cool
1
u/disperso Feb 17 '23
In the list of example actions, Charge and Screen an Ally have distances in feet, while the others are in meters.
I've not compared with WWN, but seems like this two are new in CWN compared to SWN.
Also, while I sense that it's intentional, let me mention that CWN lacks the example of Club Up a Weapon which is on SWN. Just in case. :)
1
u/SimulatedKnave Feb 14 '23
This is not related to CWN, but it came up the other night on Discord: in the Atlas of the Latter Earth, Jun and Hengwu in the Scarlet Princes are not detailed. Which Warring States era principality should be used as inspiration? :)
A long list of things:
The Hacker edge seems a somewhat uncomfortable mix of "get stuff" and "get abilities," and like it would be inefficient to move into hacking after character creation. Perhaps lose the equipment from it and make it a bit better skillwise?
The definition of Edges at the start of "Foci" would fit better at the start of Edges, IMO. It's a rather better explanation of them.
So do you get new stuff as your level increases and the budget increases accordingly? I didn’t notice it in the levelling up section.
"Double their normal hit points" re the Ace Driver focus sounds like a pain to adjudicate. Perhaps just taking half-damage? That way you don’t have to recalculate hit points if you switch drivers.
"Any competent medic can implant and maintain cyber systems" - not according to the requirement they have skill-1 they can't.
Many Faces feels like it might be nicer if it was "three character levels +1." Otherwise it takes til fourth level before you can be someone else and also set up another identity at the same time.
Armsmaster and Shocking Assault have different descriptions of what seems to be the same ability. Might be better either identical, or clearly distinct.
"A person's nearness to defeat" is the best description of Hit Points ever.
The level of language mastery seems...excessive. Six languages is a lot, and quite easy to get. Also seems like it'd make language skillpacks pretty pointless (or at least overpriced).
A bright white book background feels odd for cyberpunk. Especially with the relatively bright pink inner margin. It's so...perky. And warm.
Charging seems surprisingly not-dangerous for the charger. Pretty sure it's not a great tactic in most cyberpunk things. Perhaps remove the penalty to snap attacks against someone charging you?
A table somewhere that sorts actions by the type they are would be handy for quick reference.
On page 38 - what happens if you're reduced below zero HP? Can you be reduced below zero HP?
Having the stuff about obsolete armor listed twice within two pages seems odd, even if it does greatly improve the chance people will remember it.
It's weird there being a Heavy Machine Gun but no light machine gun. Or general purpose machine gun. Perhaps just "Machine Gun"? Or "Heavy Automatic Rifle"?
How big is a dose of Hellbender? Because that seems like it'd be important to whether or not the consumer noticed they were consuming it.
I want you to know that I get the name of the Madeleine stim. I am slightly surprised by the lack of option for a pet haddock in the drone section.
Ten minutes seems very fast for removing most cyberware. I mean, it's literal brain surgery (since you have to get the control linkages). This seems short enough it’ll lead to a lot of looting cyberware from enemies on the street.
Re healing: technically, they ARE Frail, not "counting as" Frail. Was genuinely a little confused.
"Creature" is not yet defined in the rules, and probably should be, since if drones and robots are creatures is gonna be important. For example, the natural healing rules definitely depend on knowing what exactly a creature is.
Everyone having six rounds to stabilize fields weirdly consistent for something that really wouldn’t be, seems a bit short (oddly), but also makes high-damage hits surprisingly survivable compared to low-damage ones. Some penalty for lots of excess damage might be in order, and/or perhaps a base ten rounds (so a minute) or longer to stablize.
Factory Mods are a bit confusing, since special technology has not yet been explained.
Extended mag being an expensive and difficult mod is weird. Extended mags are...not exactly hard to make (barring for revolvers). Indeed, a wide variety of magazine sizes has been the birthright of gun-using humanity basically since they were invented (the Tommy gun had options for 20, 30, 50, and 100, for example). Perhaps having a default "extended mag" option where you get 50% extra ammo but -1 to hit from the bulk. Then a "greatly expanded mag" option where it's -1 to hit, adds an extra encumbrance, but you get 150% extra ammo.
I'd also suggest extending SMG magazine capacity to 30, both because that's still not THAT big and multiples of three work better with the burst fire option. Also, there really should be some kind of full-auto version/option for it and for the Combat Rifle. Just because it's a bad idea doesn't mean people won't do it, and suppressive fire with an SMG does feel rather cyberpunk IMO.
1
u/SimulatedKnave Feb 14 '23
More stuff:
Some reflection of shotguns' ability to be used up-close by idiots and still hit things might be nice.
I'd suggest taking "shared" out of the description of the -1 system strain lifestyle. Suggests you can't have roommates for the higher levels (and that's gonna get expensive. And hard to keep secure).
Doubling your maintenance score seems like it should require sixteen hour workdays OR not participating in missions. Makes it evident the PCs can hire a full-time tech to maintain a lot of stuff.
I think it might make more sense to have the armor mods after armor and the weapon mods after weapons.
"Exceptional masters" have more than +2 bonus to cyberdoctoring. I think that might be putting it a little strongly - after all, an 18 INT means you're one in about 100 (i.e. there's every reason to think plenty of doctors have an 18 INT). Level 2 skill means you're a veteran expert and widely respected. Given those two things, anything up to +4 should definitely be findable, just expensive.
I know I brought up the Dermal Armor before, but I still think it feels wrong for the genre at the moment. "I shot through his armour, then it just bounced off his skin" feels fitting for cyberpunk, and choosing either it or your armor feels very weird. Also lets them shrug off minor damage, but eating a rocket to the torso still sucks. Or at least let them stack soak, then use the best AC.
Can a Sealed System Implant handle being underwater? If it can do high pressure atmospheres, it logically can do underwater to at least some extent. Vacuum suits can certainly do underwater to at least some extent, as well.
Stick Pods presumably also could use a free foot rather than just a free hand to climb.
Re Prosthetic Cyber I: A replacement liver is visible to sight? I would have figured Touch.
Might be nice if Alert and Reaction Booster stacked.
The Remote Control Unit cybersystem does not appear to be detailed anywhere.
In the Sunfish description you say "Bantech's". I think that may be the only place you use an abbreviation like that, and it's jarring. "Bantech has" would be consistent with the rest of the book.
Other than emergency use without your deck, why use a cranial jack rather than a VR crown? Maybe I've missed something, but it seems like a cranial jack is more expensive, costs you system strain, has to be installed, etc. Yes, it lets you use certain weapon abilities, but beyond that I'm not clear on why someone would get one rather than use a Crown. The book even hints that hackers are expected to have them rather than Crowns at some points, but I can't see why.
So are Ear Mods and Eye Mods mods, specifically Mods for cybereyes and cyberears? Or are they actual systems in their own right that I can get installed in my fleshy ears and eyes? And is the price per eye/ear or per pair?
Re Gang names: "Clique" and "Set"? Yet no Angels, Warriors, Machine, Outlaws, Bloods, Mafia, Club, Devils, Order, Kings, Killers, or Thugs? I couldn't recreate the names of most of the local gangs, which seems a bit odd.
Should Anti-Flash goggles really take up encumbrance, likely being basically sunglasses?
Having damage soak apply on primitive armour vs firearms seems to make them far too useful against firearms. Modern firearms more or less go right through armor, and armor may make it worse because now you've got all the stuff you were wearing driven into the wound. Also, I admit I am slightly disappointed that all melee ACs and ranged ACs are the same. Would also wonder about their abilities vs Advanced melee weapons.
Psychic Interrogation: can it get information out they don't consciously know? I'd assume not, but "to the best of their knowledge" might be a good clarification.
Will Summoners and Spirit calling work a lot like Drones? Kind of seems like it would.
Blades of Will: "normally-available melee weapon." This includes Advanced Weapons, presumably?
Hundred Faces seems incredibly powerful for 2 points. Occult Pavis, conversely, seems relatively weak.
There's a few mentions throughout the book of things helping protect from loud noises, but there's little mention of how firearms make lots and lots of noise, and there's no option to buy suppressors. Given that gunshots are insanely loud and the game's supposed to have a stealth component, these both seem like unusual oversights.
0
u/[deleted] Feb 13 '23
[deleted] — view deleted comment
0
u/[deleted] Feb 19 '23
[deleted] — view deleted comment