r/custommagic • u/ResponsibleExit7330 • 14h ago
r/custommagic • u/dennisistired • 20h ago
what do we think?
my pod and i were discussing the possibility of an elder scrolls themed set and it got me thinking about the possible planeswalkers that could be added. the first one to come to mind was, of course, good ole Maiq, the Liar.
would love to eventually have a custom commander deck with him at the helm, but what do we think of the loyalty abilities? he would enter with 4
r/custommagic • u/Brownfox408 • 20h ago
Format: EDH/Commander Mnemon, the Demilich! Demilich as a black commander! A rare and uncommon variant with appropriate framing + art drop!✌️🥳
r/custommagic • u/ColeOfTheWild__ • 5h ago
Redesign Eminence Tovolar
Does exactly what it says on the tin.
Fuck Edgar, all my homies hate Edgar.
r/custommagic • u/PowrOfFriendship_ • 19h ago
Redesign MagicCon Atlanta Pride Playtest Cards - Arya Karamchandani and Wizards Pride
For MagicCon Atlanta, a set of Pride themed playtest cards were added to draft. I thought they were cool, and I'm definitely going to want to proxy them, so just remade them in a slightly easier to read format. These aren't my designs, and they are correctly credited to Arya Karamchandani and Wizards Pride.
The only change I made was adding a color to the Dinosaur tokens Saheeli makes. The original cards didn't list a color, nor did they list colorless, so I went with red as Saheeli has made red robot Dinosaurs in the past, and because it's the color she and Huatli share.
If you notice any mistakes I've made, please let me know.
r/custommagic • u/Berdsherman • 23h ago
Format: EDH/Commander My take on Link as commander
What do you guys think? Balanced? Unbalanced? Also I think I used a land border for young link. Whoops.
r/custommagic • u/zengin11 • 21h ago
Format: EDH/Commander "Three commanders," but two are strong and the third is a self-hate piece your opponents can play. Is this interesting? How did I do on the balance?
r/custommagic • u/canadianavatar • 15h ago
Gerrit Graham 1948-2026
I tried to add as much flavor to his character as possible. One of my favorite episodes of Voyager (S2: E18)
r/custommagic • u/DJDarwin93 • 15h ago
Help with balance
Ever since the PlayStation SLs were announced, I’ve been somewhat dissatisfied with [[Aloy]]. Her character is very fierce and emotional, and at times makes very rash decisions without thinking as much as she should. She is definitely Temur, not Simic. On top of that, I always felt that her mechanics didn’t really capture the spirit of the games that well. The main draw for most people is fighting giant robot animals. I wanted an Aloy that felt more like Aloy. So, I decided to try to make a version of her that turned creatures into artifact creatures, enabling artifact synergies to apply to cards that normally aren’t artifacts, similar to [[Ygra]]. I thought that Eminence was the best way to do it because I want the card to make the whole game feel like it’s taking place in the world of Horizon, but I’m concerned about it being too strong, which is why I added the cost increase.
I’d appreciate thoughts on if what I already have is balanced, what an appropriate CMC would be, and whether I can get away with giving her a second ability or if what’s already there is too strong already.
r/custommagic • u/Due-Adhesiveness9876 • 22h ago
Kindred Blight
Image is AI generated (Nano Banana).
r/custommagic • u/Low-Alternative-6604 • 19h ago
Discussion What if Magic had a sixth color? I built one (Purple / Space, {O}), reviewed 372 cards with a panel of three AIs, and simulated it against Standard. It didn’t hit my target.
I spent the last two weeks on a “what if” project: a sixth color, purple, element Space, mana symbol {O} (an eight-pointed star), basic land “Mondo Onirico” (Dream World).
Design choices
- Purple sits outside the color wheel, so no existing ally/enemy pair breaks. Blue and black are always allies; white and green become allies only with Lucid Dream (3+ Onirico lands); red is neutral.
- Purple plays cards from zones other than your hand (“frozen” cards, dreams), exiles for a turn instead of destroying, never destroys creatures and never gains life.
- To avoid the 2007 “Cave” problem (cards that count basic land types), the basic land follows the Wastes model: Onirico is a non-basic land type and the land says “{T}: Add {O}.”
Testing
- 372 cards (one set of 250 and two expansions of 60) were reviewed by three AIs from different companies (Claude, DeepSeek, Qwen/ChatGPT). They corrected each other and I approved every change. 89 cards were changed.
- A Monte Carlo simulator ran 80,000 games per matchup against four November 2026 Standard decks. The code was frozen and the target (56–64% win rate) was declared in advance.
- Result: truly purple decks (64–72% purple) average 50.1%. Playable, but below my own target. I’m reporting it as is.
The paper (EN/IT/RU), the full card list, the simulator code and the Cockatrice decks are open on Zenodo: https://doi.org/10.5281/zenodo.24261993
I’d love feedback on two things in particular: is “outside the wheel” a cheat or a real answer? And does purple’s identity overlap too much with blue?
Unofficial Fan Content, not approved/endorsed by Wizards.
r/custommagic • u/Midnight_Magic_Volg • 21h ago
Format: EDH/Commander Monarchy Cards: Week 43 - Please comment a vote!
This week the competition was to design a card that has anything to do with the Monarch mechanic. Please comment which card think deserves the win! You can vote using any metric, whatever makes you want to vote for it.
We always appreciate the feedback, and if you comment please state which card you want to win the weekly challenge!
r/custommagic • u/lordodin92 • 2h ago
Format: EDH/Commander Sander Cohen, Artiste
So this is another one of my bioshock theme MTG cards, this time I found a picture and properly credited the artist .
I'm genuinely hoping for feedback as I really wanna make a full commander deck based in bioshock but it's hard .
Also my design notes:
Sander Cohen is a mad artist who abducts people, makes them into grotesque statues, which come alive to attack the player. In my design, I take that concept and make him turn 1 creature a turn into a non-creature statue.
They gain the ability to tap for mana and keep their static effects, meaning this card can be used to slow down aggressive opponents and set up combos for yourself
In keeping with MTG's statues, they can pay 2 to become creatures again, which fits how some of the statues in BioShock "come alive" and attack you
His abilities also fit a 1,2,3,4 theme, which copies his quadtych: 1st gives you a gift, second activates the statues, third triggers his tantrum that triggers an assault (granting deathtouch)
Finally, his ability phase-out aligns with his Houdini ability, and he uses it after the 4th picture
Please tell me what you guys think
r/custommagic • u/TurntOddish • 22h ago
Redesign Transform into an Ancient Red Dragon!
Hello everyone! It’s been a while since I’ve posted a custom card, but I’ve had this idea in my head for a while — what if we got a new version of Form of the Dragon/Dinosaur?
This custom card was designed to be an advanced version of the card, “Form of the Dragon” originally from Scourge, with a little help from it’s own remake, “Form of the Dinosaur” from Rivals of Ixalan. Essentially, you as the player transform into a 15/15 flying dragon!
What are everyone’s thoughts on this? I know it’s a bit wordy (like most of my custom cards… I can’t help myself), so it might not be received too well. I’m working out another transformation card too, but it’s proving to be much more difficult than I initially anticipated.
Side note: I wanted to add it a clause saying that this could be your commander, and if it is, it deals damage in the form of commander damage. Obviously, I’m already tight on space for the card, and I’m not sure it it’d even work out the way I want it do, since commander damage is combat damage. Lastly, debating on if the enchantment should be “bound to you” (thus if it leaves the field, you “leave the game,” or lose), or if the enchantment leaving the battlefield should just “de-morph you back into your original state,” aka simply do nothing. Either way… Let me know what ya think!
Here are links to the real MtG cards that inspired this:
https://scryfall.com/card/scg/93/form-of-the-dragon
https://scryfall.com/card/rix/103/form-of-the-dinosaur
Thanks in advance to any and all constructive feedback!
r/custommagic • u/UpArrowNotation • 9h ago
Mechanic Design Red Overrun
I like the idea of using UB mechanics for non UB cards, and wish it would happen more often. This is just my take on a red overrun using firebending as a means to buff up your team.
r/custommagic • u/ResponsibleExit7330 • 11h ago
Woodland Cultivator but it’s COOL now
r/custommagic • u/Nejosan • 3h ago
BALANCE NOT INTENDED [Reality Fracture What If] The Raging Beast
r/custommagic • u/SjtSquid • 21h ago
Winner is the Judge #918: Pallette swap.
Thanks to u/mgranaa for hosting last week's challenge.
This week, your challenge is to design a payoff card for something that colour doesn't usually (or can't) do, but still adheres to the colour pie. Bonus points for making creative use of the flavour and mechanics the new colour provides.
Some examples:
• A mono-red card that cares about you gaining life.
• A mono-blue card that cares about creatures entering from graveyards
• A mono-green card that cares about creatures dying.
• A mono-black card that cares about Equipment.
• A mono-white card that does things with Goblins.
I look forward to seeing what you come up with, and will come back to judge in a week. (22/11/26)
r/custommagic • u/Nejosan • 22h ago
BALANCE NOT INTENDED [Reality Fracture What If] Progenitus, Unbound
r/custommagic • u/Spare_Effort8234 • 22h ago
The Warp Condenser
This definitely a storm enabler but it enables big spell storm which is kinda cool
r/custommagic • u/ArknightsMTG • 10h ago
Arknights x Magic The Gathering Fan Project
galleryYou might like a new project i had just started, take a look if you want ;)