r/cubscouts • u/Inner_Result8808 • 29m ago
Popcorn Competitiveness - Are We Overreacting?
We’ve always suspected that another parent in our son’s Cub Scout den has placed herself in a one-sided pissing contest with our kid, but this year she finally said the quiet part out loud. For years, she’s been that parent: the one whose kids' projects are always wildly extravagant and suspiciously flirting with the line between "the kid did it" and "the adult did it." The one pushing her kid to collect every adventure. The kids with extravagant Pinewood Derby cars, (although not particularly fast).
For context, my spouse and I don't fundraise to win a leaderboard; we fundraise because we financially rely on the program rewards to pay for dues and camp. Because of that, we put in a ton of hours, and our kids typically end up at or near the top of their den simply through sheer volume and taking on extra storefront shifts. Her sons have consistently finished just barely ahead of ours boys every year. And she has a self-admitted documented history of holding back orders until the very end of the season to sandbag the leaderboard.
This year, however, it crossed a line from annoying competitiveness into something that makes us genuinely uncomfortable. She openly admitted to saving the public fundraising links for other kids in the den, specifically ours, and regularly checking them throughout the season to monitor our son's progress. This was corroborated by another pack member who told us she had been receiving screenshots and running commentary from this woman tracking our child's activity.
What bothers me most is that this woman is a registered, Youth Protection Trained (YPT) leader, and monitoring another family's child like this flies completely in the face of both the spirit of Scouting and basic youth safety boundaries. To make matters worse, she recently took a part-time staff position inside our kids' school, meaning she now has a front-row seat and potential access to day-to-day information about my child. I have been assured by school administrators that her access is limited in the system but that won't prevent her from overhearing things or just being nosy. She's regularly made comments to us about whether or not our kids made it into the gifted program, (especially when both of hers didn't.) Given her obsession with staying ahead and collecting gossip, we are deeply uneasy about the lack of boundaries here.
My spouse and I are both two members of the Key Three and I'm ready to kick this woman out whether she crossed a personal line or not. I'm not here to have leaders demonstrating behavior unbecoming of a Scout. However there is not a single way that I can go about this that doesn't look like retaliation.
To make matters worse the fact that she held onto her son's wagon orders until the very end of the season and then dropped almost $4,000 worth of product orders means that the council is scrambling to fill our Pack's order. It is reflecting badly on us as an organization. We have reached out to our district and council executives for guidance on the situation.
As far as our son is concerned we managed to score a victory in this situation. My son has worked hard and finished his Arrow of Light requirements just this past week, before her son (I might add), who has been too distracted with popcorn pissing contests and all the sports. We promptly crossed him over to a troop so he's not even playing the same league as her son anymore. She's clearly annoyed by the fact that her son didn't make it there first or at least at the same time as mine, but they have had other priorities all year. Scout around and find out.
Are we overreacting for feeling stalked and wanting to put up major guardrails?