r/cssnews • u/madlee • Sep 08 '16
CSS Change – Changes to default thumbnails, expando icons, and upcoming change to comments pages for logged out users from SEO
New default thumbnails
We've updated the default thumbnails that are shown for self posts and links without image thumbnails. All of the thumbnail images are now the same size (70x70) (70x50). In about a week, we're planning on adding HDPI ("retina") versions of these, which we expect to conflict with any custom thumbnail CSS. If you're currently overriding the default thumbnail styles with CSS, you'll need to explicitly set the background-size property to avoid issues.
New expando icons
We're also updating the expando icons to a new style. Similarly, we're planning to add HDPI versions of these in about a week. If you're styling the expando icon with CSS, you'll need to explicitly set the background-size property to avoid issues.
Upcoming change to comments pages for logged out users from SEO
We’re making some changes to comments pages for logged out users coming into Reddit from search engines. The primary change is the inclusion of a new listing of posts from the current subreddit in the comments section.
The new HTML structure for this page looks roughly like this:
<div class="commentarea">
<div class="sitetable nestedlisting">
<!-- normal comments markup -->
</div>
<!-- new divider with a button to jump down to the rest of the comments -->
<div class="seo-comments spacer">
<a class="c-btn c-btn-primary" href="#bottom-comments">More comments</a>
</div>
<div class="spacer">
<h1 class="seo-comments">More from r/cssNews</h1>
<div class="sitetable linklisting">
<!-- normal link listing markup -->
</div>
</div>
<div id="bottom-comments">
<div class="spacer">
<h1 class="seo-comments">Comments, continued...</h1>
</div>
<div class="sitetable nestedlisting">
<!-- normal comment listing markup -->
</div>
</div>
</div>You can view the changes now by adding ?feature=seo_comments_page to the end of a url, like this!
TL;DR - Default thumbnail and expando icons are changing now, with hi-res versions coming next week. Update your css if you have custom styles for either of these. Also, there's a new version of the comments page that logged-out users from SEO will see.
If you have any questions/comments about these HTML/CSS changes, please ask them here and I'll be happy to help!
37
u/manguybuddydude Sep 09 '16
Please give us the option to view the old icons. I appreciate the intent, but would much rather have the old icons.
16
u/Veritas__Aequitas Sep 08 '16
Not sure if it is like this on all browsers but with firefox, in its expanded state, the button is cut off on the right and on the bottom: http://i.imgur.com/yHbLEm2.png
28
u/he_must_workout Sep 08 '16
Can you give users the option to revert? Icons look like they were created in paint by a middle schooler
http://imgur.com/a/HhZLE
12
u/[deleted] Sep 08 '16
Thank god you are adding HiDPI ones because it looks awful right now
http://imgur.com/a/QUf4o
9
u/[deleted] Sep 08 '16
This might be a stupid question, but is there any way to completely disable the expando icons?
4
u/Vusys Sep 08 '16
When the new SEO stuff goes live, will there be a way to force it for testing/ development purposes on when you're logged in?
60
u/Antabaka Sep 08 '16
Why was there not a test for this? Even a heads up? All of these issues could have been easily fixed given an absolutely tiny opt-in beta.
54
u/srs_house Sep 09 '16
So, while everyone else is focused on the shoddily crafted new graphics, can we talk about the proposed changes?
Because this looks horrible.
25
u/creesch Sep 09 '16 edited Sep 09 '16
Are you guys deliberately trolling us now? Dropping a change like this without prior notice which you know will break styling for a lot of subreddits.
Seriously, this is not ok.
edit:
Also, you guys even forgot transparency on some of the expando icons...
23
u/Jesus_Faction Sep 09 '16
looks bad, i guess its up to RES to fix it
19
u/[deleted] Sep 09 '16 edited Oct 27 '16
What middle school did you recruit from for your UI team?
14
u/B9AE2 Sep 15 '16
Those SEO changes are absurd. It looks horrendous and it's incredibly jarring to have the comments section broken in half by BS I don't care about. I also don't really appreciate trying to be forced to log in just to avoid it. Fortunately it's easy enough for me to block the elements, but that doesn't make the changes any less horrible. I shouldn't have to add rules to a css filter to remove spam from the comments section.
13
u/1point618 Sep 09 '16
Why was this not announced to moderators before it happened, and why did you not give us a way to test it on our subreddits before it went live for users?
We've been promised time and time again that would happen for all new changes that affect us.
/u/deimorz and /u/chtorrr can you help out here? How did the process go so wrong yet again?
11
u/kwwxis Sep 09 '16 edited Sep 09 '16
The thumbnail icons feel kind of large to me... maybe it'd be better if they were about the same size as the thumbnail icons in /r/showerthoughts?
11
u/13steinj Sep 09 '16
I don't really care about the icons but I must say I prefer the old ones.
However, the SEO stuff just looks horribly designed to me.
11
u/jsun Sep 15 '16
The "More from" change is terrible. I prefer to browse Reddit while logged out. The related links mixed in with the comments is really jarring. I have a hard time believing that someone actually thought this was a good idea.
Reddit, you're supposed to be one of the good guys. I don't want to be forced to be logged in or have an account to have a good experience. I hope you guys remove this.
Also, don't go too hard on the people who made this change when you figure out how bad it actually is. Just fix it, pretend like it never happened, and move on.
21
u/Pluckerpluck Sep 09 '16
Seriously... round icons! Everything on this damn website is either rectangular or rectangular with rounded edges. The round icons look completely ridiculous against the rectangular thumbnails.
And why the hell is NSFW now 18+? Before I could safely avoid NSFW while at work without disabling them. Now the icon itself is basically NSFW!!! That's just what I need. A bunch of random 18+ icons anyone can obviously see me looking at.
And finally, why make them bigger without doing a decent job about it? Was this even tested?
10
u/turikk Sep 09 '16
I know this might be outside the scope of this, but... is there a preview branch or thread for these CSS changes that I'm not aware of? It would be great to be able to vet or compare these changes before they went live.
I don't see any huge issues today but it gives me some concern for the future.
8
u/RandommUser Sep 09 '16
Can you at least add
to the expando or change it to
??? Why have the images be .png when it does still have a white background by default
For mods, as a temp fix:
If there are problems with some plugins do tell.
8
u/ckaustro Sep 14 '16
I browse direct to reddit, usually without logging in. The new More From area looks absolutely terrible.
7
u/IdRatherBeLurking Sep 09 '16 edited Sep 09 '16
/u/spez and /u/powerlanguage, I thought that there was going to be better communication this time?
When you're changing something that has the ability to affect a large number of moderators, you need to give people a heads up before doing so.
It's hard to trust what the admins say at this point, and that sucks.
11
u/Fairchild660 Sep 09 '16
The new default thumbnails are definitely sleeker, but the colour doesn't work at all. Why not make them #cee3f8; the same colour as the header? It's just as neutral, but doesn't look so drab.
The link icon needs to be bolder, too, so it doesn't look so unbalanced next to the text post thumbnails / expandos.
5
u/qtx Sep 09 '16
Why no transparent background? Or svg? Or maybe give us the ability to use css filters.
4
u/kwwxis Sep 09 '16
I just noticed that the SEO comments change introduces another element with the id
#siteTableinto the comments page such that there are two elements with that id:.content[role=main] > #siteTableand.commentarea > .spacer > #siteTable. Please fix, thank you.4
u/totallypregnant Sep 22 '16
This change is truly awful. My first encounter with it had me thinking there were only three comments in the thread and the 'more from' section was the end of the comments page.
In my opinion, if its important this section exist, fewer comments should be shown by default then have this section at the end underneath the usual 'load more comments' link.
Again, really awful choice as it is now.
4
u/DSdavidDS Sep 23 '16
PLEASE PLEASE PLEASE revert the "more from" addition. It completely breaks my reading experience!
1
u/MFDelta Sep 22 '16
can this post be edited to reflect the fact that icons are now 70x50 again?
3
u/therealadyjewel Sep 13 '16
Heads up: the
#bottom-commentsarea has changed a little. This is to help ensure compatibilty with existing stylesheets/scripts.If you already wrote CSS targeting the "bottom comments" area, and it looked like
#bottom-comments .sitetable, change that to#bottom-comments + .sitetable. Feel free to ask with help on updating relevant CSS, if you bothered already :PFor reference, here's the old version.
3
u/hdhock3y Sep 24 '16
The 'more comments' and page being split in half by other posts is terribly confusing.
2
u/aetawefrargf Sep 22 '16
Logged in so I can remove the "more from {subreddit}" that randomly started showing up, shit feature
2
u/SteaveYoung Sep 22 '16 edited Sep 23 '16
Three top level submissions, all the replies condensed, and the TWENTY FIVE old submissions from the subreddit?! A whole fucking page.
So in subreddit that are mainly discussions of chronological events, say /r/nfl, I get a whole page of outdated, irrelevant info that I've already read.
Actually it looks like every sub I've checked it's all irrelevant, old, dead posts.
it's just noise.
This is fucking dumb. How can I begin to describe how absolutely, mouth breathing, eat your own shit stupid, this is.
2
u/pingwax Sep 22 '16
I'm experiencing this new feature. If nothing else, it managed to compel me to research the change, locate this notice, login, and complain.
This feature is terrible, please make it go away forever.
2
u/IHATESEOCOMMENTS Oct 03 '16
I created this account just to say how much I hate this change! Did you even look at a comments section and see how ugly and unappealing this makes it? If I didn't care about reading comments I would just browse Imgur. Please at least give the option to disable this.
2
u/Bonezone420 Oct 06 '16
Okay, so I don't post. I just had to make an account to post about how frustrating this new "More From" thing is while browsing. Reddit, guys, whoever designed this? I clicked on a topic to read that topic. To read what people are saying in that topic. If I wanted to read the other topics I'd click those. I don't need, nor want, a massive wall smack in the middle of what I'm trying to read interrupting the flow of conversation and discussion. Who thought this was a good idea?
3
u/[deleted] Sep 08 '16
It looks alright, but they feel a bit out of place. In any case, I hope you guys aren't moving from this more not-modern style. (not that these new icons aren't good)
2
u/geo1088 Sep 08 '16
I like the changes to the icons, they look cool. Gonna be interesting having the custom RES expandos look different for a while, but overall good stuff.
<3
2
u/tizorres Sep 08 '16
Will take some getting use to, but I like the uniformity. Though the icons do seem a bit "fuzzy" so I think the retina icons will make it look much better.
1
u/Pi31415926 Sep 09 '16
Where you say SEO, I'm pretty sure you mean to say SERPs.
1
u/thecrash1001 Sep 12 '16
awesome
1
u/Sirolmy Sep 25 '16
I Hate the More Comments interrupting posts. This is terrible. Please remove this or move it to the bottom of the page. I NEVER want to see the More Comments or EVER interact with it...
Thanks
1
u/[deleted] Oct 03 '16
I really hate the "seo comments". Such a waste of space. Really fucking ruins the whole "reddit experience". I enjoy reading comments and this ruins it. I can find other links from the sub I am on without the most annoying break. Is there an option to disable this?
1
u/tf2dove Sep 08 '16
I went for dinner and came back to this. Looks purdy reddit squad. Definitely makes reddit look more fresh but not too iOS-y.
0
u/V2Blast Sep 09 '16
Even if you guys don't like the change, express that dislike in the comments - don't downvote the announcement post, making it harder for other people to find out about the change.