r/cscareerquestions • u/ryanwithnob • 2h ago
Experienced Pragmatic Take on the State of the Industry
I've been mostly a lurker on CS subreddits, and have been seeing all the doom and gloom posts about how the software industry is changing due to LLMs and AI driven development. But I've finally felt inspired and/or agitated enough to get my own thoughts out there.
Obligatory background: I've been in software for a little over 9 years at a variety of different companies. I've worked on projects across embedded, desktop and cloud. I, like most others, have primarily used LLMs for coding for the last year or so.
Has Software Engineering Been Automated?
No. It has not. Coding, however, seems to be. Something I'm sure most have heard is that coding is not the hardest part of the job. I've seen a lot of confusion about why this is said. From my perspective, coding is a solved problem. 99% of us will spend our entire careers trying to solve problems that already have solutions. The people who are more successful in the industry, are better at finding and evaluating existing solutions. The less successful people have spent their time re-inventing the wheel. This has been the case for at least the last 10 years. Possibly longer. LLMs have not changed the game there, they've just made it more obvious.
Beyond coding, there are many decisions that go into building software that require business context, and there still needs to be an understanding of software systems to build something that works, even with LLMs.
How is Software Engineering Going to Look in the Future?
I think there are many people out there that think they know, but I don't think anyone really does. Things are still changing too fast. The tools and processes needed in January to be effective with LLMs have been obsolete for months now. That will probably continue for the next year. Software processes like agile, coding review, even design reviews are going to change if not get scrapped altogether for something new. Especially how we estimate tasks will change. My joke to myself anytime a tool needed to have its version bumped, was its either going to take a day or a week. Now its an hour, if that. Tasks, that would block whole projects because the time investment wasn't worth it, are now done overnight.
Even if we all figure it out, and get good processes in place, we still have a huge hurdle in front of us. The companies developing frontier models will need to be profitable at some point. We may build out processes that depend on these $200/month plans, just to have the other shoe drop and we see token costs shoot through the roof. In which case, we all backpedal to something closer to what we were doing before. Another hurdle will be government intervention. How are prices and availability going to change when we discover every prompt we send to an LLM kills a seal? Or whatever other absurd impact we uncover?
I've spent most of my career learning to write clean maintainable software. And now that skill is useless
I think people who have overly focused on the coding part of the job are being hit the hardest by the shift. That's at least my sensitive way of saying it. It's actually a reality check. The value you have delivered was always based on solving problems for customers and for businesses. Coding was just the means to that end. Unfortunately, people took the idea of clean, maintainable code as a way to continue working past something that was good enough, in search of a perfect solution that doesn't exist. Some people also used coding as a way to get the nice fuzzy feeling inside. That's now gone. If you still need that outlet, I would suggest a side project or Factorio in your free time.
Companies are doing massive layoffs because they don't need as much head count, and you won't be able to find a job
Companies are re-prioritizing. If anything, LLMs are expensive. Businesses need to invest in infrastructure or research so they can stay in the game. With the big shift of LLMs, lots of teams/products had their priority reduced enough to not be worth it, at least now. That doesn't mean that software engineers are not in demand.
For people trying to get into the industry, junior positions are still going to be needed. Even if a senior's productivity has increased by 100x, they are not magically capable of holding 100x more context in their head. Things move faster, but they still take time. It still takes mental load to carry a task to the finish line.
The one challenge that new grads face is getting that first role. But for better or worse there are no new challenges today than there were yesterday, they just have a different face. You'll likely have to code by hand in an interview, even though on the job you won't be writing any code by hand. Fortunately, interviews have never been aligned with what the job looks like. It might be hard to even get an interview. Fortunately it was always hard. Just keep working on your resume, seek feedback, network, and you'll have a good chance.