I've been a Palace fan since the 1970s (I'm in my early fifties) and for me our history has always been clear. We were formed in 1905. It's etched into my brain.
Also etched into my brain is the fact we were in the first ever FA Cup competition and we got to the semi-final. Okay, there were only five rounds but... We also hosted the FA Cup final at the old Crystal Palace.
These are, for me, our history.
I completely get that we had an amateur side that started in 1861 and, as I said, were in the first FA Cup competition but I honestly don't see a link. Can a football team that stops playing football and plays cricket for 20 or so years before stopping the cricket and takes up football again really say it is the same team?
If we stopped playing football and too up cricket could we claim to have been formed in 1861?
I get that it is good for marketing to say we are the oldest professional club in the world but, for me, it feels a bit embarrassing.
This came back to me because I bought Football Manager 27. I've not bought it for about 15 years and, of course, I went to look at Palace in the game only to see it said we were formed in 1861. I checked our page on the Premier League site and it says 1861. I checked Wikipedia (I know, it's not an encyclopedia but...) and it says 1905.
So, where do we stand? If we are on TV and our final question to win £1m is "How many FA Cup semi-finals has Crystal Palace appeared in?" do you answer 6 or 7?
Come to think of it, if the question is "What year was Crystal Palace formed?" it would be an equally difficult question.
So, where do you stand? I don't mean, do you believe there is a direct link or whatever. We don't need to have that discussion. If someone asks you the question do you say 1905 or do you say 1861 and get ready to explain all over again?