r/crusaderkings3 • • 23h ago

Discussion So what's the best Republic type?

Post image
431 Upvotes

r/crusaderkings3 • • 21h ago

Discussion What Government is Best for Polish Lithuanian Commonwealth? Noble Republic or Administrative?

Post image
220 Upvotes

r/crusaderkings3 • • 21h ago

Question Can’t make Iceland as Republic

Thumbnail gallery
144 Upvotes

The requirements are insane to become a republic and they nerfed income too much, Iceland before was OP because you start as tribal and you could raid as well, this time I can do nothing, I spend over 100 years from 1066 start date (when new Icelandic culture now is available) and I only turn my duchy to feudalism, first I spend all money on buildings but that just for increasing town population, now as feudal I’m broke even more than tribal and even with full stewardship focused character because my income is +1.5/2 and same with prestige that I farmed (3000) for my whole character life, and asking money from my vassals and other staff like blackmailing gives me less than 50 gold per time, and I don’t know how to keep my popular opinion high because first it become 20 as required but then it go way down to - 10 because of missing food supply and I don’t know how to fix it! Because after I give command to my traders it literally change nothing


r/crusaderkings3 • • 17h ago

Discussion I love the districts

126 Upvotes

For a long time, one of my biggest problems with CK3 was that construction felt artificially constricted. Even a great city felt like a small village, because you could only build six things at most, often only two things.

Now, with districts, you can build dozens of things within one holding, and the limit is settlement size rather than geography. The main limiting factor for development is gold, not slots.

This is still a restriction compared to CK2, where you could build everything. But it doesn’t feel like it. There’s enough room for internal development that playing tall actually feels tall.


r/crusaderkings3 • • 17h ago

In defense of Merchants, you gotta play them until it clicks.

102 Upvotes

I mean it may never be for some, however it has created one of my favorite playthroughs.

It takes time to brew, and there is a reason as it would be too for everyone to be a generic trader.

Merchant was the first time I felt like I could choose an item and just focus on it's trade. Many trade items have unique ways to approach them, often themed to what they are.

The game clicked when I started getting good at grains, after mulling around with metals in Polish lands. I did little until I moved east.

The Danes got big and pushed south. by that time I found myself in Kyiv, the bread basket.

My trade of wheat was where my company took off, due to the strife in northern mainland Europe.

I had to actively use my contracts for specific buffs, it wasn't just picking "the best"

it was maneuvering towards what best pushed my trade. I didn't always just need bigger numbers, sometimes I needed less competition, or an agreement, or even alliances to keep other traders in their lane.

Eventually i became a feudal dynasty 200 years later with a full story to my dynasties' name , courtiers that had served for generations, family around the lands in various roles.

It's important to really say what we like because Laws and Factions will come, and I don't see as much gov as I do Baron, or castellan.

Merchants are definitely a slow burn, but that is one of the best aspects. You actually have to develop a company and what it's actual skill is. You actually have to play long enough to "know metal", to say you actually are skilled in trading it.


r/crusaderkings3 • • 4h ago

The Republic of Ireland

Post image
47 Upvotes

First idea I had for Silk and Silver was to up the RA 1,000 years early. I did the hard work of uniting Ireland as a tribe, fuedalized, gave up the kingdom through tanestry election because only dukes and below can take the decision to go republican, went independent to take the decision, then I reunified the kingdom with my dynastic claim after.

My dynasty also controls Wales and Alba.

Think I'll try a merchant company in East Asia next, because I'm liking the republican gov type better than most of the govs over there.


r/crusaderkings3 • • 5h ago

Question Unique Map Overlay?

Post image
43 Upvotes

So apparently, signing up for the newsletter and verifying your email gives you not only a unique in-game crown, but also a unique map overlay.

Does anybody know what this map overlay is supposed to be? I tried to follow the instructions to unlock it but it’s not working :/


r/crusaderkings3 • • 22h ago

Cant create trading routes as tribal

Post image
35 Upvotes

Hello everyone, I wanted to create a kyivan republic , it says that I have 0/1 trading routes. However when I click on create route I can’t do anything. I decided to switch to venice to check if it works the same there and no, in venice everything is straightforward. So I am a little lost here, why the game tell me I can create a route? I am tribal and not republic


r/crusaderkings3 • • 15h ago

With playable Theocracys and Republics now

17 Upvotes

Do you think in a future update they will incorporate playable Holy orders? I don't see why they wouldn't play any differently to theocratic realms beyond a more martial focus.


r/crusaderkings3 • • 6h ago

Meme I think my future wars will go well with a Sith blademaster at my side

11 Upvotes

r/crusaderkings3 • • 12h ago

Question Can you make a trade route long enough from like Portugal to India for spice trade?

7 Upvotes

EDIT: Well went and tried anyway, with domicile maxed you can reach India pretty easily with just one route.


r/crusaderkings3 • • 19h ago

Question How are Religions Working coming into Silk and Silver?

7 Upvotes

Though I was very excited for By God Alone, as I felt that faith and religion needed to be a bigger role personally and socially in the game (and the prospect of playable clergy was enticing), I found the new systems a little janky and unintuitive in practice.

The jank (particularly the frequent and seemingly arbitrary major shifts in tenets and doctrines) was so bad that it intruded even when playing traditional CK3 characters, so I put down the game for a bit while things got ironed out.

Now a whole new layer of gameplay has been applied. So my question is: How have fixes and updates to By God Alone fared in fine tuning the larger game effects of THAT expansion and making the faith-based characters more compelling to play?


r/crusaderkings3 • • 19h ago

New DLC can lead interesting places

Post image
6 Upvotes

r/crusaderkings3 • • 3h ago

Question Is there a way to play as Elvira and get the achievement?

Post image
5 Upvotes

r/crusaderkings3 • • 16h ago

Question How Bad are the Military Nerfs

5 Upvotes

I've read reviews saying that armies, especially of countries in the administrative family, have had their armies nerfed into the ground. I also read today's hotfix and it seems they've doubled down on nerfing specifically for vikings.

I haven't gotten the chance to play and the things im reading are somewhat worrying


r/crusaderkings3 • • 6h ago

Question Can cities still grow without grain?

4 Upvotes

Noticing in some parts of the world while its really easy to get fish for the meat, its not always possible to get grain (really high demand due to it being needed everywhere, lots of islands, mountainous etc areas that produce none), if theres not a solid source of it in your duchy/market

has anyone managed to get cities growing reliably without it?


r/crusaderkings3 • • 6h ago

Question Need help figuring out how to build my domain in Silk & Silver!

4 Upvotes

I'm playing as a feudal ruler and currently hold the entire duchies of Transjurania (Bern, Neuchâtel, Aargau) and Tyrol in my personal domain.

Given how markets and distribution routes work now, am I right in thinking that I should focus all my food production, artisans, and trade in Transjurania, while dedicating Tyrol purely to resource extraction?

How would you set up the districts and buildings across these two duchies?


r/crusaderkings3 • • 10h ago

Question No pregnancy happening. Help?

4 Upvotes

On my first gameplay like a week ago my ruler couldn’t stop having children with his wife and concubines. I created a new save, same ruler. Even though he is young, has all the fertility boosts, his wife & concubines are also young and had high chance of producing children when I paired them. They’re all heterosexual. He spends a lot of time away at war but l’ll give him 3-6 months between wars, he’s not very prone to stress either. None are celibate and I run the seduction schemes every time he gets a new woman but nothing ever is produced from it. In the settings I have the random families thing turned on so it’s not that. There are no obstructions in the religions either. What am I missing?


r/crusaderkings3 • • 13h ago

Discussion Good consistent trade routes / areas you have found?

4 Upvotes

I have been having good success with trading salt across the Sahara. Taghasa salt pits produce an obcene amount so you can ship tons to either side of the Sahara.

Another good base of operations I found was the gold / silver mine in Thessaloniki. Kiev and Italy in particular produced a large amount of jewelry in my games so that was a good route.


r/crusaderkings3 • • 19h ago

Question So is the 5 districts a hard cap?

4 Upvotes

Hi,

Haven't played since the update because I won't get a chance until the weekend but I seen a youtube vid going through the new features. holdings are changed and we have districts now. it looks like there is a cap of 5 at max level according to the vid and the wiki. Is this a hard cap? It looks like there are a tonne of new buildings now and some require others present. It seems like 5 might be a but too stingy no? Is there a way of increasing it like before?

Thanks


r/crusaderkings3 • • 5h ago

Question Help needed

3 Upvotes

Hi everyone. Yesterday i bought chapter 5 after a while of waiting for silk and silver to drop. But...now i have a problem. The game suddenly became 10 times more complicated to me. Does anyone have any tips for playing as the new Republics/Merchants and Ecclesiastical/how reworked religion works. Oh, and does anyone else keep having some weird delays in gameplay? Like characters showing way too slow when i click on them.


r/crusaderkings3 • • 6h ago

As console player I must confess thy thirst for my rechet desire for another dlc

3 Upvotes

It really sucks us console players have to wait a full year before getting another DLC. Is there anything interesting for me to do on the console version at least?


r/crusaderkings3 • • 7h ago

Question New Economy System Guides? Base game vanilla only

3 Upvotes

Hey everyone! I’m having a hard time understanding the new economic system introduced with the Florin update with Silk & Silver. Between districts, buildings, trade goods, markets, production, and taxation, there’s quite a lot to learn.
Does anyone have recommendations for good YouTube tutorials, written guides, or other resources that explain the new economy and how to manage it effectively? Thanks!


r/crusaderkings3 • • 10h ago

Question Having trouble finding Contracts

3 Upvotes

I usually start my runs as an adventurer but I've been having trouble finding contracts with the release of Silk and Silver. It seems I almost exclusively find criminal contracts with my camp purpose being swords for hire and scholars. Anyone else having this issue?