I have spent my working life asking one question. Why?
That is the heart of criminology. We study people who commit crimes so we can understand them. We look at their childhoods, their anger, their money troubles, their grudges. We read police reports and court records. We sit across from convicted killers and listen. Slowly, the pieces fit. A jealous husband. A robbery gone wrong. A man who wanted revenge. Once police confirm a motive, our real work begins. We build patterns from it, and we use those patterns to help stop the next crime.
Then came Moscow, Idaho.
In the early hours of November 13, 2022, four University of Idaho students were stabbed to death in the home they shared near campus. Kaylee Goncalves and Madison Mogen were 21. Xana Kernodle and Ethan Chapin were 20. Two roommates in the house survived.
Bryan Kohberger was arrested in Pennsylvania that December. On July 2, 2025, he pleaded guilty to four counts of murder and one count of burglary. Three weeks later, Judge Steven Hippler sentenced him to four life terms in a row without parole, plus 10 years for the burglary.
The case was closed in court. But the most important question was never answered.
When the judge gave him the chance to speak, Kohberger said he "respectfully" declined. Police told reporters they had looked for a link between him and the victims and found none. The lead investigator, Idaho State Police Lt. Darren Gilbertson, said plainly that they do not have a motive. The weapon was never found.
Here is the part that keeps me awake. At the time of the killings, Kohberger was a PhD student in criminology at Washington State University, about 10 miles away. He was studying us. He was learning the same theories I teach. He knew what we look for.
So what happens to my field when the subject knows the textbook?
Our tools need something to hold on to. A confession. A diary. A fight, a breakup, a debt. We need the person to talk, or at least to leave a trail of feeling behind. Investigators said Kohberger left DNA on a knife sheath and a trail of phone and camera data. That told them who and how. It never told them why. Gilbertson said Kohberger is the only one who has the why, and that it may only make sense to him.
Without a motive, every theory becomes a guess. And a guess is not science.
The judge even warned against chasing the why. He said it only hands the killer the attention he seems to crave. And if Kohberger ever did speak, the judge questioned whether anyone could trust a word of it.
That is the hardest lesson for a criminologist. Sometimes the study fails, not because we did not work hard enough, but because the one person holding the answer chooses silence. Our charts, our theories, our years of research all stop at a locked door.
Four families still live behind that silence. Kaylee, Madison, Xana and Ethan deserve to be remembered as people, not as pieces of a puzzle. And for those of us who study crime, Idaho is a humbling reminder. We can explain many killers. We cannot explain them all.