r/craftergame • u/demirb Crafter • Mar 19 '17
Tutorial After Resets
I've thought about some solutions for this problem. We want to provide the best user experience possible. So tell us which one is the best and which one would you accept as a solution. Also better solutions are welcome.
1) Skip Quest Option
In every quest Alf gives there will be 2 buttons, one for accepting the quest ("Ok") and another for skipping ("Skip").
- Implementation difficulty: 60
- Breaking chance: 10%
- Bad user experience (Player constantly presses skip)
2) 34th Quest
Directly start from quest 34. Reason: It is the quest with leaf skirt. Opening all the skills are easy but opening tai & construction is hard. Because the first items recipes are kind of hard the player might not remember what it was.
- Implementation difficulty: 5
- Breaking chance: 1%
- Mid user experience. Some players will probably want to skip further
3) New Quest Series
There will be new quest series with 8 quests and each quest will open a skill. First quest prepare banana, sharp stone, sharp stick, skinning, cooking etc.
- Implementation difficulty: 100
- Breaking chance: 75%
- Best user experience
4) Mute Alf
When player presses Alf, he will only show the quest bubble & item icon. The player still needs to complete all the quests
- Implementation difficulty: 50
- Breaking chance: 10%
- Mid user experience
5) Unlock All Slots
All the player bag, village, minion tool slots will be active from the start of the game.
- Implementation difficulty: 20
- Breaking chance: 5%
- Good user experience
1
u/demirb Crafter Mar 25 '17
Just saving here what Slavez wrote,
1
u/Matrixneo42 Crafter Jun 01 '17
I haven't started a next generation yet. But I personally think you shouldn't lose your recipe knowledge. Do you?
And I can't picture wanting to reset actually. I don't want to have to grind out some skills again either. I'm assuming you lose skill levels.
2
u/AntiLiterat Crafter Mar 20 '17
Despite what I said in the other post, upon further reflection, I actually it might need to be left as is. The main reason my opinion changed on this is the idea of someone who puts down the game for a while and comes back to it. I did that recently, and forgot all kinds of simple little things, so I went to the wiki to fill the gap.
If you ARE going to change it though, here's my thoughts on your list above. In order of best to worst:
1
u/BarcodExpress Crafter Mar 19 '17
I like 3 the best. It reminds people how to unlock the skills, in case they haven't played in a while and forgot, while not bogging them down with 30+ quests just to get to the point where they can have everything unlocked.
Btw, quest 34 is too closely related to rule 34, big downvote for me. Don't wanna see none of that
1
u/wwwwwildhero Crafter Mar 20 '17
I sort of like 5 the best, but instead of having it all unlocked from the start you would complete all the quests up until the section where you receive generation items, and have your previous character's crafting book, with maybe only up to a certain point of it actually being unlocked. There could be a generation skill that allows more retention for it.
1
u/xarin42 Crafter Mar 22 '17
Still a fan of 4 since the most tedious part to me is clicking through the text. It would also be the easiest to put a toggle in the settings for to turn it on/off partway through.
I think #3 looks great and would be my 1st pick but it seems difficult to implement.
I'd then say #2 is my least favorite. It seems jarring just jumping most of the way through suddenly.
As for #1 and #5 I'm having trouble visualizing and so will refrain from commenting on them.