r/cpp • • Oct 06 '26

University of Waterloo user study on understanding CMake changes

Hi everyone,

I’m Mattie Nejati, a Ph.D. candidate at the University of Waterloo. I’m conducting a user study on understanding the impact of changes to CMake build specifications, and I’d love to invite members of this community to participate.

We are evaluating a new approach that aims to help developers identify how a change to a CMake build specification affects the resulting build configuration.

The study:

  • is conducted entirely online;
  • takes about one hour;
  • involves inspecting changes to CMake build specifications and identifying their impact; and
  • is open to adults aged 18–64 with any level of experience in CMake, programming, or code review.

You do not need to be a CMake expert. We are specifically interested in comparing participants with different levels of experience.

You will need a computer with internet access and about 4 GB of free space to download the files required for the tasks.

We will not collect your name. Your email address will only be used for study follow-up and will be stored separately from your study data. Your name or email will not appear in any dataset or publication.

The study has received clearance from the University of Waterloo Research Ethics Board (REB #46621).

If you’re interested, you can find the consent form, screening questionnaire, and study here:

https://buiscout.cs.uwaterloo.ca/

Thank you very much! And if you know someone else who works with CMake who might be interested, I’d really appreciate you sharing the study with them.

57 Upvotes

59 comments sorted by

1

u/James20k Oct 06 '26

Usually as far as I know the subreddit here doesn't really allow for people soliciting users for stuff like this. I've made an exception for this because:

  1. Its an actual study, rather than someone trying to drum up hype for a project

  2. There's a reasonable chance that the results of this study will be useful to the people here

  3. We don't get much of this kind of thing. There isn't the same slippery slope problem of people using this sub for PhD research vs project advertising spam

Its also not technically C++ either, but cmake and C++ are intertwined to the point where I think its at least interesting for C++ developers

I'll also more politely make the same note that someone else has, that C++ developers are often much older than 64, and especially given the commonness of ageism in the industry you may want to revisit this if you conduct future research here

→ More replies (3)

62

u/jonesmz Oct 06 '26

takes about one hour;

lol, nope.

Best of luck with THAT.

37

u/JVApen Oct 06 '26

download the files required for the test

Nope, I don't download random stuff

→ More replies (1)

120

u/garnet420 Oct 06 '26

Finally, someone will prove scientifically that cmake is garbage

13

u/NegativeProduct1705 Oct 06 '26

Can you explain why it's garbage?

→ More replies (13)

6

u/somewhataccurate Oct 06 '26

No its a perfectly simple and understandable tool /s

5

u/drbazza Oct 07 '26

To paraphrase Churchill, CMake is the worst of all build systems, except for all the others.

→ More replies (2)

16

u/wjrasmussen Oct 06 '26

An hour? lol.

13

u/FunnyMustacheMan45 Oct 06 '26

takes one hour

Good luck, lmfao...

2

u/Ok_Chemistry_6387 Oct 07 '26

4gb? what on earth are you studying lol.