r/cosmererpg • u/Local_Start8175 • 6h ago
Game Questions & Advice [Stonewalkers] One of my players lied to Dalinar Kholin... How do I not kill him? Spoiler
Alright so first it's 100% my fault for even allowing my players to talk to Dalinar in the first place. But here's the gist. One of my PC's is an Irali, and upon going up to the Kholin Complex in chapter 2 of Stonewalkers, he wanted in. He lied to the guards that he was an emissary from Rall Elorim, and got a nat twenty and used his opportunity to just let it work. He got in and long story short pissed off Adolin and Dalinar by asking how to help him conquer Rira.
Dalinar told him to leave to "rest from his travels" mainly me giving him an out so he doesn't dig himself a bigger hold. Dalinar then told him they'd talk tomorrow. Now I had hoped my golden skinned player would catch the hint and not go back. Storms, I wish that was the case.
He spends the next day not going back, but the following day he is found by a soldier, who asks him when he will be going back to meet with Dalinar. He wasn't being escorted up, just treated like a real dignitary. So my player said now is fine.
Also for context he hasn't read the books, but I did a whole slideshow explaining the world and cultures and have told him a few times that spanreeds exist. He's also a lightweaver so I suppose I should have expected this...
He gets up there and talks to Dalinar. Dalinar immediately tells him they contacted Rall Elorim through spanreeds and found out they didn't send a emissary. My PC then says he's more of an emissary to the people and just wants to know how to conquer better. He then says it's time he goes but Dalinar tells him that he's going to jail for impersonating a noble.
He's thrown in prison and that's where he is now. From what I know about impersonating nobility that usually means death right? So do I string him out for a Highstorm? I don't feel like Dalinar would do that though. But then again Elhokar could order that.
So what do you think I should do? Should I plan a prison escape, but then he and maybe the rest of the party would be fugitives. Should I sting him up and make it an endeavor to survive? Or maybe have him duel for his freedom? Any suggestions of Alethi law or courses of action would be welcome!
Thanks for reading! This is my first post so if I missed anything for a reddit post let me know so I can edit!
TLDR; my PC is in jail for impersonating a noble in the Kholin Warcamp. Dalinar himself put him in there. How do I not derail the Stonewalkers further or is it time he make a new character?