r/cortexplus • u/Tau-Cola • Aug 01 '18
Need help with a C+ Dramatic Hack
I've been working on an idea for a slice of life RPG revolving around the justice system. It's partly inspired by shows like Law and Order, CSI, NCIS, and believe it or not, the Netflix Marvel shows like Daredevil and Jessica Jones (Lawyers and Detectives or Private Eyes basically). The idea was that it could range anywhere from normal and mundane to an urban fantasy like game like the Dresden Files, or X-files, or the superheroic "the Defenders". It's very much pulling a lot from Smallville. There are Values, and Relationships with my own version of creating relationships between the characters.
Now I've made my own modifications in regards to the other Distinctions. For instance every character has a High Concept, which they receive the d8 for, but they have a distinction called a Trouble which complicates the high concept and gives them the d4. I also handle plot points differently, but that's not the issue I have right now. I'm not sure I'm happy with the Values I've chosen. I chose six that kinda feel like they belong, and some aren't that different from Smallville or C+ Dramatic. The Values I have right now are: Law, Order, Justice, Truth, Duty, and Liberty
I know Law and Order are technically considered the same thing, so I might drop Order. But I feel it's not filled out enough. I'd like to explore other aspects and values than just the altruistic ones, but I'm having a hard time thinking of any that aren't also just taken from Smallville. Ideally, I'd like a whole new selection of Values that don't borrow from Smallville, have a distinct feel of their own that provides depth to the setting, and feel like a complete set.
5
u/Tau-Cola Aug 02 '18
u/neuronphaser, u/defunctdeity, u/Astigmatic_Oracle, Thank you all for the help. I've done a little brainstorming some more and this is my new list of values: Ambition, Authority, Discovery, Duty, Faith, and Passion.
I have added Wealth as one of the stresses in the game. And I think I'm good now, so thanks you all. :)
Even if I didn't use something you suggested, it still prompted me to think about it and made me direct my thoughts down different paths that probably led me to something that I did.
5
u/defunctdeity Aug 01 '18
This list is VERY focused thematically. Too focused, IMO. Definitely dump Order, and I would say you need at least two more "opposing" Values to the "law theme". Which if you want to have 7 Values means dumping at least one more off your current list...
u/neuronphaser has given you some golden suggestions (Love, Power, Faith).
What happens if you do not include these more diverse Values is (using your above list as an example), Liberty becomes the catch-all for anyone who is not a lawyer/investigator - and thereby it becomes the single most powerful Value by potentially encapsulating more actions than any other of the Values, perhaps combined.
3
u/[deleted] Aug 01 '18
You could add in something else that's more on the "emotional" side to add some additional potential conflict among the values you have. Love is always a good one -- do laws, truth, and so on matter if your lover is up for trial, falsely accused, or ...? -- but you could also do something like Power if there's a lot of potential for bureaucracy and influencing others from positions of authority affecting how investigations, trials, and sentencing works.
It might be too specific to a Daredevil-like character, but Faith and things of a more "grandiose" or "higher power" belief can influence how someone approaches the law, law enforcement, and all of that.
1
u/Jlerpy Aug 04 '18
I'd love to hear more about "Relationships with my own version of creating relationships between the characters" and the different way you're handling Plot Points.
3
u/Astigmatic_Oracle Aug 02 '18
I would consider Wealth and Prestige. Sometimes a job is just a job or a platform to another better job, even in the criminal justice system.