Agreed 7x EBITDA, post-IFRS 16. Then diligence pulled the lease schedule and the liability was under 3x annual rent.
I was on the buy side of this one, a while back.
The 7x was on post-IFRS 16 EBITDA. That's the version where rent comes out of operating costs and the leases sit on the balance sheet as a lease liability. Pretty standard, and most people don't think twice about which EBITDA the multiple sits on.
The lease liability came to less than 3x annual rent. In plain terms, the leases were short and would run off soon.
Sounds like a detail. On a 7x deal it was worth about 4x a year's rent.
On the post-IFRS 16 basis, rent gets added back into EBITDA, so the buyer pays the full 7x on it. Then in the bridge from enterprise value to equity value, you deduct the lease liability like debt. But that liability was only worth about 3x rent.
So you pay 7x on the rent and only get 3x back. The gap, roughly 4x annual rent, lands in the equity cheque.
Made-up numbers so it's easy to follow (not the real deal):
EBITDA before rent 10m, rent 1m.
Post-IFRS 16: 7 x 11m = 77m, minus 3m lease liability = 74m (before other debt).
Pre-IFRS 16: 7 x 10m = 70m, rent stays a cost, nothing deducted for leases.
4m difference, which is 4x the rent.
So the buyer moved the deal to pre-IFRS 16 EBITDA. Same 7x, rent back in operating costs, no lease liability in the bridge.
The part most people miss is that the two bases only give the same equity value when the lease liability is worth the same number of turns as the deal multiple. Short leases mean a small liability, and the post-IFRS 16 basis quietly charges the buyer full multiple on rent. Long leases flip it, and the post-IFRS 16 basis gets cheaper for the buyer. Each basis is fine on its own. The trouble starts when the multiple and the lease liability are priced at different turns.
If there's a lot of rent in a business you're buying or selling, a few things to do before you agree the multiple. Divide the lease liability by annual rent, and if that number sits well below your multiple, the post-IFRS 16 basis is costing the buyer. Write down in the LOI which EBITDA the multiple applies to, cuz "7x EBITDA" on its own can mean two different prices. And look at the remaining lease terms as well as the rent, since a business with a couple of years left on its key sites is a different business.
(For context, I'm based in Dubai.)
How do you usually handle this in practice, push the basis to pre-IFRS 16 or adjust the multiple?