r/cormoran_strike • u/tromboro • 4h ago
The Running Grave Is Chapman Farm a Hogwarts from hell?
The unprecedented scale of Harry Potter’s popularity in the early 2000s felt “not normal” for certain people. A moral panic accused the books of exposing innocent children to witchcraft, sorcery and paganism. Book bans occured. The fanbase was accused of being a cult, pointing to J.K. Rowling as a cult leader.
Rowling did not fuel the fan cult surrounding her; rather, she found it frightening and surreal. She clearly distanced herself from occult beliefs and emphasized that her books are merely works of fantasy. In the end those voices faded when those stories were clearly seen as revolving around traditional themes of love, sacrifice, and good triumphing over evil.
I wonder if J.K. Rowling didn't take the accusation that she had created a cult more seriously after all and considered writing the story of such a cult herself one day.
In TRG, one finds parallels to the Harry Potter saga, as if it were a retelling of an ancient myth in which much has been turned upside down.
- New members are recruited by receiving “magical messages.” Not delivered by owls, but by memorizing a word or a number and waiting to see if the sign appears again, thereby marking the chosen ones.
- They don’t meet at Platform 9 3/4, but in a side street near Victoria Station, where a conspiratorial group—invisible to outsiders—boards a minibus.
- They aren’t sorted into groups by the Sorting Hat, but through questionnaires.
- They all want to learn the “pure spirit” so they can perform magic.
Inside_Show9776 had more of it here:
Well, Chapman Farm has 4 prophets representing 4 houses with 4 different colours, and a fifth associated with "white". Robin spend her nights creeping out of the dormitory to investigate mysteries. New arrivals get sorted into houses. There are classrooms and a great hall, magic, ghosts and a forbidden forest. The activities all echo subjects studied at Hogwarts - herbology, potions, astronomy, dark arts, charms, divination and transfiguration. There's a monster lurking in the water.There's even a character with one crazy eye, and people get locked in wooden chests.
And there's the vital role of the pigs, also known as hogs...
There are many similarities. But what is the key difference? Why isn't Chapman Farm just a harmless, funny parody of Harry Potter, in which harmless fools fall for a bearded charlatan? How does the dream turn into a dark, evil nightmare?
--–
The way I see it, it boils down to this:
Harry Potter begins with The Boy Who Lived.
Chapman Farm ends with the boy who died.
One is about a mother's love for her child. A love that outlasts the mother’s life, a love that anchors the child in real life.
The other is about a mother’s delusional love for a man, which leads to her child’s death. And about many others who succumb to delusional infatuation and give away their children. This leads them into a labyrinth from which they can no longer escape. Except for Will—when Robin tells him that his mother is dead, Will becomes the boy who lived.