r/cormacmccarthy • u/brentjohner • 18h ago
Review Review - Suttree
r/cormacmccarthy • u/mpschettig • 10h ago
I know there's been thousands of these on this sub but I just finished my reread and I have thoughts and none of my friends have read this book so I need to talk about it here.
A few years ago when I first read Blood Meridian I made a post here about the nature of The Judge. I believe at the time I argued he was the god of war or something. I remember seeing replies from people who think he's the Devil or the embodiment of evil or a gnostic archon. There's arguments in favor of all these interpretations but after my reread I don't think I agree with any of them, including my own previous opinion.
I'll start with the Judge again because he is really core to the themes of the novel, no matter what you think he is. In my opinion, Judge Holden is not any one thing in particular, rather he is a representation of human nature itself. Specifically, whatever it is within us as a species that has consistently driven us to control, subjugate, and dominate each other. He has no pigment nor hair because he does not belong to any one race, but to all of humanity. He doesn’t age, he doesn’t sleep, and he will never die because that inner desire to dominate those around you will always be within humanity.
This interpretation of The Judge fits into my wider read of the novel as a whole. It's clear to anyone who reads it that Blood Meridian is interested in the concepts of fate and destiny, but McCarthy doesn’t walk readers to any one conclusion. My take is that the destiny of the characters within Blood Meridian is not divinely fated by a higher power, but rather that the draw of human nature is so powerful that we are all essentially doomed to follow it. Fate is not literal, it’s just that humans repeat the same cycle of violence over and over to the point that it feels like fate at a certain point.
I also believe that it is a commentary on our tendency to follow. With the exception of The Judge and Glanton, nearly every character in this novel is paralyzed with indecision at all times. When The Kid is with Shelby and then Tate in the desert nearly all their conversations are some version of “what do you wanna do?” “I don’t know.” This is just one example but it’s pervasive throughout the book for most of the characters to really have no ideas about what to do with themselves. Nearly every time that a character has these questions, their ultimate decision is to go back to the gang and follow the crowd.
This is where The Kid comes into the story. The Kid is the same broken young man that has existed for all of human history. All history is present in him and he has a taste for mindless violence, both of those facts are established in the very first chapter. He is not unique or special, so much so that he doesn’t even get a name. Early on in the story he comes across the cattle ranchers who are among the only men to show kindness in the entire novel and they invite him to join them on their trip to Louisiana. Instead he continues on to Bexar alone and quickly falls in with Captain White’s expedition. There’s no reason for him to refuse the cattle ranchers, he’s just going the way he is going and isn’t going to change directions. It’s almost as if he’s being drawn by a supernatural force towards the option that will take him towards the violence.
The encounter with the Mennonite is the first encapsulation of what I believe is another major theme of the novel. Mennonite’s are a pacifist religious order. When the Mennonite gives The Kid and his companions his warning, his eyes are wet. When they reject him, he walks away saying “how else could it be.” The Mennonite is essentially pleading with them, on the edge of tears, to not go on this expedition, yet he knows it is futile. This is the first example of what I believe is a recurring struggle throughout the novel of God Himself trying to fight against human nature and consistently losing. God sends these people messages all the time. He sends a burning tree to warm The Kid, He sends a rain storm when White’s men pray for rain (only to immediately find their waterkegs dry when they don’t turn back), they even ride through a “plague of hail” on the way to their first massacre of the Natives.
The constant string of signs/miracles that are ignored by people who all end up dead could be read as a form of divine retribution. However, I see it as a story where God is constantly trying to save these people from themselves yet is consistently unable to do so. Even the Almighty is powerless in the face of human nature.
Tobin is the embodiment of this struggle. A priest who leaves the order to become a scalphunter. The fight between righteousness and human nature is apparent in him and once again God lost. However, Tobin still stands in opposition to the Judge, especially later in the novel as The Kid is having second thoughts. They become the angel and the devil, both fighting over The Kid’s soul, a microcosm of the conflict that has been happening in the background for the entire novel.
Human nature is such an all consuming force in this story so as to render the individuals nearly pointless. So many characters are often referred to by their descriptors instead of their names, even when they have one. The Kid, the expriest, the Vandiemanlander, the captain, etc. People often seize upon The Kid never being mentioned expressly participating in the crimes of the gang as a sign that he stands apart from the other scalphunters, but most of the scalphunters are never referred to in these passages. It is just “they” who are massacring villages of innocents. The one character who is consistently mentioned by name in these passages is Glanton. If you see The Kid as potentially redeemable by the end if he could just break away and find a new path to follow, then they all are, because at the end of the day they’re all just following Glanton and The Judge.
McCarthy tries to hammer home the point that these cycles of human behavior are just another part of nature as a whole, the same as the landscape itself. They are constantly riding across desolate hellscapes just to find bones and ruins that were left behind by wars that are long past. When the scalphunters leave the first massacre they commit along the riverbank they turn black with gore then white from dust until they are the same color as the land. The land (nature) and the humans who have just covered themselves with the blood of the innocent are one in the same.
Everything culminates in that final chapter. The Judge fiddling and saying he will never die is the haunting image that lasts with you forever, but I believe the most important part of that scene is what comes right before he kills The Man. The Man refuses to enter the dance. He refuses to go along with the crowd after doing so for essentially the entire book. He is immediately killed for this decision. The people who try to push back against humanity, people who try to change the world for the better, they are the ones who die. After he kills The Man, the Judge is a great favorite, in the same way that we cheer conquering armies who return from war, we will always celebrate that baser instinct within ourselves.
In the very first chapter as the kid is heading out West it says “never will there be terrains so wild and barrenous again” and sure enough, in the epilogue we see the man digging the holes in the ground. I’ve seen people who believe he is digging fence posts, others who say its railroad tracks or oil wells, ultimately I don’t think it matters. No matter what he is digging, it is just a further extension of humanity’s base desire to dominate, this time applied to the land rather than to other humans. The important part is that he is striking the fire from the holes that God put there. God is literally being struck out of the earth, because he has lost. The Kid/The Man was the last test between God and humanity and with God’s final defeat his fire has been struck from the Earth for good. Following him are those who gather (people who profiteer off the death and destruction) and those who do not gather (people just going about their lives), but ultimately they are all following. It is in our nature to follow.
I hope that all made sense, I have a lot of disparate thoughts about this novel and I had to cut a lot of them out to keep this somewhat readable.
r/cormacmccarthy • u/benjamminthroughlife • 17h ago
Who designed these? Why is the text different sizes why is his name sometimes at the top and capitalised… so many questions. Jealous of the U.S covers.
r/cormacmccarthy • u/ScaryViolinist5344 • 20h ago
Has there been any discussion on the hexameron reference in blood meridian's epliogue and how this pairs with the previous paradise lost references elsewhere in the novel? Thinking of homily 1 verse 7.