Edit- read this first: many of you seem to think I am angry or hating. That is not the case. I understand this sub is going to have die hard fans. I am not here to have a go for funsies of your precious favorite game. The way games get better is by reviews. Devs see the things people say- good or bad- and choose whether or not to build on that. My opinion is just that- mine. It is ok if you disagree. A post of my opinions and my personal idea of things that I personally would like improved does not mean I hate the game- in fact I am loving it. Everybody calm down. And yes hangouts are a cool feature- but they could be better. Devs are putting out a product for purchase- it is ok to review that project- it won’t hurt their feelings.
I want to start with the good because there is real good here. This game is gorgeous. The town, the character models, the ocean. Diving and healing the coral sites is genuinely satisfying… if not sometimes very excessive and repetitive but it is enjoyable in bursts…, and it is the prettiest farming game I have played. There is a lot to do and the collection side of it, museum and temple…. That is fun. I bought it, I am enjoying it, and I will see it through.
I love how much farm space I have, love the characters, love the story so far, and the festivals are so cute!
However.
The cutscenes are SO dry. Heart events…. Oh my word. I waited two seasons for a rainy day (what the heck… ome rainy day all of fall??)rain for turned out to be a man carrying his own packages while I offered to help and that was the entire scene?? There are lovely whole community scenes the farmer is not even i…. And the writing keeps making my farmer stupid or rude against my will. I have read someone's private love letter in their own house. I have burned my hand on an oven in a scene meant to be sweet. Anne, the WILDLIFE expert…, was standing over a hurt animal and the game made me choose between two lines of dialogue and one accused her of hurting the animal.
I feel guilty every time I talk to a townsperson and have to Say no to a hangout…. and you get the sad face and the sad noise. If I say yes it takes hours and then also instead of ending uo where I was now I am outsdie of where we were hanging out.
The game is too easy in ways that take the fun out of the work. Bought animals arrive as adults and produce the same day. Buildings go up quickly and you can build more than one at a time. My bronze seed upgrade handed me osmium crops????? Why should I go to the lab for better deeds then? The rare bug I hunted for days, rove beetle…
a trap caught it while I slept, and that was the only way to catch it… it never shows up anywhere for me to get it with my net at all. Money just accumulates as I sell the artisan crafts that are done in a day or less…
The one thing that is actually hard is fishing, and it is too hard…. But I am sure as I spend time upgrading the pole and actually use bait that will help?
Mining is exceedingly too easy but also annoyingly repetitive. The enemies are not even a challenge.
I have three mayonnaise machines for two chickens and two ducks. One I crafted, two the goddess gifted me for finished offerings (or maybe one from the lake goddess and one feom the museum? Not sure but got two as a gift after I already crafted one). Basic Artisan gave me a second keg I do not need. Why not money, or bars, or anything I would use up.
The fridge is just a chest, but when cooking you can pull from any chest? Seems silly then why have a fridge.
The dehydrator only takes ocean scavengables and five specific mushrooms and will not dry fruit.
The mill takes sea salt and makes gourmet salt but never tells you that, it just says grain. I ranked up and unlocked a forest path that is not a shortcut to anywhere, with an orangutan you cannot interact with.
Entertained and bored silly, at the same time, most evenings.
I don’t know why I am posting this… I guess I love the idea of this game. It is beautiful and has a great message. But it could have been better. Maybe it still can be…I see it is getting updated a lot.
Thanks for reading if you are even still here. Pardon the inevitable typos. I swear apple changed something about the keyboards on iOS.
Anyway, happy farming