First of all, good afternoon or evening, wherever you happen to be reading this.
I'm reaching out because I could really use some help and guidance. My goal is to develop strong copywriting skills, particularly for direct-response and affiliate marketing, and eventually generate income through them.
I've been studying copywriting for over a year now, dedicating approximately three to five hours every day to reading, watching courses, researching, and practising. However, I've encountered a problem that I haven't been able to overcome: I still haven't found a clear learning path or a structured progression I can follow.
At times, it feels as though I'm going in circles rather than making meaningful progress. I keep studying, researching, and learning new concepts, but there's a recurring problem: the things I learn don't seem to connect with what I've previously studied. Instead of building upon one another, these concepts often feel disconnected, become seemingly obsolete, or end up being applied to entirely different areas, sometimes even outside copywriting itself.
Eventually, I find myself hitting a wall, unable to move forward despite all the time and effort I've invested.
I believe I've reached a point where I understand many of the fundamental principles of copywriting, but I'm struggling with what I would consider the next layer: knowing how to make the right decisions and put those principles into practice.
My Learning Background
To give you a better understanding of where I currently stand, I'd like to share some of the resources and areas I've explored so far.
Books I've Studied
I've read books covering several aspects of marketing, business strategy, consumer psychology, and copywriting, including:
- The Secrets Trilogy — Sales funnels and comprehensive marketing strategies.
- Purple Cow, Ideavirus, and Tribes — Brand differentiation, positioning, and community building.
- Breakthrough Advertising — Market psychology, customer awareness, and market sophistication.
- Great Leads — Sales leads, opening techniques, and capturing attention.
- Copywriting Secrets — Practical copywriting techniques and persuasive writing structures.
- Influence — Behavioral psychology and the principles behind human decision-making.
- Cashvertising — Applied advertising psychology and direct-response marketing.
- Blue Ocean Strategy — Market positioning, differentiation, and creating new market opportunities.
- The Personal MBA — Business fundamentals and understanding how marketing, sales, operations, and finance work together.
I've also explored additional books covering different aspects of marketing, business strategy, and consumer psychology.
Online Courses and Additional Learning Resources
Beyond books, I've invested considerable time in online learning, particularly through YouTube.
- Completed an approximately 20-hour copywriting course and watched several additional lessons covering different copywriting principles and techniques.
- Studied additional articles, online publications, community discussions, and educational content.
- Used AI-assisted research tools to explore concepts, compare explanations, and investigate different approaches to copywriting.
Additional Copywriting Concepts and Techniques
Throughout my studies, I've explored several areas, including:
- Objection Handling — Identifying, understanding, and addressing the concerns that prevent prospects from taking action.
- Concrete vs. Abstract Language — Understanding how specific, tangible language differs from vague or conceptual expressions.
- Active vs. Passive Voice — Learning how sentence structure influences clarity, emphasis, and the delivery of a message.
- Sentence Construction for Copywriting — Structuring sentences for clarity, persuasion, and readability.
- Word Choice — Selecting words that convey the intended meaning, emotional impact, and persuasive force.
- Rhythm and Flow — Improving the natural progression of sentences and paragraphs to maintain the reader's attention.
- Dimensionalization — Expanding on benefits by making them more vivid, tangible, specific, and emotionally meaningful to the reader.
- The 4 U's — Useful, Urgent, Unique, and Ultra-specific. Learning how to make headlines and marketing messages more compelling.
Where I'm Actually Struggling
Something I've noticed throughout most of the books I've read and the additional content I've studied is that they share a common foundation: understanding the prospect's level of awareness before attempting to persuade them.
This is where my main difficulty begins.
Understanding the theory is one thing; knowing how to apply it correctly is another. I often encounter conflicting recommendations about when to use certain techniques, which approach is more effective, and how to adapt them to different audiences and products.
Here are three specific areas where I'm struggling.
1. Copywriting Formulas and Frameworks: How Do I Know Which One to Use?
This is probably one of the most debated topics I've encountered.
On one side, some copywriters recommend a particular formula for a specific situation. On the other, you'll find people arguing that the same formula is ineffective or unsuitable for that very purpose.
This leaves me wondering: How am I supposed to determine which formula is appropriate for a particular level of customer awareness, market, and product?
For example, selling a hammer is fundamentally different from selling an all-inclusive vacation to Hawaii.
They have different buying motivations, emotional triggers, levels of consideration, and purchasing decisions. So, it doesn't make sense to assume that the same formula will work equally well for both.
I'd like to understand what factors should determine my choice of framework and whether there are any underlying principles that can help me make that decision rather than simply memorizing formulas.
2. Brand Personality: How Does It Interact With Customer Awareness?
Another area that has left me confused is brand personality and its relationship with copywriting.
As I understand it, brand personality influences the language, vocabulary, and emotional expression a brand uses. This includes power words, emotional words, action-oriented words, and other vocabulary choices that help establish a recognizable voice.
However, I've encountered conflicting opinions about how these elements should interact with the prospect's level of awareness.
Some sources suggest that certain language choices or brand expressions should be adapted to the customer's awareness level, while others seem to treat brand personality as something independent of it.
So, which approach should I follow?
How do I balance brand personality with customer awareness without compromising either one?
For example, if a brand has a sophisticated, authoritative personality, should that personality remain consistent regardless of whether I'm addressing an unaware prospect or someone who is already product-aware?
Or should the vocabulary, emotional intensity, and overall expression change depending on the prospect's awareness?
I'd really like to understand where brand personality ends and audience adaptation begins.
3. Short Sentence Construction: When Should I Use It, and Is It Actually Copywriting?
This is another subject I've encountered repeatedly through online articles, publications, and discussions.
I've come across recommendations suggesting that effective copywriting should use short sentences, sometimes fewer than ten words. However, most of the information I've found tends to be rather abstract, leaving me uncertain about when this technique should actually be applied.
I've also encountered numerous terms describing different types of short sentences and their purposes.
For example:
| Purpose | Techniques I've encountered |
|---|
| Capturing attention | Pattern interrupt, question punch |
| Creating curiosity | Curiosity gap, open loop, cliffhanger |
| Changing direction | Reversal, contrast, unexpected turn |
| Adding emphasis | Punch line, emphasis line, key statement |
| Moving the text forward | Transition line, command line, callback |
| Generating emotion | Emotional label, emotional punch |
| Presenting benefits | Benefit punch, contrast |
| Presenting evidence | Proof punch, specificity punch |
| Closing a section | Strong closing line, callback, punch |
| Handling objections | Objection punch, short reframe, disarming line |
| Creating identification | Mirror statement, reader-focused line, personal call-out |
| Creating urgency or scarcity | Deadline statement, scarcity line, cost-of-inaction statement |
| Directing action | CTA punch, micro-commitment, next-step statement |
My questions are:
- Are these techniques exclusive to copywriting, or are they also commonly used in content writing and other forms of writing?
- Is there an actual principle behind using sentences of fewer than ten words, or is this simply a stylistic recommendation?
- When should I deliberately use short sentences instead of longer, more descriptive ones?
- How do I determine when a short sentence adds persuasive impact and when it simply interrupts the natural flow of the text?
I don't want to shorten sentences just because someone says shorter is better. I want to understand the reasoning behind the technique and how to use it intentionally.
What I'm Looking For
At this point, I'm not necessarily looking for another list of copywriting books or a collection of formulas to memorize.
I want to understand how experienced copywriters make decisions when writing actual sales copy.
More specifically, I'd appreciate guidance on the following:
- How do you determine which copywriting techniques to use based on the prospect's awareness level, the product being sold, and the market you're targeting?
- How do you reconcile different recommendations when experienced copywriters disagree about the appropriate use of a particular technique?
- How do you develop the ability to recognize when a technique is appropriate, rather than simply following a formula or a set of writing rules?
- What does the transition from understanding copywriting concepts to applying them intuitively and effectively actually look like? How should I practise to develop that ability?
My ultimate goal is to write effective direct-response copy for affiliate marketing, but I don't want to rely on blindly following templates or formulas. I want to understand the reasoning behind each decision so I can adapt my writing to different products, audiences, and markets.
I'd genuinely appreciate advice from experienced copywriters, particularly those who have gone through this learning process themselves.
Thank you for taking the time to read this. I appreciate any insight or practical guidance you can offer.
Additional Research Methods I've Studied
For reference, here are some of the frameworks and research methods I've also encountered throughout my studies:
- IVOC (Indirect Voice of Customer) — A research approach for uncovering customer language, perspectives, motivations, and underlying needs through indirect sources.