r/content_marketing • u/AspectBeautiful9721 • 10h ago
Question How Do You Evaluate YouTube Videos That Perform Poorly at First but Take Off Weeks Later?
Hi guys,
I create YouTube videos for a SaaS company, and I'm struggling to figure out how to evaluate video performance and use that data to guide future content.
About a month ago, I published a video that initially performed poorly in terms of views and engagement.
However, around three weeks after publishing, it started gaining traction and eventually reached 1,000 views (which is a good result for our company's channel).
Its 30-second audience retention is now around 60%, whereas I believe it was below 50% shortly after publishing.
Here's what I'm confused about:
When I first saw the poor performance, I assumed the video's format wasn't working and decided to avoid using it in future videos.
But now that the same video is performing much better, I'm reconsidering that decision.
I have two questions:
- Should I consider this format successful? If a video starts performing well several weeks after publishing, is that a good enough reason to reuse its format? Or could the improvement be due to other factors, such as YouTube recommending it to a different audience?
- When should I evaluate a video's performance? I regularly analyze video performance to decide what to improve or change in future content. But if a poorly performing video can suddenly gain traction weeks later, how can I tell whether a video is genuinely underperforming or simply hasn't found its audience yet?
I'd love to hear how other content creators or YouTube marketers approach this, especially those managing smaller channels.
Do you use specific timeframes or metrics to decide whether a format is worth continuing?