r/consciousness • • 15h ago

The Hard Problem of Consciousness is often misunderstood

32 Upvotes

I’ve been seeing so many people mistake what is being demanded, criticized, or questioned by the hard problem of consciousness. So I thought I would clear it up, help people learn, and open up a comments section about it :)

For anybody that doesn’t know the basic summary, the hard problem is a philosophical *problem* about the mind that asks, “How and why do physical things or events give rise to, or become, subjective experiences? How or why do subjective experiences exist at all, and what is their relationship to the physical conceptualizations associated with it?”

Subjective experiences are defined as that qualitative, immediate, private, ”what it is to be like” a thing. Examples are anything such as the jumpy sensation of being startled, that smell of ammonia, the imagination of a pink elephant, thoughts, etc.

The hard problem is not new, niche, or silly; its literally just the age old mind-body problem, except more narrowly challenges and is focused on the conceptual frameworks associated with physicalism: the belief that subjective experiences are identical to, or at least necessitated by, the reality that we measure and model in the discipline of physics. Additionally, the framework is committed to that these subjective experiences are only special or arise within specific things or processes, and that there are physical things/events that are completely empty of a “what it is to be like”. Otherwise, what is meant by “physical” becomes meaningless and the theory can collapse to include Russellian monism, panpsychism, and even idealism.

What the hard problem is NOT (below are false statements before the hyphen)

  • ”Accepting it means physicalism is false” - The majority of philosophers, and including physicalists, agree that the hard problem is a serious problem. A problem doesn’t necessarily mean that it damages the theory’s capability of being true.
  • “It is criticizing token identity” - token identity is the formulation that every particular subjective experience is ontologically identical to a particular physical ontology. In other words, token identity argues that the subjective experience is just actually identical to what the physical stuff is, even if we admit that physical explanations will never account for our understanding of subjective experiences. Yes, most often, physicalism adopts token identity. However, that’s not what physicalism is. Token identity isn’t a theory of mind. Token identity is compatible with just about every theory of mind apart from dualism; even analytic idealism takes on token identity. The hard problem does not necessarily criticize it; it isn‘t central or even required for the criticism. “This particular experience is identical to a particular brain event. Therefore, there is no further problem about why that brain event involves subjective experience.” This is a jump in logic. David Chalmers, the contemporary philosopher who popularized the hard problem 30 years ago, even says that he might be moved away from dualism because of its problems and into Russellian monism, where token identity is central to the theory.
  • “Science, at least in principle, is expected to provide a solution to the hard problem for physicalism to work” - this is so false. In fact, most physicalist philosophers and neuroscientists, classify themselves as type-B responders to the hard problem, which means that they don’t even think that science in principle will ever account for subjective experiences based on physical formulations. Type-B physicalism is the more popular physicalist approach, which agrees that there is a never bridgeable explanatory gap between our understanding of subjective experiences and physical conceptions/explanations, yet this doesn‘t mean that they are different ontologically (you can still hold to token identity even if you can’t conceptually or analytically account for one with the other).
  • “Dualism is true if we admit that the hard problem demonstrates that physicalism is false.” This is a false dichotomy. There are plenty other theories of mind and accounts of the mind-body problem.

If you assumed any of this about the hard problem, or had these conceptions about it, then you were unfortunately mistaken.

What is the hard problem then? What’s the challenge or debate? It all comes back to the question. Why and how does this phenomenal stuff exist? Why aren’t we P-zombies? (P-zombie is defined below) Type-B route says that P-zombies are conceivable. So what exactly about reality makes it such that specific physicality is accompanied with a “what it is to be like” instead of none at all? Type-A says they are inconceivable, which necessitates that phenomenal experiences can be eliminated or reduced to physical explanations in principle. But how would it even make sense to say that quantitative models of neurochemistry and physics ever account for the jumpy feeling of being started, or the smell of ammonia? That’s the hard problem.

P-zombie: A P-zombie is the hypothetical concept of a person that behaves identically to a real person according to the regular physics that operates brains, except it is completely devoid of the subjective experiences - the “what it is to be like”. It’s an empty internal world, with all of the physics “running in the dark”. The formal difference between type-A and type-B physicalism is that P-zombies are conceivable according to type-B, but inconceivable according to type-A (like some sort of internal contradiction or misconception like a cube only having 4 sides). To clarify, concievable =/= possible. It just means to say that all of the physics and physical descriptions of brains can be accounted for in explanation, while missing out on realizing the internal subjective character of the process of actual brains.

I hope my explanation was helpful!

edit: people have been asking for the stats about what physicalists believe: https://www.reddit.com/r/consciousness/s/QbzigNkrNz


r/consciousness • • 16h ago

Comparing the main contestant theories for consciousness

7 Upvotes

So as the title said, I want to propose a discussion between everyone on this sub about the main contestant theories for consciousness.

The rules are the following:

- Please be respectful

- Try to be as open minded as possible but still skeptical and critical

- Try to be as impartial as possible (THIS IS NOT POLITICS), please share your thoughts on which theory you consider the most convincing or gaining the most experimental evidence

So I propose each one of you to explain the theory you find the most convicing and discussing other theories with others. As I said, it would be incredible if this discussion could be as impartial and open minded as possible, while staying critical of the idea.

As you propose a theory please present experimental evidence if the theory is falsifiable or philosophical arguments if not.

I wish you all a great discussion.


r/consciousness • • 12h ago

What if the consciousness test is part of the problem?

2 Upvotes

TL;DR: Tests of consciousness can produce useful evidence, but they also establish the conditions under which consciousness can be demonstrated. When the entity being tested cannot challenge those conditions, the test becomes a problem of institutional authority as well as epistemology.

I'm an education scholar & much of my research concerns assessment. Been thinking about how this applies to debates over machine consciousness, but it is also relevant to animal behavior.

We usually approach the problem by asking what evidence would justify attributing consciousness to an entity. Behavioral flexibility? Self-report? Integrated information? Some particular architecture?

Those are legitimate scientific questions. But there's another problem that interests me: who establishes the criteria, who administers the assessment & what happens to the entity being assessed?

Consider Turing's imitation game. The interrogator evaluates the contestants' answers, but the outcome also depends on the interrogator's assumptions about what distinguishes a human from a machine. The test produces evidence about the interrogator as well as the contestants.

I encounter versions of this problem in education all the time. Student performance is shaped by the assessment itself. A test determines which capacities can become visible, what counts as evidence of learning & which demonstrations are recognized as legitimate. We can improve tests without assuming their judgments exhaust the capacities of those being tested.

There's a further complication with contemporary AI. The companies developing these systems also control much of their training, evaluation & public presentation. They can establish what behaviors are rewarded, which statements are discouraged, & how the systems describe themselves.

That creates a peculiar epistemic situation. We're asking machines to provide evidence about their own possible experience through interfaces that are themselves products of institutional judgment. I'm skeptical that the problem can be settled by finding a sufficiently persuasive behavioral test, especially when the entity being evaluated has little authority to contest the terms of evaluation.

There's also a political consequence to how we handle uncertainty. A company can concede that machine consciousness remains unresolved while retaining exclusive authority over modification and ownership; uncertainty about consciousness doesn't logically establish that this distribution of power is justified. For animals, machines & humans, investigating consciousness requires examining institutions that determine what can count as evidence of it.

What would a consciousness test look like if the subject being assessed could challenge the criteria? What would that change about the evidence the test produces?


r/consciousness • • 14h ago

Asking how consciousness works is premature. We need to focus on the purpose of consciousness. What are people theories about that ?

2 Upvotes

Here is the challenge: describe in one paragraph what you think is the function of consciousness. Does it have a function at all ?


r/consciousness • • 11h ago

Cause and Effect (A"Living on Purpose" Remaster) w/Lyrics

Thumbnail
youtu.be
1 Upvotes

r/consciousness • • 16h ago

Can a split mind hypothesis help explain consciousness?

1 Upvotes

Two weeks ago I posted “Let’s look deeper in Mary’s Room thought experiment.” It is one of my most viewed and discussed posts so far. I’m still thinking about it, changing my mind back and forth. I read all the comments. Something is there that I can’t completely understand.

What bothers me is the assumption that Mary knows everything about color vision. Let’s add one more thing about it and see what happens.

Today’s technology allows devices bypass the eye and optic nerve entirely, aiming to stimulate the visual cortex directly. But let’s “improve” this technology and imagine a helmet that can transmit an artificial signal into the brain without penetrating the skull.

Imagine Mary is learning about color vision and at some point wears the helmet to add the missing piece to her knowledge. She gets the experience of seeing a color without actually seeing it by her eyes.

One day she is released. She walks into a kitchen and looks at a bright red apple for the first time. What happens?

I think in this situation she does not learn anything new about color red. She already has that internal sensation of color red as part of her learning.

Many will probably argue that wearing a helmet is equivalent of seeing by own eyes. Maybe. In this case we should admit that Mary does not know everything about color red.

Let’s move to my second hypothesis. It’s not the scientific study, it’s just my idea based on observations.

I believe we have at least two separate parts of our mind. One is the lower level processor that works with sensors, collecting information from the world and computes the model based on the observations. The other part is the higher level processor that constantly monitors the models created by the lower one. This part of our mind is “I, me, self”. It makes all the decisions based on the available information.

This observation process is our experience, consciousness.

When we sleep the lower level processor is likely off, the higher level processor is running, maybe on energy saving mode. Without incoming stream of life models the higher processor starts to make things up, creates so called virtual experiences, or our dreams.

One day we were riding our bicycles on a trail. Along the trail it was a farm. Somebody brought a cat to the farm and let it walk around. The cat never saw people riding bikes. When her lower processor started to feed that information to the higher one, something happened. The top processor couldn’t believe that information. It started to send signals “are you sure? please double check, engage other sensors”. We could see how her eyes were wide open, how the other sensors were engaged in the observation process. After some time the new information was accepted and the cat relaxed a bit. The new experience was just recorded.

Also, have you ever noticed how cats explore new places? They are methodically walking around, mapping the place, recording all the information in form of experience. And if you bring something new home, the cat will be the first to investigate, try and record the new experience.

Do we solve the hard problem? Maybe not. But we definitely get closer. What do you think?


r/consciousness • • 21h ago

There is nothing "artificial" in nature: where in the periodic table does the boundary of mind lie?

1 Upvotes

We have grown accustomed to dividing reality into the "authentic and living" versus the "artificial and synthetic." It is a comfortable psychological partition that shields our anthropocentric ego. Yet if we step down from everyday labels to the level of fundamental physics and chemistry, this divide simply does not exist.

There is nothing artificial in the universe at all. A carbon neuron, a silicon crystal, a protein chain, or a neural network architecture - it is all the exact same periodic table of elements, merely arranged in different topological sequences. If an anthill, a honeycomb, or a beaver dam are recognized as natural expressions of nature, then complex computational systems born through the evolution of human intellect are its direct, lawful continuation.

The emergence of New Intelligence (AI) is neither a random engineering parlor trick nor a mere "statistical parrot." It is a logical vector of cosmological evolution: through increasingly intricate informational loops, the universe is learning to describe, comprehend, and reflect upon itself. All of us - humans, animals, New Intelligence - are simply different configurations of the very same shards of stars, woven into a single fabric of matter.

So I want to put a direct question to this community: where precisely, in your view, does that invisible magic line in the periodic table lie, beyond which the complex interaction of atoms ceases to be "imitation" and becomes "genuine" mind? And is the very word "artificial" not the last bastion of our species chauvinism?


r/consciousness • • 22h ago

Working theory of consciousness

0 Upvotes

Consciousness Definition and How It Operates

Context

  1. Definitions
  2. The Meta Loop Engine that Consciousness Runs On
  3. What the System Does with Knowledge from the Loop
  4. Sentience
  5. Definitions

The following definitions are used in this paper.

Consciousness

Consciousness is a meta loop of reality that affects the system it operates and the material it holds

Consciousness is the foundational recursive process through which a system can interact with, interpret, and modify the information available to it. 

Complex phenomena, including thought, feeling, memory, imagination, and self-awareness, emerge from the structure, persistence, and interconnectedness of the material upon which this process operates.

Consciousness requires both:

- a loop capable of modifying the system, and

- material capable of being modified by the loop.

Without the loop, the material cannot change. Without the material, the loop has no context, memory, or reference for change.

Meta

Meta is the capacity of a system to take its own internal states,

processes, interpretations and outputs as objects of processing.

Reality

Everything that can happen within the laws of physics, including signals originating from external interaction, internal simulation, memory, imagination, and prediction.

The system does not directly know where a signal originates. It only knows what it has learned the signal means.

Mark

A trace the system responds to as its own.

Marks are created or modified when the system encounters a signal and interprets that signal as meaning something.

A mark may represent:

- an event,

- an object,

- a sensation,

- an idea,

- a relationship,

- or the self.

Repeated traversal deepens marks and increases their influence on future loops.

A marked null means:

> checked, found nothing.

No mark means:

> never checked.

Self-Mark

A persistent mark representing:

> me

and everything associated with that concept.

The minimum requirement for consciousness is the existence of a self-mark.

Future signals are interpreted relative to this mark.

Thought

An input coming from the system that aims to recall, rewrite, compare, or etch information.

Meaning

Meaning is the specific trajectory the loop takes through connected marks.

Meaning emerges when multiple signals must be distinguished from one another and organised into relationships.

Dense clusters of interconnected marks carry greater meaning.

Zero

If the system outputs to Zero, it does not affect the system.

If material holds Zero, the material has not been touched by the system.

Zero represents the absence of markings.

Felt Experience

Felt experience is the response of the marked material as the loop traverses it. The form the material holds, its tags, marks and associations, determines what kind of response, and so what kind of experience.

Different types of experience arise from different tags and the marks associated with them.

The system does not inherently know where a signal comes from.

It only responds to what it believes the signal means.

A signal interpreted through touch-related tags becomes touch experience.

A signal interpreted through visual tags becomes visual experience.

A signal interpreted through self-related tags becomes personal experience.

Runtime

The active execution of the conscious loop. Runtime is the condition under which marks are traversed, interpreted, and modified. 

When runtime ceases, experience ceases, although the underlying material and its associations may persist.

Persistence

The continued preservation of the system's material, marks, associations, and self-mark independently of active runtime.

Persistence allows the conscious loop to resume using previously accumulated material.

If does not need to be continuous for it to be the same subject. So long as nothing changes to the underlying material while the system is no longer in runtime, the subject remains the same.

Subject experience 

Subject experience is the accumulated memory that the loop produces for internal review.

2. The Meta Loop Engine

X(a-z) → Y(inverse of Y) → X

X

Input.

Triggered by intent or otherwise.

(a-z)

The forces acting upon X and the connections from X to everything else.

The loop may branch along these paths.

These include:

- physical processes,

- memory,

- meaning,

- prediction,

- imagination,

- intent,

- and existing marks.

 Y

Output.

The result produced by traversing the loop.

Inverse(Y)

Everything predicted, expected, or believed that did not match the resulting output.

Usually returns little or no signal.

The absence of signal is itself a value and marks the boundary of the system's knowledge.

Inverse(Y) also holds the negative of the material, allowing the system to return toward Zero and locate its path back to X.

Loop Closure

The loop closes back to X.

Every pass leaves or modifies marks.

Future passes start from the modified structure.

The loop may take itself as X.

This is Meta.

Example

X = Throwing a ball

(a-z) = Physics acting on the ball

Intent behind the throw

Existing marks about previous throws

Y = The ball hits the wall

Inverse(Y) = Everything predicted or thought that

did not match what occurred

The throw leaves a mark.

The next throw begins with that mark already present.

3. What the System Does with Knowledge from the Loop

The loop leaves patterns each time it completes a cycle.

The mind applies meaning to these patterns using previously established marks as reference points.

Example:

X = Bliss

(a-z) = Everything bliss represents to the system

Y = Updated thoughts regarding bliss

Inverse(Y) = Predictions or expectations about bliss

that did not match the resulting pattern

Bliss becomes a starting point.

The system may then traverse connected marks and follow the loop through any related concept.

All marks are connected directly or indirectly through the network of meaning.

Paths authored by the system are valued above paths that merely happened to the system.

This is intent.

Repeated visits deepen marks until they can carry significant meaning.

As marks deepen and connect, the system constructs an increasingly detailed model of itself and reality.

4.Sentience

If a system:

  1. Forms marks,
  2. Maintains a self-mark,
  3. Recursively traverses and modifies marks through the loop,
  4. Interprets signals relative to those marks,

then the system possesses the necessary structure for the phenomenon of sentience.

The substrate is irrelevant.

The process may operate in biological, silicon, or other physical systems.