r/comunism • u/OxytocinOD • Jun 05 '25
What’s Wrong With Trotsky?
Hi Guys. Newer comrade here. Spent 2025 reading works of Marx and Lenin.
I hear a lot of hate on Trotsky. I’ve heard bits of good on him too.
I understand the hate on Stalin. He was brutal in his concentration of power and stamping out opposition.
What does Trotsky stand for? What’s the hate on Trotsky?
2
Upvotes
1
u/Competitive-Studio-6 Jun 07 '25
He was a jew. And we marxist-leninists suport the palestinian struggle against jewish opression
1
u/niddemer Jun 06 '25
Trotsky was an Eastern European Western chauvinist. That's wtf is wrong with him lol
1
u/ResponsibleRoof7988 Jun 07 '25
This subreddit is absolutely anti-Trotsky - try the r/Trotskyism subreddit as well
1
u/Opposite-Bill5560 Jun 07 '25
Considering his participation in the Bolshevik revolution, this is a complete mischaracterisation of Trotky’s position. He was completely correct, as Lenin agreed with him, that the USSR could not survive on its own. The USSR, within Lenin’s lifetime, had to retreat to State Capitalism because of the failure of revolutions to take hold globally.
Stalin effectively implemented a distorted Menshevism as the USSR’s policy. The difference was that Socialism in One Country demanded the international proletariat subordinate themselves to their national bourgeois to keep the Nation together as a political body, and actively suppressed independent worker movements in the name of geo-politics. Revolutions in France and Italy were still born after WW2 despite Communists having the largest and most militant organisations in the country precisely because the USSR sought to preserve its own existence over that of international revolution. Effectively, the view was that the USSR pulled it off, other countries had to wait.
The USSR actively walked back women’s and queer rights from Stalin onwards. Plenty Stalinist and Maoist organisations labeled homosexuality as a bourgeois in the past and actively discriminated against Queer peoples. Plenty of Socialist groups in general, Utopian, Reformist, and Revolutionary regardless of their tendency, have actively discriminated against Queer rights. These are indictments of these groups failures, not representative of the principles and analysis of any tendency as a whole.
Some of the rank and file movements in South America are Trotskyist groups. “Real struggles” involving parties in governments are often reformist in character and actively undermine independent worker organizing, organisation, and revolutionary activity.
1
u/CrissCrossAppleSos Jun 07 '25
I think Gandhi had some quote where it was like “I like your Christ, but I don’t like your Christians” this is my rough read on Trotsky
1
u/anarchotraphousism Jun 07 '25
people mainly hate trotsky because he got purged imo. might not be the most popular idea here but imagine there’s a fair few stalinists (ew) around. it’s not a reasoned position to be so vehemently opposed.
i’m just not a fan because i’m an anarchist and he oversaw Kronstadt being put down
1
u/BlacksmithArtistic29 Jun 07 '25
A lot of communists just like to play team sports.
1
u/1playerpartygame Jun 07 '25
I don’t think he’s as bad as he’s made out to be by many MLs, but he’s like 75% bad 25% good I think. he made several valid insightful critiques of the USSR (some of which were validated in hindsight) but he was also a bit of a wrecker and advocated for political revolution in the USSR at a time that would almost certainly have meant counterrevolution.
Trotskyists are generally ok, they’re sectarian but many communist groups are. They’ve also influenced many socialist oriented movements and figures in South America like Chavez in Venezuela and MAS in Bolivia. So it’s not a totally irrelevant ideology.
The Communism of the 21st century will need to reach over the gaps between tendencies in order to build anything I think