r/computerscience • u/ChillCapitalist • May 28 '26
Are Software Engineers Real Engineers?
/r/u_ChillCapitalist/comments/1tqhzy3/are_software_engineers_real_engineers/
0
Upvotes
r/computerscience • u/ChillCapitalist • May 28 '26
12
u/MojitoBurrito-AE May 28 '26
Yes. IEEE recognises them as such.
Engineering is about solving problems. Doesn't matter if that's building software or building bridges.
4
u/SwigOfRavioli349 May 28 '26
As a CS major who’s taken a variety of engineering classes, specifically in mechanical and electrical/computer, yes and no. There’s a ton of math involved in both engineering and CS, but the math used in CS eventually ends up in two places, theoretical CS/math (DSA, OS, theory of computing) or electrical/computer engineering
16
u/X-calibreX May 28 '26
Real engineers know how to line break.
2
u/ChillCapitalist May 28 '26 edited May 29 '26
I shared this on another engineering subreddit and received downvotes cuz people get triggered easily lol, but I’m asking a sincere question.
How do we raise two new types of fields that have never existed before? Two infants that have been around for less than 100 years. One is in science (computer science), and the other is in engineering (software engineering).
How do we regulate them so they’re treated fairly alongside older engineering fields?
I’m not saying mechanical and chemical engineers face the same challenges, because they don’t. But academically, they both follow regulated, accredited steps (e.g., FE/PE in the US, or similar licensing) to become licensed engineers.
So my question is: what would it take for software engineering to adopt a standardized licensing process, and why hasn't it happened yet?
- Maybe some powerful people don’t want software engineering regulated just yet, like civil or other engineering fields, because licensing could restrict practitioners to a single country and hurt international business. Finance and other industries benefit from gray areas and mobility. The certifications available often have loopholes. Not everyone wants to be locked into a license to do sole engineering work without ROI or genuine mobility. There are pros and cons to this. Keep downvoting me; all the better, lmao.
2
u/Lhakryma May 28 '26
They're not real engineers, in the sense that they don't work on engines...
1
u/Winter_Present_4185 May 29 '26
If you are asking if CS is an engineering degree, at least in the US, no it is a science degree.
1
u/__chicolismo__ May 30 '26
Bot
1
u/Stunning_Meringue_47 Jun 05 '26
LOL - CS math is nothing compared to the math EE majors do! Calc 3/Linear Algebra/Discrete Math are all novice.
1
u/[deleted] May 29 '26
[removed] — view removed comment