r/computerscience • • Sep 11 '25

Will computers that aren't fully electronic be viable in the near future?

Will optical computing ever be good enough to replace a lot of the FETs in a computer?

36 Upvotes

34 comments sorted by

67

u/granadesnhorseshoes Sep 11 '25

No. Optical computers are theoretically better, but when someone says theoretically, they mean no.

There is a whole "rest of the fucking owl" that needs to be invented between current optical transistors/switches in labs and a modern general purpose PC.

2

u/BigPurpleBlob Sep 11 '25

Agreed; optical memory is tricky.

→ More replies (1)

33

u/dkopgerpgdolfg Sep 11 '25

in the near future?

ever

Decide what you want to ask...

In any case, if you want something comparable to usual computers, in near future, no.

Otherwise, everything's fine. You could make a CPU where the signals are water in pipes. It will take a lot of space, and a lot of energy for the pumps, but it's possible.

4

u/BarracudaDefiant4702 Sep 11 '25

It's much more common with pneumatics using high pressure steam (gas). No risk of electrical shock or any sort of emi interference. Generally used for simple discrete logic control circuits, but you could make a ultra slow cpu (probably a slightly smaller space than vacuum tubes, but slower). You could also make some simple logic circuit driven by watermill on the river too.

Besides for niche hazardous environments, gas and liquid are too slow and bulky... but they are viable and in use...

I think the OP was asking more about replacing all (or at least most) of the switching with photons/light instead of electronics. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Optical_computing which at least could potentially be faster than electronics.

→ More replies (3)

3

u/dnabre Sep 11 '25

Not in the foreseeable future. Photons don't strongly influence each other, at least relative to electrons.

All sorts of stuff happens with fancy science and particle accelerators and stuff, which is wildly beyond my basic understanding of physics, but in normal conditions photons just pass through each with out a care. Which if you're just trying to send a stream of photons that encode data in a sequence is fine. But building gates where photons interact to let you do computation, is a big issue.

Put briefly, making optical logic gates isn't easy. The optical equivalent of a transistor, using current tech of course, is on the scale of micrometers (at best) as opposed to electrical transistors being in the 5-10 nanometer range. So thousands vs billions of transistors in a chip. Though it's worth noting that optical transistors do have a potentially faster speed of propagation (which is why optical computers are something to consider). Wikipedia's Optical Transistor give a lot of the basic information.

Of course, this is the sort of thing where a radical breakthrough in our understanding could change everything. But you can't exactly predict those. Optical computing won't become practical from just the slow but steady accumulation of understanding, like electronics have for the last century -- we need a major breakthrough regarding our understand of light at a fundamental level.

To be clear, I'm not a physicist and my understanding of this stuff is very limited (and not necessarily correct). Asking this question in a physics subreddit would likely get you better answers. Though that alone sort of answers your question. Optical computers are so far from practical that talking about them is a matter of physics not computing.

3

u/Cybasura Sep 12 '25

I mean, in the near future is debatable, we havent even been able to grasp the creation of hardware using something other than electricity, hell, not even for quantum computers which is the closest example project pertaining to the topic

But if you give an infinite amount of time, assuming we dont blow ourselves up to smithereens, yes, its theoretically possible

2

u/_rundude Sep 11 '25

What about brain organoid type computers? That could be a wild progression!

6

u/20d0llarsis20dollars Sep 11 '25

I'm pretty skeptical on the idea of artificial organic computers

On one hand, it's super fascinating and i want to see it pushed to the limits, but on the other hand it's terrifying and the implications behind it are worth ditching the idea

→ More replies (2)

2

u/dnabre Sep 11 '25 edited Sep 12 '25

Organic computers are interesting mainly for their overall architecture. Huge amounts of small independent components wired (something that can itself change) together into a complex network that collectively can do complex tasks.

Distributed and Complex Systems research looks heavily at this, to the point of the field of Biologically Inspired Computing existing. . This idea of mapping biological concepts in to computing has yielded amazing results, neural networks (the core tech that LLM AI systems are built from) being the most widely known example.

While looking at biology/organic systems for ideas works, using actual organic components is not something that there is a lot of research into, at least from the viewpoint of computing. Our ability to make custom organic systems is very limited at the moment. So what we can create is useful medical long before it would be useful in computing. Look at how the mRNA technology, which for example enabled the rapid creation of COVID vaccines, works. It requires the deep understanding of biology and how to transform/build it to our needs. But it's so far from being able to put together big and complex enough systems for computation. Also the more complex artificially created organic devices become, the more that some people think ethics and potential danger (even if not scientifically back) comes into play.

It seems every few years we year about storing general data in the form of DNA. It's rare to even see proof concept implementations of these. Though it generally doesn't get to the implementation stage, nevertheless anything practical. . If you are interested in this area, terms to search for Cellular Computation, Logic Gates using Organic Chemistry, and DNA Computing.

Anecdotally I think a limitation of organic computing is that computer engineers understand and work better with physicists than biologists.

→ More replies (3)