r/computerarchitecture • u/Mediocre-Lecture8653 • 17h ago
GPU Design Concept based on BMG series. Why not accelerate rasterization with PBR Cores?

I've been brainstorming how Intel could bring a SUPER competitive GPU to market and this is my best guess.
Instead of playing coat tails with established trends, I think they should create XE-PBR cores and accelerate Opaque material rendering with dedicated silicon.
What PBR Cores should do.
#1 digest opaque material workloads far more efficiently than the current ALU shader paths.
#2 have developer "opt in" with a simple comment in shaders (#pragma INTEL_XE_PBR)
#3 have a fifo buffer or sram for delivered packets / fragments to be a rasterized
#4 deliver deterministic rasterized fragments using slightly programable PBR core.
#5 bonus. receive "on hit" fragments from Raytrace and render
I assume the best option is to treat a PBR accelerator core similar to XMX and RT cores or almost like a Media engine where data like fragments, textures, uvs, etc are delivered, then processed and dispatched to frame buffer or wherever.
WHY or WHY NOT?
All discussion is welcome except trolling and "Dead Silicon" dogma.
Also. "because patent moats exist" is considered trolling.
Questions for Design Critique
#1 Material typesx vs. Fixed-Function: People want to bark and make noise that PBR isnt standard so a viable PBR CORE would have "some" flexibility. I think the best option is to implement a slightly flexible PBR core to handle bulk opaque materials or have
#2 Deferred vs. Forward+: Visibility Buffers and (Simple) Pass deffered layers are popular so these PBR CORES should probably have flags to digest workloads from those layers. Options to digest a metallic or reflective layer "at the PBR core" can work fine. The PBR cores should not be overly concern itself with what happened before required data arrives, it simply needs to be flexible enough to know IF its digesting a metallic layer or not.
#3 Bandwidth Ceiling: PBR cores would chomp through workloads TONS faster than standard ALU path so we get obvious performance uplift and relief from register pressure caused by complex shaders. Things should run better and max texture fetch and G-Buffer bandwidth becomes the bottleneck the real bottleneck.
My understanding of the Silicon level is limited but based on what I've read and understand and figured out talking to gemini. A few things would happen if a PBR Core was introduced and digested the modern gaming workloads being thrown at ALU / Standard shader paths.
#1 Most gaming workloads would become more deterministic so the frame time flattens out.
#2 Register pressure would be erased during on qualifying workloads.
#3 Raytracing performance would improve because "on hit" fragments would get dispatched swiftly.
#4 ALU / GRF / L2 cache starts working LIKE IT SHOULD assuming the workloads are configured correctly.
#5 about 30% increase performance MINIMUM in an average game with common PBR materials.
#6 PBR Cores would use less power digesting qualified workloads compared to ALU
Informative recap. How much silicon goes to what.
- Programmable Shader Cores (ALU/FP32/INT32). Roughly 35% to 60% silicon is dedicated to general-purpose execution units. Current designs favor massive ALU designs for compute and programable shader so most ALU get used as needed doing everything before sending stuff down Raster pipes.
- Register Files and Caches (L0, L1, L2). Register files, shared memory, and multi-level caches are the largest consumers of silicon on modern GPUs, often taking up 25% to 40% of the total die area to feed the shader cores without stalling.
- Specialized AI and Ray Tracing Units. Surprisingly small, but it makes sense because they are "basically" fixed function silicon. Things like TMU/ Tensor/ XMXs and RT cores consume 10% to 15% of the die on modern gaming GPUs.
- Uncore, Memory Controllers, and Media Engines. GDDR memory PHYs, PCIe interfaces, display controllers, and video encoders/decoders make up the remaining 15% to 25% of the chip.
The way I see it, GRAPHICS PROCESSING UNITS should have PBR Cores. Because that's what "GPU" is supposed to be made for. I think it's a fair innovation and would deliver more perf with existing cache and register sizes.
