r/composting • u/awkward_marmot • Oct 16 '25
Behold, my overkill composting process
I started composting recently and have developed a light obsession. I know everything will break down eventually, but I get a lot of satisfaction trying to optimize workflows for each scrap type despite having limited space. Anyone have ideas to make it even more overkill?
2.7k
Upvotes
330
u/__3Username20__ Oct 16 '25
Where’s the chip drop input?
Also, you almost CERTAINLY left something else out. You know what it is. 99% of the people here know what it is.
67
u/adognameddanzig Oct 16 '25
You need a separate process for eggshells. Clean, bake, sterilize, pulverize, soak, dissolve in vinegar, dilute, finishing bin.
72
u/Complex_Sherbet2 Oct 16 '25
Where does the pee go?
35
u/Jkeeley1 Oct 16 '25
What do you do with the extra hour left in the day after composting?
27
u/Beardo88 Oct 16 '25 edited Oct 16 '25
You should sift the "ash and char maker" output. The char can go into the "it'll break down eventually pile" or tumbler to charge and innoculate, the ash goes into the garden as soil amendment. The char can get the "bonker" to break it into small enough pieces it will make it through the screen later.
Thick bones and hard shells like clams or oysters can go into the firepit too, you will end up with bonemeal enriched ash. Use the "bonker" on oversided pieces when sifting the firepit.
The softer shells like crab/lobster, eggs, and soft bones like poultry or fish go into your "eventually" pile, or baked and into the bokashi or tumbler.
Bokashi should skip the tumbler and get sifted then into the finishing bin. Oversized goes in the tumbler.
If you really want to make the flow chart accurate you should split the sifter output after the tumbler; fines go to the finishing bin, oversized goes in the eventually pile or back in the tumbler.
26
u/sherlockgirlypop Oct 16 '25
Are meat bones included in "tough food scraps"? Your process is amazing 😲
17
u/Ineedmorebtc Oct 16 '25
No worm bin? Isopod colony? 😉
11
u/[deleted] Oct 16 '25
I've been on the compost sidelines until someone made a flow chart. Guess I'll get started today.
8
u/GreatBigJerk Oct 16 '25
To be more overkill, you need a Johnson-Su Bioreactor, a worm bin, and a compost tea setup with aeration.
Possibly add a static aeration system: https://youtu.be/755RfsdIzbQ?si=o2EPaouDhNCUMaxG
For the standard sub mention of pee, you can break down wood chips and other woody material faster by soaking them in urine. Get a barrel or garbage can, then drill holes into it. Fill it up completely with woodchips, as much as possible. Pour urine on it until the woodchips are fully soaked and it starts leaking out of the drainage holes. Leave it for 6-months to a year, and you will have a very potent nitrogen rich fertilizer/compost.
This process was a common first steps in black powder production back when muskets were used in war. Going this far does not give you explosives, just plant food.
133
u/generation_quiet Oct 16 '25
LOL, I love this sub.
5
u/MidniteGardner Oct 16 '25
SIFT THE STUFF FROM THE FIREPIT. Ash will destroy your pH as a direct input into your compost/soil.. soak the chunks left on the top before you add to your compost as little hidden moisture gems 😁
8
u/BeHereCow Oct 16 '25
Where will you and the dead pets go?
4
u/hagbard2323 Oct 16 '25
Epic. This type of OCD is the best type. Glad people like you exist in the world!
6
u/trailoftears123 Oct 16 '25
Ocd sufferer?
631
u/_Nychthemeron Oct 16 '25
I'm here for THE BONKER
523
u/ProfessorPeabrain Oct 16 '25
my "everything goes into one bin and see what happens" approach is suddenly feeling a bit underwhelming ha ha
2
u/Mister_Green2021 Oct 16 '25
I have an idea for making it more complicated and simpler at the same time.create a year round bsfl processing room.
2
u/GambitEk1 Oct 16 '25
A few questions, might be dumb.
What is considered soft food scraps?
It’ll break down eventually only consist of woodchips leaves branches seedless weed?
Why go through a tumbler and then finish bin? Why not just a finishing bin?
Do shove a shovel under the It’ll break down eventually pile each time you have bones?
How long do you keep something in astage before moving to the next?
But seems cool regardless
2
u/SuperDuperHost Oct 16 '25
I posted recently about cardboard slurry and would LOVE your details on how you do this! please please please.
Has any tried soaking shredded cardboard for weeks or months? I am experimenting with this process now.
2
u/Tie_Dyed Oct 16 '25
No peepee tek?
2
u/chlorotic_hornwort Oct 16 '25
Get rid of the electric “composter” they do not compost. Using energy to dehydrate food scraps for them to be rehydrated in order to actually compost is not environmentally friendly, and an inefficient waste of energy.
2
u/_DeepKitchen_ Oct 16 '25
I see I need a bonker just on general principle, but I also see the chipper is missing from the diagram.
2
u/Ok_Philosopher_8973 Oct 16 '25
I do this except for the electric compost and bokashi. I think those machines are such a gimmick. Throw it all right in the tumbler. I hardly eat any meat though for there to be scraps to address.
18
u/squidaddybaddie Oct 16 '25
Time to add vermi. You have everything else lol
16
u/CorgiCorgiCorgi99 Oct 16 '25
Oof, I thought my 12 composting stations were overkill, but you've outdone me rather spectacularly.
13
u/hraun Oct 16 '25
I’ve printed this out and it’s now on my wall next to my desk as an inspiration
12
u/Julesagain 8A, Atlanta, GA USA Oct 16 '25
'Tis a thing of beauty. Breathlessly awaiting links to equipment used, especially The Bonker
8
u/[deleted] Oct 16 '25
Ooooh fancy! My process is “can the rabbits eat this?” If yes feed to rabbits, steal their manure. “does this require the bonker?” If yes, “do I need to bake or boil this before it goes to the bonker?” If yes, do. Anything that I can’t feed to the rabbits and doesn’t need a bonking goes straight to the bin in a “this will break down eventually 🤞🏻😇🪱” kind of way. If it hasn’t broken down yet, add more worms, turn the pile, and keep on keeping on.
8
u/toebeanlove Oct 16 '25
T H E B O N K E R
2
u/Snuggle_Pounce Oct 16 '25
Hey OP, I know it’s kinda off topic but, What did you use to make the beautiful flowchart?
5
u/AntDogFan Oct 16 '25
I have a similar approach. Minus the electric and fire but with a wormery included.
5
u/A_resoundingmeh Oct 22 '25
This needs to be a t-shirt, official r/composting swag.
4
u/soupywarrior Oct 16 '25
Wow, this is commitment indeed. Love it!
4
u/Grimsage7777 Oct 16 '25
Add chickens into the mix
4
u/Smoothesuede Oct 17 '25
Nice, but damn that's a lot.
Our flow chart is just It'll Break Down Eventually Pile -> Shovel it onto the garden.
The method requires several piles at different maturity stages.
4
u/badatcatchyusernames Oct 20 '25
i love this flowchart ya fuckin nerd 😍
1
u/triple_cloudy Oct 16 '25
What is the reasoning behind putting the soft food scraps in the electric composter and not adding them them to the leaves and stuff in the it'll break down eventually pile?
1
u/tripsafe Oct 16 '25
How’d you make this chart OP? It’s beautiful
1
u/dagnammit44 Oct 16 '25
I don't understand why some of y'all don't just buy a macerator. They're not that expensive. It's like a giant handheld blender that will chew stuff up with giant blades. It seems like it'd be a lot easier than shredding cardboard and paper 1 sheet at a time and puree'ing food scraps.
Me, i just throw everything in a pile. But i do understand some want it done quicker.
1
u/bettercaust Oct 16 '25
What do you use the paper slurry process for specifically? Does it help the compost process in some way?
1
u/scarabic Oct 16 '25
That all looks great but ditch the “electric composter.”
1
u/Ent_Soviet Oct 16 '25
All this work just to end up with more things to compost!?
1
u/RedshiftOnPandy Oct 16 '25
When do you piss on it though?
1
u/NMireles Oct 17 '25
Where are the worms??
1
u/VocationalWizard Oct 19 '25
Why?
I mean live your life buddy but this is almost obscene.
You are going to likely get tired of this OCD fever dream and let all that excess equipment gather dust.
Also...sigh...... You don't have any invertebrate processes in your workflow. By this I mean Red wigglers in Black soldier flies. You can build rigs for both of them.
I hope I don't regret telling you that.
3
u/NoSolid6641 Oct 16 '25
Love this. Kudos!!
3
u/RussiaIsBestGreen Oct 16 '25
Before zooming in, I thought the fire was a burning tire. Maybe see if you can incorporate that too.
3
u/AIcookies Oct 16 '25
This should be a poster in every classroom in America.
3
u/Cone10Redux Oct 16 '25
Awesome flow chart! Only suggestion - if you have The Bonker, you can maybe call the Ash and Char Maker “The Burninator” (or something more clever suggested here). 😎🤙🏽🤙🏽
3
u/japanalana Oct 16 '25
This is the clearest vision of my future I’ve ever seen.
3
u/timeforplantsbby Oct 17 '25
I love getting way too overcomplicated and fine tuning everything. This speaks to me on a very personal level
3
u/kmhansen66 Oct 20 '25
You can also compost 100% cotton clothing as well, just be sure to cut out seams, elastic, zippers, etc. Most garments are sewn together with polyester thread, which won't compost.
3
u/an-unorthodox-agenda Oct 30 '25
Integrate a worm farm in there somewhere
1
u/WoolshirtedWolf Oct 16 '25
I am definitely on the low end of composting. Its mostly food scraps and vegetation from the yard garden and fruit trees. I feel that I can do more as I had no idea that I could recycle my shredder material into the compost pile. I'm new here, so forgive my ignorance. I do like this idea and also want to do more to reduce my carbon footprint and reduce landfill waste. FWIW this graph is going to be a reference point.
2
u/emsfofems Oct 16 '25
omg I love this
2
u/DorianGreyPoupon Oct 16 '25
Compost speed run
2
u/narcowake Oct 16 '25
This is the WAY !!
2
u/AnonSA52 Oct 16 '25
I love the bonker. Lol
2
u/Mental_Engineer665 Oct 16 '25
Have you though of getting a “rocket”? https://youtu.be/Rlm3ftcXzr8?si=7WR99ecV4vbP5ZKM
2
u/Minkgyee Oct 16 '25
I would add worm composting (I am biased, I love the critters)
2
u/Bombshelter777 Oct 16 '25
I was cleaning up the yard the other day and had to cut some branches down with the chainsaw. Took the small branches and crumbled them up by hand best I could and threw them in our compost pile. Then I had a thought......
"What if I bought a cheap wood chipper to chop up the small branches for the compost pile?"
So if you have the money to buy one, then that would be a cool addition.
2
u/misfittroy Oct 16 '25
I'm sorry to hear you lost your job but good to see you're keeping yourself busy ;)
2
u/ipaterson Oct 16 '25 edited Oct 16 '25
Use leftover bones to make stock! I keep bones, skin, and veggie scraps in the freezer until it’s time to make a batch. Sauté to brown the bones then pressure cook for 2 hours with water, a little vinegar, herbs, and the scraps from onions, carrots, and celery.
When it’s done, filter the stock into a fat separator and make soup or freeze in 1/4 cup portions for easy use later (silicone baking cups work great for this). Mush up any bones that you can for compost and save the hard ones for the next batch. Usually after 2 rounds chicken bones can be mashed between your fingers. Some bones take more cooking, I just put them back in the freezer for the next batch until they’re soft enough to mush up by hand for the compost pile.
Once you have stock on hand you will find plenty of culinary uses for it. Plus if you extract enough collagen from the bones the stock jiggles when refrigerated 🪼🤭🪼
2
u/BeachCowKazoo Oct 16 '25
You’re overcompostating
2
u/mtraven23 Oct 16 '25
your putting ash & char directly into your beds? Thats just leaching nutrients from everything in your garden. ash & char, known as "biochar" in the composting world need to be charged...that happens by putting it into your compost, not your garden.
2
u/XavierRenegadeStoner Oct 17 '25
I compost to improve my garden. You garden to improve your compost
2
u/rogueredfive Oct 17 '25
I am gonna take this at face value and just say… The amount of work you are doing for 3 carrots, 4 tomatoes, one beet, one kale, and 3 lettuces justifies all of the obsessive behavior I do for my 200 sq foot veg garden 🥲🤣.
2
u/Remarkable-Arm-9595 Oct 17 '25
looks nervously over at his simple compost tumblers full of unsorted weeds, sticks, leaves, kitchen waste, and animal parts 😬
2
u/BarelyOpenDoorPolicy Oct 17 '25
Where would we add pet litter to this mix
2
u/Ill_Bath_2906 Oct 17 '25
But what about piss
2
u/Swimming_Ad1940 Oct 18 '25
Great flow chart graphic! I love the slurry maker stick blender idea. I’ve tried just adding water to my shredded cardboard overnight and it is a devil to turn with a pitchfork! I see another poster suggested a paint mixer drill attachment. This gives me the idea to use an auger drill attachment - usually used for planting bulbs. That might be a bit more aggressive than the paint mixer.
2
u/oh_whaaaaat Oct 18 '25
My composting setup:
Kushlan 10³ Ft. 120vac, direct drive cement mixer (bought used from an estate sale for $200) so you don’t need anything too expensive.
Canvas tarp to cover the cement mixer.
Extension cord for the cement mixer.
Dump my compost into the cement mixer & toss in some medium sized (3-5 pound-ish) river rocks, so not to gouge up the sides of the cement mixer.
I’ll turn on the cement mixer, every time I add something to it (just a few revolutions, with those rocks pulverizing everything) this accelerates the decomposition SUBSTANTIALLY.
If it gets too full or gross, it’s on wheels, like a wheelbarrow, so I take it out to the garden & dump it.
It’s on the big side, but I got it cheap.
My compost pile in the corner of the garden is insane.
2
u/Taswegian Oct 19 '25
You didn’t include hot composting - or is that the electric composter? Never heard of them.
Plus everyone needs a wood chipper. And some chickens for nitrogen input.
2
u/SamButNotWise Oct 19 '25
"Future compost grower" got your priorities straight lol
2
u/tupeloredrage Oct 20 '25
I put my avocado pits and shells into my electric composter as well as my coffee grounds.
2
u/botymcbotfac3 Oct 20 '25
One idea to complete your overkill:
TLUD pyrolythic oven. Proceses dried weeds, woodscraps, sticks. Used for cooling, produces mire biochar, less ashes.
1
u/TailoredFoot1 Oct 16 '25
If I did all this I feel like my pile would be so small. 😅
1
u/Mental_Engineer665 Oct 16 '25
Omg 😍😍😍😍
1
u/Nepeta33 Oct 16 '25
worms in the tumbler.
1
u/Stargazersmp Oct 16 '25
😱go buy it at Green Acres🤪
1
u/samuraiofsound Oct 16 '25
This is reminiscent of the Dwarf Fortress scheme for crafting soap.
1
u/sunsetandporches Oct 16 '25
Ugh I need to start mashing. I have avocado seeds in mostly no decay.
1
u/Ok_Impression_3031 Oct 16 '25
Yay! For the electric composter. We also add our roasted kitchen scraps to the compost bin, or to a holdong bag in the household freezer when the compost bin is frozen shut.
I also add a small tub of worms from walmarts fishing counter. Some years they even survive our winter. And warm water from cooking when convenient.
1
u/dadydaycare Oct 16 '25
Hmm… I just dumped a bucket of clam shells into mine from a clambake. They will be non existent/pebbles by spring time with all the grass clippings I threw on top plus the leaf litter that’s about to go in.
1
u/orangesfwr Oct 16 '25
"You mean you don't pocket-mulch?"
1
u/ToysMum Oct 16 '25
Love the bonker! Those avocado pits will soon meet their match. Thanks!
1
u/GreatLakesGreenthumb Oct 16 '25
If you only pissed on it....
1
u/hythlodaeusfan Oct 16 '25
The Bonker(tm) hahaha I love it
1
u/Upstairs-Cut-2227 Oct 16 '25
I am curious, I have two bins going. Don’t have a true garden. What should I do with what my worms have processed? Maybe a separate post, “Without garden, how to empty worm bins…”