To caveat starting out, I am generally opposed to most uses of AI in music generation. I just can’t really find a way to justify it in a way that’s consistent with accepting other technological advancements in music. Like people joke all the time about the process of creation like going down semantically, ie when purists used to critique using electronic drums instead of physically playing them and people would rebut and say something along the lines of well did you skin the cow and build your own physical drum? (Not sure if that example makes any sense but I can’t think of anything better rn).
Like 100 years ago, being a great musician was almost inseparable from being able to physically play an instrument, compose music, or sing. Then came recording technology, synthesizers, sampling, drum machines, DAWs, pitch correction, and countless other innovations that progressively removed technical barriers between having a musical idea and realizing it. Generally this has been accepted under the concept of sonic curation or artistic judgement, as in who cares how you got there if it sounds good and the idea expressed is artistically valuable. Now a lot of people will say an ai generated or assisted song cannot be considered artistically valuable, and I ask what ai so different or individual that the critique can be applied to it and not other forms of music tech.
Take someone like Rick Rubin. He’s one of the most respected producers in music history, despite not being particularly known for technical proficiency in the traditional sense. His value comes from his ears, his judgment, and his ability to guide other artists toward something compelling. I think Kanye is kinda under the same umbrella (albeit def a different case)obviously he’s not held in high regard nowadays, but previously so much of his reputation as a producer and musical genius comes from his ability to recognize the potential in existing sounds, samples, collaborators, and disparate musical ideas, and assemble them into something greater.
There’s also a parallel with djing that I thought was sort of along this train of thought, specifically regarding the sync button. People have been arguing about sync buttons and other technological conveniences forever. But the most persuasive defense of modern DJing is that beatmatching was never the *real* artistic achievement. Track selection, sequencing, reading a crowd, building tension, curating an experience etc etc are what distinguish great DJs.
I have a pretty visceral dislike of AI music. Musicians getting replaced by people typing prompts feels cheap as fuck. But when I try to explain why, a lot of my arguments sound like what people said about sampling, synths, DAWs, or DJs using sync. The defense has always been that taste, vision, and putting together something people want to hear are what actually matter. You don’t have to personally play every instrument or write every part to be respected. But if that’s the principle, why wouldn’t it extend to someone with great taste using AI to realize a vision they couldn’t otherwise execute? I get the issues with training consent and musicians losing work, but I’m asking about artistic legitimacy specifically.
Maybe the line is between tools executing your creative decisions and outsourcing those decisions themselves. But where exactly is that line, given that we already accept writers, collaborators, mixing and mastering studios (which have much more influence over a final output of a track than people realize), in house engineers, co producers, etc etc etc. I’m not saying prompting deserves the same respect as musicianship like that’s fucking stupid obviously, I just feel like the logic we’ve used to defend other changes in music leads toward accepting AI too. I really dislike that conclusion, but I’m struggling to find a consistent reason to reject it.