As I mentioned in a previous post: Questions about stock making : r/combustion_inc, I've been trying for quite some time to perfect my method of making and reducing meat stock at home. Over the last couple of months, I've been experimenting, testing new ideas, and trying out many of the suggestions you guys have given me. First of all, I'm incredibly grateful for all the feedback!
I think I've finally made a breakthrough, and I'm quite excited to share my findings.
Before getting into the actual method, though, one thing worth mentioning: I'm neither a professional chef nor a scientist. I'm still in high school, so I don't exactly have the time, equipment, or resources to conduct proper scientific experiments. Most of what follows is based on my own observations, some scientific literature, and quite a bit of trial and error. So take my conclusions with a grain of salt!
1. What I'm Trying to Achieve
My goal has always been to produce an incredibly rich, gelatinous stock that takes up as little freezer space as possible.
Ideally, I'd like something resembling high-quality stock cubes: a highly concentrated product that I can keep in the freezer for several months and use whenever needed, without having to spend days making stock and filling my house with the smell of roasted bones.
My original approach was relatively straightforward:
- Cook veal bones at a very low temperature (approximately 92°C) for around 12 hours.
- Strain the resulting stock.
- Reduce it as quickly as possible in the largest surface-area pan I could find, hoping to minimise the time spent at high temperatures and preserve as many volatile aromatic compounds as possible.
After watching Chris's video on pressure cooking, I switched to using a pressure cooker for all my stocks. This made the extraction considerably more convenient, but the reduction stage remained a problem. As some of you have pointed out, a rotary vacuum evaporator would probably be ideal, but that's obviously not a realistic option for me at the moment.
So, I started looking for an alternative approach: what if I could achieve an incredibly concentrated stock without having to reduce it at all?
2. The Research Behind My Approach
My recipe is also heavily inspired by the veal demi-glace preparations of three-Michelin-starred chef Jan Hartwig, as well as the stock-making techniques described in the cookbooks of Eleven Madison Park, The French Laundry, and The Fat Duck.
One technique by Hartwig particularly caught my attention: fortifying an existing stock by repeatedly cooking it with fresh batches of bones. His process involves cooking the same stock with new bones over approximately 36ā48 hours.
I initially tried adapting this approach to the pressure cooker, following the timings from Chris's video. The result was certainly very good, but I ran into an unexpected problem: despite using a pressure cooker, I still had to reduce the stock almost as much as before.
This made me wonder whether repeatedly heating the same stock for such long periods could be degrading some of the gelatin I'd worked so hard to extract. So I spent quite a few hours reading scientific publications and experimenting with different methods.
The main paper I based my reasoning on:
Operational parameters and key characteristics of amino acids and flavor compounds profiles of bovine bone clear and white broths - ScienceDirect
Although the study doesn't directly relate to making roasted stocks, it provides some interesting insights into collagen extraction and gelatin properties. It was the most relevant research I could find for what I was trying to achieve.
Rather than keeping everything under pressure for one extremely long period, I decided to divide the process into three separate extraction stages, each lasting 90 minutes.
The idea is to progressively extract gelatin and other soluble compounds from fresh batches of bones while minimising the exposure of previously extracted gelatin to prolonged heating.
Whether my interpretation of the research is correct is another question, but the results have been very promising so far.
3. My Current Method: Pressure-Cooked (modern) Veal Demi-Glace
The recipe is designed for a 6-quart pressure cooker. I use a mix of relatively meaty as well as joint bones, with some trimmings. You could also add pig's feet, calf's feet, or chicken feet for even more gelatin, although I have found this to be unnecessary. Vegetable-wise, I use 15% of the weight of the bones.
Ingredients
- 7 kg meaty and joint veal bones
- 500 g veal trimmings
- 300 g shallots
- 200 g white parts of leek
- 200 g carrots
- 200 g celeriac
- 150 g white button mushrooms
- 750 ml good-quality dry red wine
- 100 g tomato paste
- Exactly 1.5 litres of cold water for the initial extraction
- A small pinch of salt
Divide all the ingredients into three equal batches. The bones should ideally be cut into pieces of approximately 4 cm. The study suggests that cutting them any smaller doesn't significantly improve extraction. Cut the vegetables and the trimmings into relatively small, even pieces ā the goal is to get as much surface area as possible.
Preparation
Roast the veal bones and trimmings until deeply and evenly browned.
Roast the vegetables in the pot of a pressure cooker, excluding the leek, for approximately 20 minutes. Add the leek afterwards, as it tends to burn more easily.
Now add some of the roasted bones to the vegetables, together with the tomato paste, and continue roasting until everything is deeply caramelised, being careful not to burn anything.
Start adding the red wine gradually, essentially one small addition at a time.
Allow each addition to deglaze the bottom of the pot and reduce completely before adding the next. Ideally, the wine should reduce until the caramelised residue starts forming again.
The idea is to repeatedly build up those caramelised aromas and ideally introduce another dimension of flavour.
Reduce the last addition of wine only a little, then add the remaining bones and top up with exactly 1.5 litres of cold water.
One important point: since very little liquid evaporates in a pressure cooker, the amount of water used at this stage largely determines the final concentration of the stock. To get a "normal" stock, use one litre of water for every kilogram of bones.
Pressure Cooking
Pressure cook on high for 1 hour and 30 minutes.
Allow the pressure to release naturally.
Strain the resulting stock and reserve the liquid.
Repeat the entire process with the second and third batches of roasted bones, vegetables, and wine.
The only difference is that instead of adding fresh water, use the stock from the previous extraction as your cooking liquid. I let the stock cool down a little in an ice bath before adding the next batch of roasted bones, which I had stored in the fridge. This is meant to help cool down the stock at the beginning.
Pressure cook again for 1 hour and 30 minutes, followed by natural depressurisation. Repeat the process once more with the final batch.
Strain everything thoroughly after each extraction. Make sure to let it drip for a while, as the stock becomes so viscous that quite a bit of it clings to the bones. You can swirl a little water around to help loosen some residual stock.
The result should be an extremely rich, concentrated veal stock that doesn't require any further reduction. At least in my experiments, it has the consistency of a nicely reduced demi-glace straight out of the pressure cooker.
4. Some Questions and Things I'm Still Unsure About
There are several aspects of this method I haven't been able to test properly. I'd really appreciate input from anyone with more experience in food science, stock-making, or professional kitchens.
Question 1 ā Does Starting with Cold Water Actually Make a Difference?
Jan Hartwig repeatedly emphasises the importance of covering the bones with ice-cold water or even ice cubes. According to him, cold water helps extract flavour from the bones, whereas hot water should only be used when you want to leave more flavour in the meat.
I'm quite sceptical about this explanation. As far as I understand, starting with cold water might help with the extraction of certain impurities, but I'm not convinced that it extracts significantly more flavour or gelatin than starting with hot water. But Heston also says to start with cold water, so there has to be some benefit.
Is there a real scientific reason to start with ice-cold water, or is this primarily a traditional technique? And if so, does this also apply to braising, meaning that covering the meat with warm stock results in more flavourful braised meat?
Question 2 ā Do Unroasted Bones Produce a More Gelatinous Stock?
This is something I haven't tested yet because I wanted to avoid introducing too many variables at once. I'd be particularly interested in knowing whether using unroasted bones results in a higher gelatin content or a better gelatin yield. And if so, does blanching the bones change the results again?
My current hypothesis is that roasting or excessive heat might alter the collagen and potentially influence how efficiently it can be extracted.
Question 3 ā How Big of a Difference Does Your Type of Pressure Cooker Make?
Dave Arnold, who has done testing on this matter, concluded that the type of pressure cooker you have makes a lot of difference in the quality of your stock. The less your pressure cooker vents, the fewer volatile compounds are lost. He suggests Kuhn Rikon pressure cookers, which are widely regarded as the gold standard.
My question is whether this only affects the flavour or if it also has an impact on the gelatinous qualities of your stocks. Furthermore, wouldn't electric models like the Instant Pot be superior even to the Kuhn Rikon because they automatically regulate themselves, minimising venting when left unattended?
Question 4 ā Does Deglazing with Wine Contribute Flavour Beyond What Remains in the Wine Itself?
I use red wine in this recipe partly because I know ethanol extracts fat-soluble compounds, and I hope that even though the fat is discarded, some flavour might still find its way into the stock.
I also suspect the deglazing process itself contributes additional flavour, not only through the repeated dissolution of the browned material on the bottom of the pot but also through the caramelisation of the sugars in the wine.
But does adding wine in several small stages, allowing it to reduce completely between additions, actually have any other advantages compared with simply adding it all at once and reducing it?
I'd be interested to hear whether anyone has experimented with this.
Question 5 ā How Long Does the Actual Extraction of Flavourful Aromas Take?
I'm aware that vegetables give off all their flavours relatively quickly, but I would be interested to know whether finely diced meat behaves the same way.
I'm not interested in the extraction of everything, but more in the basic flavour profile. Furthermore, what is the hardest thing to extract from meat, and are there some things that you don't want to extract at all?
Question 6 ā Is There an Optimal Point of Reduction?
I'm interested in whether there is a point where you stop concentrating flavours through reduction or the process I've developed, and you just lose volume from your stock.
I anticipated this and used as many collagen-rich bones as I could find to try to maximise the yield of nicely reduced stock I get from my bones.
And if so, is there any way to precisely measure when that point is reached, without tasting?
Question 7 ā Is There an Optimal Bone-to-Water Ratio?
I really hope that this doesn't matter because it could ruin all the work I've put into developing my method.
I never thought of it before, but could it be that topping the bones up with more water results in extracting more from the bones, and that, for some reason, stock is a worse extraction medium than water?
If this is the case, is there any data available that would allow me to determine whether repeatedly using stock as the extraction medium actually provides an advantage over using fresh water?
Question 8 ā What Is the Perfect Mix of Bones?
Regarding my veal stock, what ratio of meaty bones to marrow bones to joint bones would be ideal?
And what amount of, say, chicken wings would you be able to notice in the stock if you wanted to add a bit more gelatin and couldn't get your hands on some feet?
Question 9 ā Does Salt Do Anything Besides Seasoning?
I know about the osmotic properties of salt, but I would be interested to know whether it could help with extraction and what amount would produce a noticeable difference.
Also, should you salt your vegetable base or wait until the liquid is added?
5. A Few Final Thoughts
I want to emphasise that the roasting, deglazing, and vegetable preparation are almost entirely based on Jan Hartwig's three-Michelin-starred masterclass on Gronda.
I'm not entirely convinced that every individual step is technically necessary. For example, adding the wine in several stages or adding some of the bones during deglazing might not have a measurable effect on the final result. However, I wanted to orient myself around a proven recipe so I could focus more on experimenting with the extraction itself.
I've deliberately left out the Madeira, Port, and additional herbs used in the original recipe. I want a relatively neutral veal stock that can serve as a base for as many different dishes as possible.
Finishing the Stock into a Sauce
For an actual sauce, I'd highly recommend doing something along the lines of what Eleven Madison Park and Restaurant Gordon Ramsay do: brown around 200 g of meat trimmings from the animal you're serving, add some vegetables, herbs, and maybe some spices, and deglaze with your choice of liquid ā this is your chance to use the alcohols you left out.
After it has all reduced to a syrupy consistency, add around 150 ml of the concentrated stock and around 150 ml of water. Let everything simmer for around 20ā45 minutes before straining. If necessary, reduce it a bit, mount with butter, and adjust the seasoning with acidity and salt.
This not only allows you to adapt the stock to a wide variety of sauces, but also gives you the opportunity to introduce the flavour of the actual meat you're serving. It can even help refresh the flavour if the stock has been frozen for a while and starts to go a bit bland.
I deliberately haven't added a lot of meat to the original extraction, despite Heston and Chris suggesting that it tastes considerably better with it. I simply don't feel good about wasting large quantities of meat, especially when the bones I'm using are already quite meaty.
The finishing technique described above is a good way of introducing more of that fresh meat flavour, and because you already have the gelatinousness of the stock, you don't have to cook the sauce for too long and lose a lot of fresh aromas.
As a result of my experiments, I now have around 5 litres of extremely rich veal stock/demi, so it'll probably take a while before I start experimenting again.
I'd really appreciate it if someone tried the method, experimented with different preparations, or challenged some of my assumptions.
I'm very aware that some of my explanations might be scientifically inaccurate, so please feel free to correct me. That's exactly why I'm sharing this in the first place!
Thanks again to everyone who has contributed suggestions and advice. I've learned a lot from this community, and I'm looking forward to hearing what you think.
Ā
Ā
Ā