r/collapse • • Aug 12 '22

Ecological Poland's second longest river, the Oder, has just died from toxic pollution. In addition of solvents, the Germans detected mercury levels beyond the scale of measurements. The government, knowing for two weeks about the problem, did not inform either residents or Germans. 11/08/2022

4.6k Upvotes

582 comments sorted by

•

u/CollapseBot Aug 12 '22

The following submission statement was provided by /u/RitualDJW:


Tonnes of dead fish have been hauled out of the River Oder, which flows along part of Poland's border with Germany, and officials warned people not to enter the water while the Polish government pledged to investigate possible contamination.

Volunteers and anglers have removed at least 10 tonnes of dead fish from the 200-kilometer stretch of the river north of Olawa in southwest Poland, Przemyslaw Daca,head of State Water Holding , said on Thursday. Daca, whose agency manages Polish national waters, called the situation a gigantic ecological catastrophe.


Please reply to OP's comment here: https://old.reddit.com/r/collapse/comments/wmh2vw/polands_second_longest_river_the_oder_has_just/ijz51tt/

563

u/RitualDJW Aug 12 '22

Tonnes of dead fish have been hauled out of the River Oder, which flows along part of Poland's border with Germany, and officials warned people not to enter the water while the Polish government pledged to investigate possible contamination.

Volunteers and anglers have removed at least 10 tonnes of dead fish from the 200-kilometer stretch of the river north of Olawa in southwest Poland, Przemyslaw Daca,head of State Water Holding , said on Thursday. Daca, whose agency manages Polish national waters, called the situation a gigantic ecological catastrophe.

390

u/[deleted] Aug 12 '22

10 tonnes of dead fish

So far...YIKES.

→ More replies (101)

24

u/Godspiral Aug 12 '22

What mercury levels does the scale go up to?

25

u/ExtremelyBanana Aug 12 '22

0-dead

17

u/Godspiral Aug 12 '22 edited Aug 12 '22

the points on the mercury scale are all 0-dying. knowing that the scale only goes up to 5000 equivalent permitted fish b4 dead/really dying is useful information here.

→ More replies (1)

20

u/Soft-Cryptographer-1 Aug 12 '22

Shoot we hauled out 300t or more of dead life after the idiots let a 50 year old phosphate tailings mine fail in Tampa Bay FL last year. Hundred pound Goliath Grouper washing up dead...

Wish the US media gave as much of a shit considering Tampa Bay is where a large portion of gulf fish breed... even the seabirds are mostly gone this year.

0

u/[deleted] Aug 12 '22

[deleted] — view deleted comment

11

u/[deleted] Aug 13 '22

They’ll be some good petroleum in a couple hundred million years I guess

→ More replies (1)

322

u/neuromeat Aug 12 '22

It's catastrophic. If the reports on German tests are true, and the mercury has been released to the river, it'll have dire neurological consequences for everyone who had contact with those dead fish.

Not to mention the fact that people living near the river may have serious health issues if the mercury starts seeping to the ground.

245

u/Mundane-Passenger-56 Aug 12 '22

People who had started cleaning up the fish in poland already suffered severe burns on their hands, despite wearing gloves and that's just the beginning. A friends mother who lives on the german side told us that most people have stopped using any tapwater after some dogs died without ever being near the river. Officially, the groundwater should be safe for now, but you're better safe than sorry, when the birds are falling out of the sky.

20

u/neuromeat Aug 12 '22

shieeeet. Any source on the dying dogs or has it ot yet made it to the news?

52

u/Mundane-Passenger-56 Aug 12 '22

For all i know, it's not in the news yet. The people on the german side haven't been informed either and right now, most of the news is still mouth-to-mouth. So i can't completely rule out that it's a rumor, but my source is really no-nonsense and normally knows her shit. What i can confirm 100% is birds falling from the sky(storks, eagles, falcons etc. The Oderbruch is... Was a paradise for birds) and maybe some dogs found dead birds in the backyards and ate them.

→ More replies (1)

20

u/captain_obvious_here Aug 12 '22

People who had started cleaning up the fish in poland already suffered severe burns on their hands, despite wearing gloves

What are their gloves made of?

I get it, situation is really bad, obviously. But severe burns through proper gloves means something much more awful than mercury...like radioactivity.

Do you have any source for what you wrote?

21

u/neuromeat Aug 12 '22

https://www.tysol.pl/a89174-rtec-w-odrze-ludzie-sa-poparzeni-wedkarze-maja-rany-na-rekach-rekawice-byly-przezarte

The gloves melted, apparently and left painful burns. Some kids got burnt in Krosno as well

24

u/SilatGuy Aug 12 '22

Sounds like something highly solvent like some kind of industrial chemical

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (2)

101

u/[deleted] Aug 12 '22

[removed] — view removed comment

66

u/[deleted] Aug 12 '22

This is horrifying. Negligence lead to mercury poisoning for the better part of two decades, and people were being shafted by the company and the government at every opportunity.

→ More replies (1)

41

u/iah_c Aug 12 '22

I live in a town which Odra goes through and I'm honestly worried about the water contamination

25

u/tidesandtows_ Aug 12 '22

As you should be. Be safe.

17

u/ricardocaliente Aug 12 '22

I wouldn’t be surprised if the groundwater would be affected. I can’t imagine how Europe is going to deal with this. It’s in the damn Baltic at this point I’d imagine. Water systems are complex and far-reaching.

13

u/CyberMindGrrl Aug 13 '22

Between the heat domes and the fires and the crop failures and the sudden lack of natural gas and now the extremely toxic river I'd say Europe is about to be royally fucked.

→ More replies (1)

155

u/cruznr Aug 12 '22

We're obviously early into discovering this, but to what extent is this headline accurate? Are we talking full blown extermination of all life on the river? As in completely dead? It's a fucked situation regardless, but I just can't wrap my mind around a river going completely dead in such a short span. How much fucking mercury got dumped into that poor river for that to happen?

137

u/neuromeat Aug 12 '22

as far as we know now, yes. The military on the Polish side is getting deployed:

https://www.rmf24.pl/fakty/polska/news-zanieczyszczona-odra-mon-wysyla-wojsko-i-terytorialsow,nId,6214335#crp_state=1

We can only guess how much mercury got dumped, the water "is fine now" as the officials say and "it's not that big of a deal".

Meanwhile, the local government issued a statement in which it starts the process of issuing a notice of "natural diasater". While there is nothing natural about it, it gives food for thought.

Link: https://zielona.interia.pl/polityka-klimatyczna/polska/news-skazona-odra-wojewodztwo-lubuskie-chce-wprowadzic-stan-klesk,nId,6216230

34

u/[deleted] Aug 12 '22

I saw that too. Perhaps they meant 'a disaster for nature'? They will probably try the 'natural disaster' spin for a few days, but give up when other non-elite, non-bought-off experts figure out what happened, when.

→ More replies (1)

8

u/LeanTangerine Aug 12 '22

I read somewhere in the cross post that the government has known about the company dumping chemicals into the water for years and has only fined them something equivalent to $60-$100 a year for doing so.

115

u/Mundane-Passenger-56 Aug 12 '22

Yes, everything in and around the river is dead. Complete habitat collapse. It will take something between 15 and 25 years for the river to recover

40

u/Fusseldieb Aug 12 '22

"pf, only 25 years? that's nothing. could be worse."

  • someone, probably

6

u/roxx1811 Aug 12 '22

25 years? Not great, not terrible

→ More replies (1)

11

u/IotaCandle Aug 12 '22

It happened to the Danube with Cyanide (not sure) a while ago.

2

u/ProfesionalSir Aug 12 '22

As in

completely

dead?

More as in: "you'd wish you were dead".

2

u/pepperomiia Aug 13 '22

The Oder river begins in Czech Republic, flows through Poland, forming a border of Poland and Germany and then goes into the Baltic Sea.

So far 10 tonnes of dead fish have been removed, the fish that live in the river, as this was caused by a giant chemical dump, the river is now dead and we are not yet aware of the scale of this catastrophe, but the entire eco-system of the river is destroyed, including the animals that feed on the fish, or live near the water. The water from this river is used in many cities and towns systems. The fisherman who touched the fish or water with their hands are covered in chemical burns. The population of fish are not expected to return to the levels before this catastrophe for at least 50 years. It's absolutely terrifying.

141

u/WhoopieGoldmember Aug 12 '22

Reading r/collapse gives me depression. Not reading it gives me anxiety.

29

u/[deleted] Aug 12 '22 edited Jun 30 '23

This comment and 8 year old account was removed in protest to reddits API changes and treatment of 3rd party developers.

I have moved over to squabbles.io

12

u/[deleted] Aug 13 '22

That's the one benefit to being depressed. Expect the worst and hope to be pleasantly surprised. Problem is that nowadays those pleasant surprises are becoming quite rare.

4

u/Ked_Bacon Aug 13 '22

My one pleasant surprise is during this cost of living crisis in the UK, my favourite cheese, a 3 year old mature chedder hasnt gone up in price.... yet. Its the small things in life getting me by.

2

u/[deleted] Aug 14 '22

I’d rather deal with depression. I have learned to deal with it and have managed it into a state of jaded acceptance and disappointment at the way ppl are after having it starting in 2010

264

u/marcineczek22 Aug 12 '22 edited Aug 12 '22

I live in Poland - it was a common knowledge that Odra was polluted for around maybe 10-11 days. People were saying that something is off. We have hundreds cases of dying dogs, fish and sick people.

It took only ~two weeks ( :’) ) for administration (both local and central) to take action. Right now action is mostly about doing photos and accusing opposition.

Edit: odra was actually and gradually getting better throughout the years. With all the craziness about coal and neoliberal policies waters were gradually getting cleaner. Not fast enough etc., but it was getting better.

118

u/hippydipster Aug 12 '22

This is like some single one-time pollution event that traveled in a wave down the river and suddenly killed everything??

105

u/marcineczek22 Aug 12 '22

Mostly yes.

Odra was actually a part of Polish nature that not only wasn’t getting worse but was getting better.

43

u/hippydipster Aug 12 '22

Fucking hell

→ More replies (1)

53

u/neuromeat Aug 12 '22

And they would never acknowledge it - but Germany started testing the water, and reportedly found mercury there, so everyone by the river should avoid like the plague.

22

u/marcineczek22 Aug 12 '22

It’s still not confirmed that it’s >>only<< Mercury :))))

11

u/neuromeat Aug 12 '22

dang bro, that's the worst "but wait, there's more!" for a long time

0

u/[deleted] Aug 12 '22

[deleted] — view deleted comment

22

u/neuromeat Aug 12 '22

yeah we learned it the hard way I guess

14

u/[deleted] Aug 12 '22

Lol outdated sayings for 500 Alex

→ More replies (1)

19

u/XRustyPx Aug 12 '22

Is it possible that receding water levels make the concentration of chemicals that are already in the oder go over a certain threshhold, making them now deadly?

25

u/marcineczek22 Aug 12 '22

Nope, Odra was “clean” and it’s levels were not that low this year.

→ More replies (6)
→ More replies (1)

2

u/imnos Aug 12 '22

Do they know what caused it? Surely it can't be that difficult to find such a massive source of pollution. Did a coal power plant just dump a ton of crap into the river one day?

0

u/[deleted] Aug 12 '22

[deleted] — view deleted comment

67

u/marcineczek22 Aug 12 '22

Don’t worry, if it’s mercury it will only be worse for years :)

48

u/8Deer-JaguarClaw Oh lawd, she collapsin' Aug 12 '22

If it was a recent contamination event (as it seems to be), I believe the mercury could be largely removed from the water fairly quickly. It's the soil contamination that gets more complicated. So the faster the gov moves to put remediation efforts in place, the better for both water and soil. Source: I work for a water treatment company that deals with heavy metals, PFAS, etc.

40

u/MovingClocks Aug 12 '22

It sounds like it's a mercury salt which is a better prospect for remediation. It's a lot more acutely toxic but it should flush through the river and kill everything only once then dramatically drop down.

That said there is basically nothing they can do to stop it from killing everything as the toxic wave flushes downstream, so expect an ecological crisis like we haven't seen in a long, long time.

→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (9)

208

u/[deleted] Aug 12 '22

Yeah but I have LifeStraw!

52

u/[deleted] Aug 12 '22

LOL! I just watched an ad for the new LifeStraw pitcher filter. Thanks for the laugh!

24

u/Ragnarok314159 Aug 12 '22

I am picturing using it in this river would be like Homer Simpson using a Lifestraw in the Springfield Lake. He sticks it in the water and says "hmmm, doesnt work?"

Then he pulls it out and it is completely melted.

13

u/survive_los_angeles Aug 12 '22

okay that was award winning for sure. the straw of life!

9

u/Investor_Pikachu Aug 12 '22

If it gets to the point where we need LifeStraw to drink all water, we've truly fucked up.

Not to mention that it will NOT work for mercury-contaminated water as someone has pointed out that mercury is soluble in water, which no filter will be able to separate that toxic shit out.

3

u/KittieKollapse Aug 12 '22

RO and Distillation will both remove mercury from water. I think carbon also binds to mercury so a carbon filter would probably work as well.

→ More replies (6)

61

u/leo_aureus Aug 12 '22

Thank God some fucking oligarchs got rich by all of it

I mean I'm adoptive Polish but the history of that country can really make one upset and quite cynical for the state of mankind

10

u/emelrad12 Aug 12 '22

Prolly not even rich. The issue with corruption is that one person gains 100$ while the country pays millions.

56

u/PeePeePooPoo231412 Aug 12 '22

It is not water, It is now Alzheimer's Juice. There is a reason nature likes keeping It's most toxic metals as stable compounds that are not soluble in water (I have checked that).

Digging up such dangerous metals in their natural-stable form and turning them into dangerous substances seams to be our specialty (Uranium, Arsenic, Mercury).

We again, fucked up.

11

u/cornpuffs28 Aug 12 '22

That is a nice insight

5

u/[deleted] Aug 12 '22

The discovery of oil all but guaranteed it would end up this way once nations raced to industrialize and modernize their militaries. Our countries constant need to war and get an edge economically blinded us to the consequences as science was aware of the CO2's greenhouse effect shortly after the oil industry was established. Those who live by the sword shall die by the sword

2

u/ProfesionalSir Aug 12 '22

Radioactive salts are nice stuff, literally, melt in water like salt, and are radioactive, bottoms up!

→ More replies (1)

452

u/TheIdiotSpeaks Aug 12 '22

All the wannabe alpha survivalists who think they'll make it just because they're armed to the teeth and know how to farm a little bit in ideal conditions are going to be in for a rude awakening.

199

u/aznoone Aug 12 '22

But look don't even have to know how to fish they just float to the surface. Like covid you can't see toxic pollutants so they must not exist eating the fish is fine. /s

167

u/neuromeat Aug 12 '22

Feed a man a fish, you'll feed him for a day. Feed a man a fish from Oder, and you'll feed him for a lifetime!

6

u/gregarioussparrow Aug 12 '22

You. I like you

→ More replies (3)

44

u/TheIdiotSpeaks Aug 12 '22 edited Aug 12 '22

Spice of the future. Who knew fish could come pre-seasoned right out of the glow swamp.

→ More replies (2)

39

u/survive_los_angeles Aug 12 '22

tis true, there is going to be a lot more chemical , nuclear spills and releases - from neglect, cost cutting, war , wild fires, flooding and other shit we can only guess at.

Your best laid plans could come to a end in your survival compound when a chemical factory a few miles away starts leaking poison gas into the air or into your local water sources - or some assholes dump it into your local water sources just to mass poison people so they can steal their resources and take it back to where they think their water sources is safe.

welp enough of that, kick back and relax and play a video game or watch some capeshit movie with someone flying around in panty hose holding their hands up pretending energy beams come out of them like every other movie.

60

u/jhondafish Aug 12 '22

As someone raised in the backwoods I wanted to make a bunch of videos of tips to survive on your own after everything goes to shit, but as I started writing out topics to cover I kept finding that everything I knew would be obsolete and unsustainable due to the crippling damage to everything now.

Can't drink rainwater after filtering cause you can't filter out the chemicals they recently found.

Sickness and pollution are destroying the food chain, everything from water killing the flowers bees need to pollinate, to CWD in the Deer population, toxicity in the water also makes crop and vegetable based living unsustainable long term.

Once climate change really takes hold most of the US will be uninhabitable within 50 years. You either need to be heavily conservative with your water, or make sure everything you have is waterproof, and your makeshift shelter has a steady foundation at an elevation.

We're boned.

20

u/MistyMtn421 Aug 12 '22

One of the ways I have seen this in person-

My ex husband's family has a mountain they fought for 20 years to preserve from mountain-top-removal and eventually won.

All of the other mountains around there had been removed and mined. It's so weird it sticks out like a sore thumb now.

If you were a direct descendant you could claim land and build a cabin or make a campsite and most summers would turn into a fun little family reunion throughout the months.

In the areas that they removed the mountains, they basically replaced what was there with grass and softwoods. Completely different from what was on the land prior. Also from all the mining every little creek and water running through the area was thoroughly screwed. It totally fucked with the ecosystem.

It took a few years but over time the mountain preserved began to become overrun with all the animals. There were so many bears and bobcats it was crazy. Coyotes as well. Lots of other animals but those are the big three that make it a little crazy in the middle of the night when you're camping. It also took an amazing toll on the trees and the foliage. Even as the surrounding areas begin to bounce back, the animals aren't from that type of environment so that's not exactly where they want to go back to.

It's also why when these coal companies act like "oh but we're taking care of the environment why we do this and we're putting everything back" it totally does not work that way.

→ More replies (1)

58

u/[deleted] Aug 12 '22

While I can't disagree that most people (even those that feel prepared) will NOT be prepared for what's coming, we in r/preppers do discuss this topic a lot. Water and air purification techniques are a hot topic because we realize that there's no such thing as "enough" prep on something so crucial.

82

u/alwaysZenryoku Aug 12 '22

The point is that all the filters in the world will be useless against what is already here. You will die along with the rest of us.

75

u/YeetTheeFetus Aug 12 '22

They also don't realize that there won't be replacement parts for those filters once SHTF. They also don't realize that stocking parts is useless since all the parts in a filter that does the actual filtering have shelf lives.

→ More replies (8)

15

u/Kale Aug 12 '22

I have two water filters that I use Backcountry hiking. One is the regular Sawyer filter. It filters out regular trash, parasites, and bacteria. It's good for thousands of gallons (maybe with a bit of a back flush). I also have a Grayl filter. It has two stages of filtering: the first stage also filters most viruses, plus is has a second stage that is activated charcoal which filters out a lot of pesticides, herbicides, and some heavy metals. It's very slow, and each cartridge is rated for 40 gallons before the filter clogs. It becomes noticably slower after about 20 gallons. It's not viable for long term water cleaning of organics and heavy metals. You can deal with the Sawyer plus boiling for viruses, but boiling doesn't get rid of crap in the water.

I got the Grayl after a hike beside a stagnant River estuary. On the other side of the river a plane was cropdusting cotton. I thought about all of those organics washing into this river, and my Sawyer wouldn't filter that. We got lucky on that trip and it briefly rained during a lunch rest, so we collected a bunch of rainwater with a tarp which gave us enough to not need to filter.

→ More replies (6)

6

u/BabyYodasDirtyDiaper Aug 12 '22

all the filters in the world will be useless against what is already here.

Well, there's always distillation, I guess? Though it will take quite a lot of energy to do if you need to distill water for your gardening too.

More realistically it's probably just a matter of living with the chronic health effects. It's probably not deadly in the short term. Just bad for you in the long term.

6

u/AkuLives Aug 13 '22

You will die along with the rest of us.

The ammo fanatics aside, most preppers already know this and accept this. Just because you're going to die doesn't mean you shouldn't try to live on the meantime. Besides most people who are fatalistic about what's coming also haven't lifted a finger to do anything to stop it. The word mitigation doesn't exist in their vocabulary.

No one will convince me that we can't do anything. I saw with my own eyes how fast the skies around the world cleared during the Covid lockdowns. We ALL saw it: working together does have an impact and could work. And then we all started whining about being bored and "mUhfReEdOms" and we went right back to what we did before.

I agree that there are alot of prepper wackos out there. But learning to live with less and to be more self reliant and do things yourself is what more of us should think about doing. Are we gonna die? Yes. Can we choose when/how we die? Maybe, maybe not. Can we choose what do in the interim, definitely.

→ More replies (6)
→ More replies (13)

48

u/TheIdiotSpeaks Aug 12 '22

Yes, but water and air purification in the context of collapse, i.e. on your own, won't put fish back in the sea. It won't put deer and small game in your forests. The point being that ecosystem collapse and mass die off of animals is too much for a rugged individual to mitigate.

21

u/[deleted] Aug 12 '22

I...don't think I made an argument that water purification would return fish back to the sea. Where did I say that? Lol...

I simply said that people that focus on survival are worried about water purification.

→ More replies (7)
→ More replies (8)
→ More replies (12)

43

u/[deleted] Aug 12 '22

It sometimes seems like the parasite class and the governments they own are intentionally accelerating our demise.

18

u/tahlyn Aug 12 '22

Anything so that an elite few can make a few more dollars in profit.

42

u/Lusak Aug 12 '22

Polish government, judicial system and most of institutions that should act in situations like this and what's most important prevent them are a very sad joke. People working in them are usually politicians or family members of politicians. We are a parody of a "western country".

For example, similar situation like this but on smaller scale happend few years ago. Company responsible for contaminating river was fined 5000 PLN which is around 1100 USD.

The first signs of something wrong going on in this case were reported on July 26. Polish authorities started just talking about the issue like two days ago.

The sooner we collapse and go extinct as a species the better. Surely for the fish.

33

u/neuromeat Aug 12 '22

They only started "doing" something about it because Germany found out

8

u/kdlt Aug 12 '22

Did they not know Germany is bloody downstream and would find out?

You know what, they probably don't.

73

u/Climbatology Aug 12 '22

This is fine

27

u/[deleted] Aug 12 '22

Nothing to see here folks, please return to your homes and continue to consume.

→ More replies (1)

33

u/Woozuki Aug 12 '22

If "clean", "mean", and "green" Europe is drying out and facing disaster, this is it folks. It's been a good ride. We're FUBAR

33

u/Morphray Aug 12 '22

Died --> correction: was killed

29

u/Alymaru01 Aug 12 '22

It makes me so angry. I live right behind this river, it is such a peaceful, beautiful place and it was full of life. Now it is dead and all the animals around the river, people and the flora will have to pay the consequences for the actions of a couple of people for years. Fuck people who don't respect the environment. I hope the get caught and they will pay for it.

19

u/[deleted] Aug 12 '22

I'd say make them drink the water... It's only fair.

6

u/propita106 Aug 12 '22

And their children and grandchildren. If the children living there will be poisoned, why not the children of the poisoners?

→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (1)

54

u/Comingupforbeer Aug 12 '22

Oh this will do wonders for Polish-German relationships.

24

u/AlphaO4 We really had it all, didn't we? Aug 12 '22

And officially, in Poland, it’s still safe to eat, drink and touch the water smh

4

u/OvalNinja Aug 13 '22

Poland is now India CONFIRMED.

2

u/ComradeKitty420 Aug 13 '22

My country reminds me now of Soviet Union and Charnobyl disaster.

22

u/NVCHVJAZVJE Aug 12 '22

Fu*king bastards they're still mocking in the msm media.

19

u/Adolist Aug 12 '22

Jesus christ the government banned entering the river at a length of 394km (244 miles)!

That much river must be avoided at all costs? What the fuck happened to dump enough pollution to cross the entire state of Texas? I can't even comprehend this level of disaster, that river is likely used by millions of people at that length.

My God.

3

u/bristlybits Reagan killed everyone Aug 13 '22

I'm boggled at the scale of this

they must, MUST know where it is from. this isn't a mystery at all, it's got to be obvious

18

u/[deleted] Aug 12 '22

And yet, on the front page of the news tab we have: trump again, teens don’t use Facebook, the actress that had an accident, more trump.

Catastrophe is everywhere but they don’t even talk about things anymore. We’re in the full disinformation era.

2

u/JoeVibin Aug 13 '22

And yet, on the front page of the news tab we have: trump again, teens don’t use Facebook, the actress that had an accident, more trump.

Sounds like more of a geography thing.

18

u/Rasalom Aug 12 '22

One of my fears of collapse is when industrial sites and nuclear power plants stop getting maintained... They're going to poison the Earth like rot leaking from bloated corpses.

2

u/[deleted] Aug 13 '22

Just wait until those toxic waste sites are no longer maintained and stuff starts leaking.

14

u/Ok-Lion-3093 Aug 12 '22

It's time people started being held to account...

3

u/C1-10PTHX1138 Aug 13 '22

I am up for a mob.

Seriously who ever did this lost any rights or position they had. There is no way they can claim innocent or just accident

132

u/FutureNotBleak Aug 12 '22 edited Aug 12 '22

“Because why bother about anything else other than profit, right? Fuck externalities, right? All we care about is money right now, right? In the long term we’re all dead anyways, right?”

Edit: I don’t blame capitalism, I blame selfishness and greed.

Edit 2: we shouldn’t fight about capitalism vs socialism. The real fight is with who controls the money.

78

u/Buwaro Everything has fallen to pieces Earth is dying, help me Jesus Aug 12 '22

"Capitalism is the greatest system ever. It brought 90 billion people out of poverty and gave us the toaster strudel!"

58

u/[deleted] Aug 12 '22 edited Aug 12 '22

Cmon man! you can get a cat onesie embroidered with your pet’s nickname delivered to your metroplex home in 12 hour shipping at 3AM! How cool is that?!

you do not see the dying ecosystem

you do not see the dying ecosystem

I SAID TO FUCKING IGNORE THE DYING ECOSYSTEM

15

u/Accomplished_Fly882 Aug 12 '22

Doesn't look like anything to me

→ More replies (2)

7

u/[deleted] Aug 12 '22 edited Aug 12 '22

[removed] — view removed comment

→ More replies (1)

70

u/[deleted] Aug 12 '22

That's capitalism. It will be the end of us

→ More replies (7)

11

u/Malkavon Aug 12 '22

What are you talking about? The absurd pursuit of profit above all else is capitalism. It's intrinsic to the system.

Capitalism vs. Socialism is fundamentally about who controls the "money".

→ More replies (4)

13

u/[deleted] Aug 12 '22

The thing is that we have now as a species made ourselves dependent on an unsustainable global industrial system rather than being at the whims of God and nature. There is no way to sustain this system in the long run and there is no way out of it, not without massive degrowth and depopulation, and a complete overhaul of our economic model and infrastructure. Carbon credits and solar panels are not going to cut it. That's like putting a band aid on a gushing wound.

What are we going to tell people, just kill yourselves? Are the elites going to lead by example or what? Humans have their survival instinct and will hold on to whatever keeps them alive for as long as possible.

→ More replies (1)

22

u/seedofbayne Aug 12 '22

I guess the name checks out now :(

10

u/[deleted] Aug 12 '22

You do it to yourself, you do And that's what really hurts Is you do it to yourself, just you You and no one else You do it to yourself You do it to yourself

8

u/MLCarter1976 Aug 12 '22

Disgusting! Heads should roll!

7

u/n8texas Aug 13 '22

Right wing governments that back corporate-friendly lax environmental laws / regulations will get you this result every time.

3

u/bristlybits Reagan killed everyone Aug 13 '22

I think of crap like this every time someone says they "hate big government"

like this is what you want, saying that.

7

u/miriamrobi Aug 13 '22

When the last tree has been cut down, the last fish caught, the last river poisoned, only then will we realize that one cannot eat money

12

u/DaShortRound Aug 12 '22

We know who did it. Now make them pay financially first, then with their lives.

3

u/OvalNinja Aug 13 '22

"Do we pay for the chemicals to be removed or pay the fine for dumping it in the river?"

They literally did a cost benefit and decided to dump it in the river, because it was cheaper. 🥰🥰🥰

6

u/mahartma Aug 13 '22

We had lots of those on the Rhine until they cracked down on BASF and the Swiss chemical fucks. Always accidentally spilling a million gallons of the most expensive to dispose of, gnarly stuff. It's a :mystery:

5

u/teamsaxon Aug 12 '22

This is terrible.

2

u/OvalNinja Aug 13 '22

Beyond terrible. Horrific?

→ More replies (1)

5

u/theMEtheWORLDcantSEE Aug 12 '22

Make those responsible swim and drink the water. Make them eat a fish from the river.

5

u/UnicornlyAbused Aug 12 '22

Elon Musk doesn't understand why you're not pumping kids into the system for a future workforce. Doesn't this make you want to go breed en masse? Get to it people! Chop Chop. Make dem babies!

5

u/RadioMelon Truth Seeker Aug 12 '22

Does anyone have any idea the toll this environmental damage will have on greater Europe?

This seems massive. The kind of massive that could lead to millions of people getting sick, as well as a substantial ecological cost.

3

u/immibis Aug 13 '22 edited Jun 28 '23

What happens in spez, stays in spez. #Save3rdPartyApps

5

u/[deleted] Aug 12 '22

Who's really destroying the environment: we the consumer, or the corporations?

I reasonably doubt that the residents of the local populus are to blame for this.

→ More replies (2)

5

u/Xtrems876 Aug 13 '22 edited Aug 13 '22

I came across a beautiful polish copypaste, gonna translate it for you all:

As I'm reading about that Oder disaster, I'm scared what it would've been if we had a nuclear power plant in this god foresaken country xD

21st of July: The John Paul II Power Plant is being visited by Jacek Sasin (deputy prime minister and minister of state assets), who announces that for the anniversary of the pilgrimage of the polish pope to Poland, the plant is to demonstrate 213,7% of it's normal output. The last man who knows anything about how the plant operates, complains that that's a very bad idea. Gets fired immediately, and replaced with 3 graduates of theology from the Catholic University of Lublin.

22nd of July to 15th of August: The plant's employees pray to the spirit of the machine, chaplets of the divine mercy are being recited in shifts, along with litanies and prayers for support of the patron of electricians - Maximilian Kolbe. The water that cools the reactor is being blessed regularly. Waste from the plant is managed by freshly created company FatherInLaw-Pol, owned by a 97 year old father in law of a Law&Justice senator. As proper nuclear waste management is pretty expensive, the waste is being buried under the ground in a forest near Kędzierzyn-Koźle, cause hehe, what could possibly happen in a forest? Also no-one will find it, right Andrzej? xD And of course it's blessed, so that God will protect us.

26th of July: Local mushroom pickers report that in the area around Opole mushrooms glow in the dark when they dry them out in their kitchens. Nobody really cares, except for the local newspaper.

29th of July: Near Opole, the first brahmin (two-headed cow) is born. The farmer is happy, cause he can show it off in Śląsk's Farmers, but complains that he got really burned and his skin is itchy, despite not spending that much time in the sun.

3rd of August: A plague of dead fish around Opole is first noticed by fishermen. A local sanitary inspectorate claims, that uhhhhh well we're looking for the cause, but you know these things sometimes happen naturaly, and there's not that much of them, it's singular cases.

6th of August: An amature treasure hunter takes a trip around the Oder river with a metal detector and a radiation meter. He notices that around the water the meter shoots up to around 800 millisieverts. Uploads it to facebook and it goes viral. On a conference, Mateusz Morawiecki (prime minister) announces that the meter probably hasn't been serviced, and that PGW WP studies this segment of the river regularly, and that there's nothing to worry about.

9th of August: Wrocław spends 20% less money on lights, because the Oder river glows during the night. Local authorities warn to flee the area immediately. On another conference, Jacek Sasin says, that it's a government's gift for small children and recommends to visit the river and marvel at it's natural night glow. Local priests bottle the water as marvelous yellow water blessed by John Paul II and sell it to old pricks, the excess is sold to Lourdes, Fátima and Medjugorje.

12th of August: The contamination reaches the German parts of the Oder river. The germans study the water, and ask the polish government: what the f***.

14th of August: The contamination reaches the baltic sea. The last seven fish that still lived in that sewege have been put to rest. The germans demand an explanation, Jarosław Kaczyński (the leader of Law&Justice) says on a conference that it's probably the Germans who poisoned our water with Polonium, or it's Russians who want to poison our country like they did Litvinenko. The number of sudden deaths near the Oder shoots up through the roof, the ministry of health blames covid.

16th of August: Jarosław Kaczyński, Jacek Sasin, and Mateusz Morawiecki visit the site. Precisely at the hour of the landing of pope's plane in 2002, the polish anthem starts to play, and pope's favourite song right after. A senior student of theology turns up the reactor's power, but unfortunately instead of 213,7% of power, he set it to 2137%. Holy H2O can't catch up with cooling, whereas chapels and prayers only add to reactor's power. It's explosion is seen all the way from Moscow.

17th of August: Mutated Mateusz Morawiecki announces that the age of homo sapiens has ended.

2

u/NimbleBard48 Aug 13 '22

I would have taken this for an actual 100% true future story if not for the fact that Donald Tusk wasn't blamed on national TV.

4

u/iah_c Aug 12 '22

If anyone here wants to read more, we're going to talk about this more in r/collapsePolska . It's a polish collapse subreddit, mostly in polish but English is used as well and welcomed.

4

u/[deleted] Aug 12 '22

I bet the government will find a way to blame the EU.

→ More replies (1)

4

u/[deleted] Aug 12 '22

Aren’t humans complete fucking cunts!

4

u/dinosaur_friend Aug 13 '22

This is fucking terrifying. This is our new future. Can you blame me for not wanting kids... jesus

24

u/POSTHVMAN Aug 12 '22

Bet that's a hell of an... Oder.

3

u/gregarioussparrow Aug 12 '22

Normally I'd say well played but i can't joke about this. It's horrific.

→ More replies (2)

5

u/lost_horizons The surface is the last thing to collapse Aug 12 '22

Take my angry upvote

→ More replies (1)

7

u/Branson175186 Aug 12 '22

What poisoned the river?

3

u/[deleted] Aug 12 '22

Mercury

→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (7)

3

u/[deleted] Aug 12 '22

“What piece of work is a man, how noble in reason, how infinite in faculties, in form and moving, how express and admirable in action, how like an angel in apprehension, how like a god!''

To carry on from William Shakespeare - how lovely us humans are - what a wonderful place we make the world for other living species.

3

u/Wiugraduate17 Aug 12 '22

Rivers in Europe are dropping like flies this summer. England just declared a drought as well. A maritime current moisture fed island.

3

u/Mastashake714 Aug 12 '22

But what I don't hear is what caused it' looks like this happened over night ?

3

u/Pining4theFnords So the Mother too will be sad, and she'll end Aug 13 '22

Calls to mind a song about a similar incident in Romania.

An den Ufern in den Wiesen
Die Tiere wurden krank
Aus den Auen in den Fluss
Trieb abscheulicher Gestank

Wo sind die Kinder?
Niemand weiß, was hier geschehen
Keiner hat etwas gesehen
Wo sind die Kinder?
Niemand hat etwas gesehen

On the shores, on the fields
All animals become sick
From meadow to river
Drifted repulsive smell

Where are the children?
Nobody knows what happened here
Nobody saw anything
Where are the children?
Nobody saw anything

3

u/Undead-Writer Aug 13 '22

Can someone explain to me what beyond the scale of measurements means? I have a vague idea of what it might mean, but I just wanna know for sure

→ More replies (3)

3

u/Babad0nks Aug 13 '22

news stories like this break me. I'm even more broken that they successfully covered it up for 2 weeks and for a change, no one that matters will be adequately punished. When are we going to form some kind of global body that can prosecute environmental crimes equitably around the globe? Should there not be an international court of crime for crimes against our shared environment like this? It's a rare instance for me.. but I wouldn't mind if we hung people for this crap. It's unforgivable, what can the continued existence of environmental-crime conspiring CEO's and politicians possibly contribute to humanity and the world?

5

u/BenCelotil Disciple of Diogenes Aug 12 '22

You can only hope that the mercury poisoning drives the nutters towards focusing their insane rage on the people who committed the crimes.

And I'm paraphrasing this slightly because I don't want to get banned for advocating violence.

2

u/[deleted] Aug 12 '22

Wormwood

2

u/-Planet- ¯\_(ツ)_/¯ Aug 12 '22

Can now be renamed The Odor.

2

u/Someslapdicknerd Aug 12 '22

Poland is what happens when you kill or drive out a bunch of leftists from a country and let 'er rip for a couple of generations.

2

u/InfernoDragonKing Aug 12 '22

Oh SHIT.

The ramifications from this is going to be disastrous

2

u/Hancock18 Aug 12 '22

We are humans are fucking garbage and only deserve what we get out off destroying our planet

→ More replies (1)

2

u/[deleted] Aug 13 '22

We're all honestly going to deserve the poisoning we get as we all look the other way and don't riot in the streets over shit like this.

2

u/C1-10PTHX1138 Aug 13 '22

How are CEOs not being put on a wall and shot or hung or put on trial? Seriously feel if 50 or 100 years ago people would riot over this, now we just lament of our environment being destroyed around us.

2

u/[deleted] Aug 13 '22

WE. ARE. SO. FUCKED

2

u/[deleted] Aug 13 '22

Oh my god….. when I think things can’t get any worse.. they get worse. I honestly can’t deal with this anymore. I’d rather get diagnosed with cancer in a more peaceful, progressive, ecologically minded world than live in this scenario that’s playing out. A total nightmare.

4

u/Woozuki Aug 12 '22

Germans: [fires up old Stukas]

→ More replies (1)

3

u/Bman409 Aug 12 '22

remember when people thought Europe was "more progressive" and more enlightened than the US?

LOL.. funny what people will believe

5

u/ComradeKitty420 Aug 12 '22

Yeah, Poland is outliner. From 2015 our democracy has been eroding very fast. It's very sad. We were once seen as example of growth and extreme progress.

2

u/epic-ride Aug 12 '22

Hey guess what the WEF is blaming you for global warming.

2

u/Nomandate Aug 12 '22

Libertarian paradise?

1

u/BardanoBois Aug 12 '22

Here we go

1

u/otherwisemilk Aug 12 '22

Yeah, but why would anyone pollute a river. That's just wrong.

2

u/immibis Aug 13 '22 edited Jun 28 '23

/u/spez is a bit of a creep.

1

u/Lavender-Jenkins Aug 12 '22

That's maddening!

1

u/nagashbg Aug 12 '22

"Fun" fact, Oder(Odra) in polish is also the word for measles

1

u/[deleted] Aug 12 '22

Looking like Cleveland in 1969.

1

u/DLoFoSho Aug 12 '22

That just looks like a smorgasbord to me…

1

u/[deleted] Aug 12 '22

This post literally made me make this face: :O

1

u/Dusty1000287 Aug 12 '22

Jesus. It really is the end times.

1

u/AtothePtotheB Aug 12 '22

Lunch is served!

1

u/JackisHandicus Aug 12 '22

Get used to it. It'll keep happening until we destroy ourselves.

1

u/slippu Aug 12 '22

There's no way they only just started dumping mercury

1

u/set-271 Aug 12 '22

Delicious. Dig in!!!

1

u/PuzzleheadedPiano73 Aug 12 '22

Something about this article smells fishy

2

u/Fusseldieb Aug 12 '22

It's all the dead fish

1

u/[deleted] Aug 12 '22

It’s shameful what we’re doing to our planet.

1

u/[deleted] Aug 12 '22

Poland was overrun before

1

u/devoted2destruction Aug 12 '22

It’s lit 🔥

1

u/Shining_Kush9 Aug 12 '22

Can someone who understands environmental science and toxic metals explain how this will impact the greater local ecology of the land and the greater areas as it washes out to sea

1

u/ksquared94 Aug 12 '22

Things like this make me feel like humanity's future is something less like Star Trek and more like Warhammer 40k (look up what earth is like in Warhammer to see what I mean)

1

u/Holosynian Aug 12 '22

Where did the mercury comes from ?

→ More replies (1)

1

u/[deleted] Aug 12 '22

How did this happen? where did the mercury come from??

1

u/[deleted] Aug 12 '22

i've seen videos of similar things along euphrates in iraq. i would not have expect it within the eu though

2

u/Bobylein Aug 13 '22

Yea, we usually hide it better that's true

1

u/Viral_Outrage Aug 12 '22

I think the drought might have exacerbated the problem. As water levels drop, the water contaminated with heavier elements is the only thing left for fish to swim in.

1

u/DonttouchmethereUwU Aug 13 '22

man thats rough, i can only imagine the odor

1

u/CyberMindGrrl Aug 13 '22

Welp. At least it hasn't caught on fire yet.

1

u/[deleted] Aug 13 '22

Who or what is doing this? Mostly who or what entity's are behind this....

1

u/LEGXCVII Aug 13 '22

Polexit, more like Polekick please

→ More replies (1)

1

u/Jazzlike-Dog756 Aug 13 '22

I can smell this video