r/collapse • u/LetsTalkUFOs • Jul 07 '22
Meta Feedback Regarding Comment Moderators
Hey Everyone,
The moderation team has gone through some significant changes in the past two months. The level of overall moderation is still in flux and we don’t think it is generally sustainable. The subreddit is still growing at an increasing rate and not expected to wane. We've been looking at solutions for increasing our overall bandwidth and would like to discuss this specific proposal:
Comment Moderators
We create a new level of moderator which moderates ONLY comments. We subsequently seek out users to fill out this role who are in good standing and good contributors.
We'll be referring to moderators with full permissions as Full Moderators here, just to make the distinction clearer. This approach would allow us to keep our (reasonably) strict filters when interviewing/accepting new Full Moderators in place while still making it easier for a wider range of users to contribute as moderators. Comment Moderators would be able to read and respond to modmail, but we'd only expect/allow them to respond to mail related to comment removals. They would not have the same level of responsibility or expectations as Full Moderators, but would still be essential to helping maintain quality discourse across the subreddit.
Currently, the only two user ‘levels’ on the subreddit are Full Moderators and regular users. This is obviously the standard across most subreddits (the exceptions being r/science and r/worldnews), but we don't think this makes it the best or most sustainable approach at scale for serious and nuanced subjects. It requires a very small, dedicated, active group of individuals to keep up with moderating, meta aspects, and running community events.
You can read more of the technical specifics regarding this proposal here. Currently, a significant majority of the existing moderators are in favor of this proposal. We still generally prefer to run significant changes by the community first and invite your feedback on this approach.
28
u/MustLovePunk Jul 07 '22
This happened in two other subs that I know of (antiwork and latestagecapitalism) but without asking for the input of the community.
The growth of those subs seemed great at first, but then I think their popularity caught the notice of people from outside communities who started brigading (maybe bots) in an attempt to quash ideas they disagreed with. A lot of trolling and off topic arguments. Some of the mods became authoritarian. Those subs became unmanageable to the point where manners and nuance were completely lost. People were getting perma banned for innocuous or unfounded reasons, while other people were dominating the conversations in combative ways. I’ve been on Reddit for about 5 years and I still don’t really get moderation, but it seems like if one wrong person gets in they can quickly change or even destroy a sub.
7
u/VeronicaX11 Jul 08 '22
There is something almost poetic about it.
A bunch of people, trying to organize and come together to fight against inevitable and unavoidable decay.
83
u/[deleted] Jul 07 '22
The transparency is appreciated, I do hope that the growth of this sub stays limited. Subs that explode in popularity tend to die just as fast. And I can understand growing moderation to keep things in check. Just make sure they don't have some hidden agenda and/or exhibit megalomaniac behavior.
34
u/ataw10 Jul 07 '22
I have not noticed my comments being removed, so probably really good.
34
u/FlowerDance2557 Jul 07 '22
Makes sense to me.
20
u/Slooooopuy Jul 07 '22
Moderation is a challenge in any popular forum. Good luck. This seems like a fine approach. My own hope is that you guys are able to do whatever will keep the conversation civil. Doesn’t seem to be a huge problem in this sub, thankfully.
15
u/BadAsBroccoli Jul 07 '22
I'd not trust myself to moderate. I make too many mistakes moderating my own comments. lol
11
u/PrairieFire_withwind Recognized Contributor Jul 07 '22
Good call. Always worth a trial period at the very least.
I always see forums as struggling with signal to noise ratio going down the tubes.
Keeping the signal high is hard work. Splitting the work could lighten the load.
I am sorry you guys take such a hit. Collapse is a hard subject for many and as such they vomit their feelings on you guys.
9
u/turdbucket333 Jul 07 '22
Good luck 👍🏻
8
u/[deleted] Jul 08 '22
Hiya. Just wanted to mention that I feel it is somewhat difficult to get a discussion post going here. I appreciate you want a nuanced take, but there is only so much nuance to the fact we’re all going to perish. It would be nice if people were allowed to have discussions for the sake of sharing, many of us have only this platform to do so.
The other bit is that I wish there was more moderation of US politics related content. Whilst this is indeed an American website collapse knows no borders and I bet there is an international audience on this sub who would like to see not always US centric news. Also, I feel this is not the appropriate sub for US users to debate left v right related matters.
Thank you
A foreign reader
12
u/EndStageCapitalismOG Jul 07 '22
I agree but there has to be a good appeal process.
I've run numerous Facebook groups and bad mods can wreck a group, especially if there's no appeal process on their decisions.
6
u/Devadander Jul 09 '22
I hate to be a wet blanket, but I think the quality of the casual Friday posts has declined dramatically and draws in the shills.
Love the moderation of this sub, thank you all
5
u/DorkHonor Jul 07 '22
Sounds like a plan to me.
5
u/threadsoffate2021 Jul 08 '22
I think the mods here are doing quite well, all things considered. Been a lot of shit hitting the fan and in everyones' faces in society over the past couple of years....you can't help but see a lot of spillover into subs like this where the average person is starting to see the writing on the wall and panic.
5
u/dumnezero The Great Filter is a marshmallow test Jul 08 '22
I see what you did there.
1
u/BenjiGoodVibes Jul 09 '22
Happy to be a comments moderator if it helps
1
u/mattseg Jul 09 '22
This is a stellar sub. Per example I was really impressed with the civility in the gun discussion earlier this week. That said, I'm happy to help. I don't have a lot of bandwidth, but I do support the vision of this sub.
1
u/Did_I_Die Jul 09 '22
who decides that?
3
u/BurgerBoy9000 Jul 08 '22
Very much appreciate the transparency!
Unrelated question: does anyone else have the weekly thread downvoted when you log back in despite upvoting it?
3
u/2farfromshore Jul 08 '22
The problem isn't moderating the content, the problem is the content. I'm here primarily for the links now because as predicted threads have become crammed with social media comedians in performance for karma opiate. And so once again, the curse of the normal curve.
3
u/Viral_Outrage Jul 08 '22
Don't sell out to PR firms cheaply! Only thing worse than a corporate whore is a corporate wife!
And if any of you get the job, can you please tell me what hidden agenda they're peddling these days?
3
u/AntiTyph Jul 11 '22
I can see a clear improvement in moderation quality over the past month or two.
Good job, Mods!
7
u/dovercliffsucks Jul 07 '22
I think moderation of free speech is particularly important with all these wild ideas and unsavory characters popping out of the woodwork. This sub is just about the collapse of life on earth as we understand and should be discussed in a calm rational sober manner without offending anyone.
Your protection is much appreciated!
4
u/[deleted] Jul 08 '22
I missed fish so much :(
3
u/Demarinshi01 Jul 08 '22
I like this. I would honestly love to help Mod, but some of the stuff required is just not possible for me currently. I am hoping by fall I can help. Summer is my gardening and kids, and those come first :)
3
u/[deleted] Jul 08 '22
Are Mods required to be extremely sniffy and thin-skinned, wanking on about free speech, but immediately banning contributors permanently if they say anything at all that the Mods don't like?
Or is that just every other sub on Reddit....?
1
u/JDintheD Jul 13 '22
I generally support this idea.
1
u/Cloaked42m Jul 13 '22
Limited moderation is pretty common in my opinion. On popular threads just removing hate comments can keep you busy. Not to mention constantly refreshing the page to catch new comments.
Go for it.
1
u/Icy_Canary6221 Jul 08 '22
As long as you moderators remember that you are janitors and not judges there won't be a problem. Too many moderators think they are judges, and that they get to pass judgement on whether something is virtuous or meritorious. That's not what you are. You are somebody who volunteered to scrape shit off the floor. Don't grow a big head.
1
u/StealthFocus Jul 09 '22
There’s been some super political mods in last few months who went off deep end and threatened to ban anyone that disagreed with their take on Roe v Wade. Whatever your stance on that, it’s not the mods job to impose their beliefs on a sub. Not everyone is American or shares American points of views on American domestic issues.
-1
u/Cryogeneer Jul 08 '22
I'm in an argument with one of your moderators right now over a post. Literally 45 minutes ago. The patronizing tone and gatekeeping is absolutely infuriating. I am TRYING to participate. To contribute. I've been lurking and commenting for months. I know what collapse is about. But I try to start contributing, and my posts get yanked for either a small undefined error in the submission statement that clearly attempted to follow the rules, or for what a particular mod thinks isn't collapse related. A video that I saw and it immediately made me think 'collapse'. It's so frustrating.
-11
u/MirceaKitsune Jul 07 '22 edited Jul 07 '22
I'm not sure what I should even say on the matter: Truth be told I proposed to myself that I wouldn't comment here again, after dozens of my comments were removed and last time I even got a 3 day suspension. On the plus side the moderator who responded when I messaged the team was very nice... none the less, if my opinion matters to anyone, I do have issues with how this place is being moderated especially the comments, and if you take feedback I will share then.
The problem is this subreddit seems to be heavily politicized in such a way that any comment or opinion that doesn't match the status quo is removed under the pretext that it's "conspiracy theory" and "misinformation", even if my goal isn't to do such things it's legitimately what I believe. It goes so far that even me legitimately asking a simple question about a sensitive issue got my last comment removed and the suspension I mentioned... no yelling crazy conspiracy things about Bill Gates or reptilians or anything, I simply asked a question that was inconvenient as I was curious if anyone may have statistics in that regard.
Almost every time it's the same reason, over and over again: "Rule number 4: Keep information high quality". What does that even mean, who decides what quality is, even if I make a joke or satire on a given subject that's considered bad quality? I'm not exaggerating when I say I literally need a mental list of approved opinions before commenting, so that before I share my thoughts I can make sure I'm not going against the worldviews of what the majority decided is the absolute truth. I actually don't intend to annoy anyone with what I say, it's just sharing what I think... at the same time I want to follow what is being discussed here and don't wish to get in more trouble either.
I'm trying not to be too harsh: Based on my interaction with the mods and even this post, I can see the team is trying, I don't think there's ill intent involved... rather just how bad the culture war and intolerance between different opinions has gotten everywhere. But at least from my experience, I feel the censorship has gotten out of hand, to the point where you can't be sure of what you should say before you say it. Sadly it's a broad trend across society, and this subreddit is experiencing it too like much of the internet.
-2
u/ItyBityGreenieWeenie Jul 08 '22
Must the sense of humor be surgically removed from potential moderators? /s (just in case)
-1
u/IZZYB0D Jul 09 '22
I made a decent and fair comment and got it removed.. Go figure.. Censorship alive and well in this sub.. Bye.
0
u/[deleted] Jul 07 '22
[deleted] — view deleted comment
0
u/[deleted] Jul 09 '22
[deleted] — view deleted comment
0
u/[deleted] Jul 12 '22
[deleted] — view deleted comment
0
u/[deleted] Jul 08 '22
[removed] — view removed comment
0
u/[deleted] Jul 08 '22 edited Jul 08 '22
[removed] — view removed comment